Indonesia Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
7,806
Reactions
21 12,403
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
In the end those systems are an over kill and premium line for a patrol boat with these features. Bofors 57mm could have been better on OPV or PKRs. This one could have received SIMBAD-RC + a cheaper cannon (bofors 40) + a cheaper E/O.

I think the navy must consider at least 1 SIMBAD RC launcher in the stern if they decide not to continue with NG-18 CIWS.

or this:


Thales_RAPIDSeaGuardian_CIWS_Euronaval_2016_news.jpg
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
652
Reactions
4 627
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
I think the navy must consider at least 1 SIMBAD RC launcher in the stern if they decide not to continue with NG-18 CIWS.

or this:


Thales_RAPIDSeaGuardian_CIWS_Euronaval_2016_news.jpg
when 76mm is too big and 40mm a little bit to small, then 57mm is perfectly fit

i think by having one 57mm gun is enough because it can do multirole task, anti-surface and anti-air weapon,

the armament KCR 625 quite more or less like this then,
1x 57mm
2x2 SSM
2x 12,7mm

and i think that is quite decent, even JMSDF Hayabusa-class and ROKN Yoon Youngha are not so meriah mainannya
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
2,942
Reactions
3 2,524
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
when 76mm is too big and 40mm a little bit to small, then 57mm is perfectly fit

i think by having one 57mm gun is enough because it can do multirole task, anti-surface and anti-air weapon,

the armament KCR 625 quite more or less like this then,
1x 57mm
2x2 SSM
2x 12,7mm

and i think that is quite decent, even JMSDF Hayabusa-class and ROKN Yoon Youngha are not so meriah mainannya
At least the newest version is better equipped.


640px-Mubarraz-%28P141%29-130521-N-GZ984-250-crop.jpg

Only 44 m but have Ashm, SAM, otmel 76 mm and the speed is 40 knots. Very different from ours.
 

R4duga

Experienced member
Messages
1,670
Reactions
2 2,367
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Crotale?
The real kapal cepat
those are Sadral.

a well armed Small patrol craft usually need to sacrifice their endurance range (should have been like this since they aren't going to go far away from the coastline).

Finnish Hamina would be a good example of well armed patrol craft.
1638761483409.png
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

when 76mm is too big and 40mm a little bit to small, then 57mm is perfectly fit

i think by having one 57mm gun is enough because it can do multirole task, anti-surface and anti-air weapon,

the armament KCR 625 quite more or less like this then,
1x 57mm
2x2 SSM
2x 12,7mm

and i think that is quite decent, even JMSDF Hayabusa-class and ROKN Yoon Youngha are not so meriah mainannya

Lets we think a while, i mean look at this ambassador 3.

images (7).jpeg


600 tons weight, 63 m leght, 10 m width, 41 knots, 2.000 nmi, 8 days, 36 Sailors.

Combo with Otmel 76, Phalax, RIM, 8x Harpoon.

Such an overkill, even almost surpass Corvette. Not to mention it's use 4 engine.
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
652
Reactions
4 627
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Lets we think a while, i mean look at this ambassador 3.

View attachment 36723

600 tons weight, 63 m leght, 10 m width, 41 knots, 2.000 nmi, 8 days, 36 Sailors.

Combo with Otmel 76, Phalax, RIM, 8x Harpoon.

Such an overkill, even almost surpass Corvette. Not to mention it's use 4 engine.
you want something more? its still on 60 meter class


DIMDEX_2018_Fincantieri_Unveils_Qatari_Navy_OPV_Design_3.jpeg

"In terms of weapon systems, the OPVs will actually be closer to FACM (Fast Attack Craft Missile) or even light corvettes: The OPVs will be fitted with a 76mm main gun by Leonardo, 8x VLS cells for VL MICA surface to air missiles (by MBDA), two Marlins 30mm remote weapon stations (Leonardo), 4x Exocet MM40 Block III (MBDA) anti-ship missiles."

and too much electronic to be on the list so i put down the link

while me seeing this musherib class, me start crying in rupiah :"

and its true, diatas langit masi ada langit
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
As long as it Fast, and can do Attack it will be ok.

As an example If Klewang II is good enough to speeding up to 30+ knot, then Put 4x AShM and 1 CIWS for me is considered enough for a FAC.

Putting Such gun other than AShM in FAC is considered a self defence mechanism
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom