Canada's parliament declares China's treatment of Uighurs 'genocide'

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India

Canada's House of Commons has voted overwhelmingly to declare China's treatment of its Uighur minority population a genocide.

The motion - which passed 266 to 0 - was supported by all opposition parties and a handful of lawmakers from the governing Liberal Party.

Prime Minister Justice Trudeau and most members of his cabinet abstained.

The motion makes Canada just the second country after the United States to recognise China's actions as genocide.

Lawmakers also voted to pass an amendment asking Canada to call on the International Olympic Committee to move the 2022 Winter Olympics from Beijing "if the Chinese government continues this genocide".
Mr Trudeau has so far been hesitant to label China's actions against the Uighur minority in Xinjiang a genocide, calling the term "extremely loaded" and saying further examination was needed before a decision could be made.

Just one member of his cabinet, Foreign Affairs Minister Marc Garneau, appeared in parliament for the vote. Speaking in the House of Commons, Mr Garneau said he had abstained "on behalf of the government of Canada".

Speaking ahead of the vote, opposition leader Erin O'Toole said the move was necessary to send a "clear and unequivocal signal that we will stand up for human rights and the dignity of human rights, even if it means sacrificing some economic opportunity".

In an open letter to Mr Trudeau earlier this month asking him to "stand up to China", Mr O'Toole noted the recent banning of BBC World News from China - a decision that followed a BBC report alleging systematic rape, sexual abuse and torture in China's "re-education" camps in Xinjiang.

Monday's non-binding motion marks the latest escalation in Canada-China relations, which have soured over recent years.

At the weekend, China's ambassador to Canada Cong Peiwu told the Canadian Press that the motion was "interfering in [China's] domestic affairs".

"We firmly oppose that because it runs counter to facts," he said. "There's nothing like genocide happening in Xinjiang at all."

Rights groups believe that China has detained up to a million Uighurs over the past few years in what the state defines as "re-education camps".

BBC investigations suggest that Uighurs are being used as forced labour.

Canada's symbolic motion does not lay out next steps, but says the Canadian government needs to follow the lead of its US neighbours.

Both the current and former US Secretaries of State, Anthony Blinken and Mike Pompeo, have declared that China's policies against Uighur Muslims and other ethnic minorities in its western Xinjiang region constitute genocide.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Warnings issued and thread ban issued for trolling to certain member for off-topic spam.

I advise other members to not meme etc when replying to him as he is doing his typical tactic.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Some days back as the vote-session approached (Feb 20th), interview with Mehmet Tohti, prominent Uighur rights activist here in Canada:

Mr. Tohti has not been able to speak to his mother (in PRC) since 2016...has received cruel messages from CCP regarding her status, and does not know location/condition of her and most of his relatives there.

More details on the passing of the motion (Feb 22nd) and condition+situation of Uighurs with Mr. Tohti (after the motion passed) and also one of the liberal party MPs (Sameer Zuberi) that voted (and didnt officially/non-officially abstain unlike other half of his party and its leadership):


Cannot begin to think how being in his shoes and those like him (Mr Tohti) would feel like.

The House of Commons approved a motion accusing the Chinese government of committing a genocide against the Uighur minority. The vote was 266 in favour and zero opposed; Trudeau and the Liberal cabinet abstained.

This is and has been (IMO) shameful performance by our prime minister + cabinet on this issue in copping out and not supporting the 266 (all the opposition party MPs and about half of the liberal party MPs) parliament majority that voted.

Though I cannot say I am totally surprised given earlier vague mumblings he has made on the matter, and that being the executive he has to weigh geopolitical factors and consequences (investment from PRC into Canada has been sizeable lately and there is the "two michaels" hostage issue).

Reference: There are 338 MPs in total....so its about 266/338 = 79% support rate for this motion in parliament.

Thankfully it is good to see that not one MP voted against and only 2 MPs formally abstained (they will be scrutinised)...most liberal MPs abstained unofficially (shameful, this will bear scrutiny).

Big props to conservative party to get the ball rolling on this motion and forming consensus with their political rivals NDP (who are also in opposition)...and visually demonstrating (to Canadian public) which MPs and parties mean what they say in the end w.r.t this issue in a basic way.

Earlier statement (before vote) from conservative party leader:
They got about 54% of liberals in end to support the bill openly....but PM+cabinet stayed away shamefully.

The vote to lobby IOC to move 2022 winter olympics away from PRC (if it does not stop what its doing to Uighurs) passed 229 - 29.

Those 29 MPs that voted against will all be scrutinised too.

With these motions and vote results, pressure will mount upon PM Trudeau and Liberal Party going forward to clarify their position and take a firm stance.

Hopefully more countries in EU/europe/developed world now follow precedence set by USA (strongly bipartisan) and now Canada (bipartisan to lesser degree) on this matter w.r.t their legislative bodies at the minimum.

Canada should also take more meaningful actions w.r.t imports (sourced from uighur forced labour camps), following the (recent) US lead on this.

Canada must push for access for on-site investigation with western peers consensus and help of Turkey and Kazkahstan (w.r.t Uighur refugees there) as Mr. Zuberi said in 2nd vid.

This all of course needs PM + Cabinet to get on board firmly with the political consensus in the legislature...and the requisite commitees and bill formation.

It cannot be left to be non-binding motion...actual bills need to come about now.

As much pressure needs to be also put on American legislators and Biden admin w.r.t magnitsky act adoption w.r.t sanctions on specific CCP individuals involved.

This has come up for discussion at several junctures by Mr. Bill Browder himself.

Canada and EU have similar legislations passed or are under consideration....these should also be implemented ASAP w.r.t individuals responsible for perpetrating crimes on Uighur people at such collective level.

@Joe Shearer @VCheng @Sinan @xenon5434 @Madokafc @Vergennes @Costin84 @AlphaMike @Saithan @Fuzuli NL @anmdt @T-123456 @Deliorman @Jackdaws @UkroTurk @Kartal1 @Paro et al.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Chinese Ambassador reaction (for anyone interested in the other perspective, in case you never heard any of it before):

No surprise comments on all these videos are turned off on youtube.
BTW someone need to push youtube so we at least know who turned off comments option when that is done for a video...(i.e the publisher or youtube).
 

VCheng

Committed member
Think Tank Analyst
Joined
Sep 4, 2020
Messages
278
Reaction score
291
Points
63
Canada and EU have similar legislations passed or are under consideration....these should also be implemented ASAP w.r.t individuals responsible for perpetrating crimes on Uighur people at such collective level.

It will be interesting to see how far China can be pushed in this matter.
 

Huelague

Contributor
Joined
Sep 11, 2020
Messages
716
Reaction score
990
Points
93
Genocide is a legal term. Why governments decide about that?
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India

Jackdaws

Contributor
Joined
Nov 24, 2020
Messages
484
Reaction score
264
Points
63
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
Chinese Ambassador reaction (for anyone interested in the other perspective, in case you never heard any of it before):

No surprise comments on all these videos are turned off on youtube.
BTW someone need to push youtube so we at least know who turned off comments option when that is done for a video...(i.e the publisher or youtube).
It's the publisher.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
It's the publisher.

Yeah I looked into the fine print a bit more, you are correct. Good to know. The Youtube closure of it looks different when they do it.
 

GoatsMilk

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 21, 2020
Messages
306
Reaction score
930
Points
93
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
The anglo-american world and china are in conflict, its natural that such an open and obvious genocide will be used against China. However for Turkey efforts should be made to rescue these people. The conflict between the anglo american world and china is only going to escalate, it is none of Turkeys business, they deserve each other. But the safety of the Uighur people must be settled.
 

Nein2.0

Experienced member
Joined
Aug 27, 2020
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
3,733
Points
113
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Uygurs were oppressed for decades now all of a sudden people started caring because the Tibetans have gone old fashioned.

Im against China why were the Uygurs ignored this whole time?? When it came to the Tibetans the Uygurs were ignored now its opposite.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Uygurs were oppressed for decades now all of a sudden people started caring because the Tibetans have gone old fashioned.

Im against China why were the Uygurs ignored this whole time?? When it came to the Tibetans the Uygurs were ignored now its opposite.

Well if you listen to Mr. Tohti, he came to Canada in 1998 itself and has been highlighting the human rights problem. Lot of uighur testimony itself talks about the situation really taking a turn in the last decade or so....that makes it stand out compared to previous period (corellates with the re-education camps evidence too).

Have to remember during cold war the whole area was isolated to begin with (as PRC itself was isolated from western world + economy etc)....and PRC could not push itself around in such draconian way (on specific minority as opposed to entire population like in GLF and cultural rev etc) given the threat imposed by USSR to the north and west....and less than ideal relations with the US/West too.

It has really been in the recent timeframe (after cold war ended and china opened up economically) there is indisputable evidence from remote sensing and witness + refugee testimony from uighurs (and the leaked PRC, CCP govt documents) w.r.t the "re-education" camps and the genocidal policies implemented.....that make this situation stand out far more from the more regular human rights problems found world over (in both developing and developed world).

In Tibet there is simply no remote sensing evidence for the mass expansion of camps to re-educate them, since for most part their suppression was achieved over the cold war era (esp given cultural revolution brutality) to a more pacified (w.r.t to CCP) state (since they number just 3 million people or so, most concentrated in a few valleys).

In hindsight, Stalin/USSR should have intervened in Turkestan and not let Mao into the area (when mao was very weak)....and British should also have formalised a treaty with Qing empire too about Tibet being buffer independent state in perpetuity too etc...that would have allowed independent India to continue enforcement of such.

But we got to work with world we have now.
 

Nein2.0

Experienced member
Joined
Aug 27, 2020
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
3,733
Points
113
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Well if you listen to Mr. Tohti, he came to Canada in 1998 itself and has been highlighting the human rights problem. Lot of uighur testimony itself talks about the situation really taking a turn in the last decade or so....that makes it stand out compared to previous period (corellates with the re-education camps evidence too).

Have to remember during cold war the whole area was isolated to begin with (as PRC itself was isolated from western world + economy etc)....and PRC could not push itself around in such draconian way (on specific minority as opposed to entire population like in GLF and cultural rev etc) given the threat imposed by USSR to the north and west....and less than ideal relations with the US/West too.

It has really been in the recent timeframe (after cold war ended and china opened up economically) there is indisputable evidence from remote sensing and witness + refugee testimony from uighurs (and the leaked PRC, CCP govt documents) w.r.t the "re-education" camps and the genocidal policies implemented.....that make this situation stand out far more from the more regular human rights problems found world over (in both developing and developed world).

In Tibet there is simply no remote sensing evidence for the mass expansion of camps to re-educate them, since for most part their suppression was achieved over the cold war era (esp given cultural revolution brutality) to a more pacified (w.r.t to CCP) state (since they number just 3 million people or so, most concentrated in a few valleys).

In hindsight, Stalin/USSR should have intervened in Turkestan and not let Mao into the area (when mao was very weak)....and British should also have formalised a treaty with Qing empire too about Tibet being buffer independent state in perpetuity too etc...that would have allowed independent India to continue enforcement of such.

But we got to work with world we have now.

Communist China should have been stopped ages ago what a shame!!!

That we allowed this monster to grow. They won the civil war, they took tibet and east turkistan.

Now they built themselves an economy with Western help all our jobs got outsourced to China. On top of that they built nukes.

What a shame to be honest. For decades they grew and nobody wants to face them because it will lead to a war if not a World War.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Communist China should have been stopped ages ago what a shame!!!

That we allowed this monster to grow. They won the civil war, they took tibet and east turkistan.

Now they built themselves an economy with Western help all our jobs got outsourced to China. On top of that they built nukes.

What a shame to be honest. For decades they grew and nobody wants to face them because it will lead to a war if not a World War.

Yup I find western world hypocritical in many ways. They have indulged in human rights violations in middle east (on fake evidence w.r.t Iraq WMD)....all through that time they also helped build up PRC to what it is in some very short-sighted way (they both assumed PRC people cannot level up and stay as cheap wage stuff only etc and also assumed that somehow PRC turns into some less draconian entity after what it had done). It was all part of globalist haze of winning the cold war and deciding to reward PRC in some way since they did their bit to help w.r.t USSR in 2nd half of cold war etc.

US PNTR was signed literally while the blood stains where still quite fresh in tianenmen, ridiculous how hypocritical western govts are and how greedy+dumb wallstreet (And all the donor groups) are.

It is quite unimaginable to me what west has done w.r.t Turkey (NATO ally) for example (this goes well past Erdogan own short-sighted mistakes)...as direct result of this quagmire set up to turkey's south too.

Now we have to deal with this BS going forward....I don't let western apologists and virtue signallers off the hook when they try to act all uppity about this (PRC w.r.t uighurs). I give them a dose of their culpability in all of this....they have to coldly hold themselves to account on it to have any chance of dealing with it well going forward.
 

Nein2.0

Experienced member
Joined
Aug 27, 2020
Messages
1,644
Reaction score
3,733
Points
113
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Yup I find western world hypocritical in many ways. They have indulged in human rights violations in middle east (on fake evidence w.r.t Iraq WMD)....all through that time they also helped build up PRC to what it is in some very short-sighted way (they both assumed PRC people cannot level up and stay as cheap wage stuff only etc and also assumed that somehow PRC turns into some less draconian entity after what it had done). It was all part of globalist haze of winning the cold war and deciding to reward PRC in some way since they did their bit to help w.r.t USSR in 2nd half of cold war etc.

US PNTR was signed literally while the blood stains where still quite fresh in tianenmen, ridiculous how hypocritical western govts are and how greedy+dumb wallstreet (And all the donor groups) are.

It is quite unimaginable to me what west has done w.r.t Turkey (NATO ally) for example (this goes well past Erdogan own short-sighted mistakes)...as direct result of this quagmire set up to turkey's south too.

Now we have to deal with this BS going forward....I don't let western apologists and virtue signallers off the hook when they try to act all uppity about this (PRC w.r.t uighurs). I give them a dose of their culpability in all of this....they have to coldly hold themselves to account on it to have any chance of dealing with it well going forward.

You know in Australia a lot of people once warned that China was going to get strong in the future. Instead our politicians backed by think tanks turned a blind eye to it because of their love of money and their stupid arrogance not to mention even using the race card by saying stop being racist now China's influence is already in the Australian government I mean you had politicians who met with ccp officials in private which ASIO our intelligence agency of Australia uncovered which led to some resigning not to mention a University student in Brisbane got suspended because he protested against the CCP.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Canada Moderator
India Moderator
Joined
Aug 23, 2020
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
5,886
Points
113
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
What an inept weak PM we have. 😡

 
Top Bottom