McCool
Contributor
- Messages
- 685
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
The russians think they could get away with this aren't they?
Live Conflict Ukraine-Russia War
- Thread starter Kartal1
- Start date
The russians think they could get away with this aren't they?
- Messages
- 3,041
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Ukraine Through Russia’s Eyes
Nick Reynolds and Dr Jack Watling25 February 2022
The Kremlin’s pre-invasion research suggested Ukraine was fertile ground for subversion, but the shock of war may transform Ukrainians’ willingness to resist in unpredictable ways.
While the Russian military is capable of defeating the Ukrainian armed forces, the prospect of occupying a hostile country constitutes a major gamble for Moscow. In order to accurately assess why President Vladimir Putin concluded that he could invade and occupy Ukraine, it is necessary to consider how Russian officials understood the Ukrainian population and its political, economic and social structure on the eve of the invasion. This article analyses social surveys conducted across Ukraine in February 2022 and commissioned by the Ninth Directorate of the Fifth Service of Russia’s Federal Security Service (FSB). These indicate how Russian officials viewed Ukraine as they were planning their invasion, and what this might mean for the trajectory of a Russian occupation.
The KGB’s Fifth Service had been responsible for counterintelligence in the territories of the former Soviet Union. When the KGB became the FSB in the 1990s, and these territories became independent states, the Fifth Service transitioned into an intelligence agency targeting Russia’s neighbours. Its Department for Operational Information is responsible for compiling data on Russia’s ‘near abroad’, and the Ninth Directorate, targeting Ukraine, has been overseeing the gathering of intelligence on Ukrainian society to inform Russian decision-making. Its February 2022 surveys reveal much about how the Kremlin assessed the resilience of Ukrainian society.
Ukraine in February 2022
According to the polling data, Ukrainians in early February were, by and large, pessimistic about the future and apathetic about politics, and did not trust politicians, political parties or the majority of Ukraine’s domestic institutions. Their main concerns were overwhelmingly inflation and the cost of living, with both perceived to be rising.Trust in the office of the president sat at 27%, with 67% distrustful of the presidency. President Volodymyr Zelenskiy had poor approval ratings at −34, but a high proportion of Ukrainians polled still professed that they would vote for him over other candidates. The Ukrainian Army, both regular and reserve, was highly trusted, with 68% of the population supportive, as were military veterans, while regional and municipal governments were comparatively well-trusted with over 40% of the population having a favourable opinion of them. However, other institutions enjoyed approval figures that ranged from mediocre to poor, including the police at 28% and domestic security services at 23%. Trust in the Rada – the Ukrainian parliament – and in political parties was abysmal, at 11% and 8% respectively. And when it came to willingness to serve in the military or otherwise resist a foreign invasion, 40% of respondents stated that they would not defend Ukraine.
The population notably had a high opinion of the military’s capabilities, although this is worryingly divergent from the assessment of professional military analysts. 51% of respondents believed that the Ukrainian Army had the capacity to repel an invasion force, despite Ukrainian technical capabilities being decisively outmatched and outnumbered by those deployed by Russia. They also for the most part did not believe that the Russian military build-up – of which 90% of those surveyed were aware – would necessarily result in invasion. These expectations are in the process of being shattered.
Other points of Russian leverage were also identified in the survey conducted for the FSB. More than half the Ukrainian population was assessed as having a favourable opinion of the church, despite those parishes which consider themselves a part of the Moscow Patriarchy’s jurisdiction being heavily penetrated by Russian intelligence. The extensive mapping of how different political figures and parties were perceived also provided the FSB with an indication of which ones to prioritise for co-option, coercion, marginalisation or elimination. Notably, when looked at from a national perspective, the Ukrainian population appeared to possess only a moderate level of resolve. However, when broken down by region – north, south, east and west – it becomes clear that attitudes in the south and east of the country exhibit much less faith in the Ukrainian state.
Implications for Russian Operations
These trends will have been factored into Russia’s invasion planning, and the implications are worth considering. It is notable that Putin, in his pre-invasion televised address, spoke extensively about the failures of Ukrainian governance in terms that mirrored the picture painted by the FSB’s surveys. The institutions in which Ukrainians have the most faith – the armed forces – are precisely those against which Russia can act most rapidly and decisively. High casualties and the isolation of Ukrainian military units short of air cover may see Russian armoured thrusts bypass centres of resistance, disabusing the population of their military’s defensive capacity.In Ukraine’s cities, there is also the question of popular mobilisation and unconventional resistance. However, even here, regional disparities are of higher importance. While a minority of Ukrainians surveyed by the FSB said they would not defend Ukraine, this population was disproportionately concentrated in the south and east of the country. Furthermore, among those who said they would not fight, around half indicated that in the event of war they would ‘adapt and survive’, suggesting that large parts of the population in the south and east of Ukraine would be open to complying with the occupation authorities if they could provide services.
By contrast, Kyiv, the capital, came across as markedly different, and the research suggests it will be vital ground for the success or failure of Russia’s war plans. Trust in civil society and voluntary institutions was deemed high, and President Zelenskiy’s call for mobilisation will see large numbers of military-aged adults armed. However, as we have written previously, it is civil society organisations that Russian Special Forces, directed by the FSB, intend to ruthlessly target. If the Russian military can displace the Ukrainian government in Kyiv, the FSB has little evidence to suggest that citizens of Eastern Ukraine will be sorry to see the political parties and politicians replaced.
If those who planned Russia’s invasion took the survey seriously, its impact on a Russian occupation strategy is clear. Russia stands a good chance of destroying Ukraine’s trusted institutions and replacing those that are less trusted. New occupation administrations would also be well-advised to use the language of anti-corruption and to rely on the supply of services as a means of coercing swayable parts of the population, a task perhaps made easier by the fact that 44% of the population was expecting to struggle to pay utility bills at the beginning of February. Putin has already used this language in his public addresses, but given the endemic corruption in Russia and the impoverishment of occupied Donetsk and Luhansk since 2014, it must be doubted whether Russian occupation administrations will convince the population of their ability to deliver good governance. While the FSB may have identified opportunities to leverage Ukrainian society, that does not mean the Russians will be able to follow through.
Putin Rolls the Dice
The problem with surveys of social attitudes is that they are a snapshot of a moment in time. In stable conditions, trends in the data can suggest the trajectory of public sentiment, and the FSB has social trends data for Ukraine going back as far as 2006. But a seismic shift of context can cause major variations in sentiment and attitudes. Air attacks, even when limited to precision strikes on military targets, have historically been perceived extremely negatively by civilian populations subjected to them, who may also not fully understand the difference between area bombardment and military targeting. This often inspires intense hatred of the attacker and stiffens the resolve to resist. Likewise, military casualties in the face of an enemy ground invasion can make a population more determined to resist, so long as resistance does not appear hopeless. Ukraine’s small but symbolically important tactical victories like the retaking of Antonov airport gain a wider significance when looked at in this light.If Russia hoped that shock and awe in the destruction of the Ukrainian military might deter resistance, historical experience points to the opposite result. Thus, while the FSB survey may have been accurate in measuring opinions at the time it was conducted, it told the Russians little about how sentiments would evolve in the aftermath of an invasion.
The FSB-commissioned surveys also highlighted the traditional regional disparity in Ukraine between the eastern and western parts of the country. The FSB’s Ninth Directorate has mapped out occupation administrations for oblasts (regions) east of the Dnieper, but it has not done so west of the river, other than for Kyiv. And yet, if Russia only has a weak hold on the west of the country, the western parts could remain a long-term vector for resistance groups that will continue to contest Russia’s invasion.
Given the significant gamble revealed by Russia’s own assessments of the human terrain in which it is operating, it is evident that occupation could prove exceedingly difficult. Furthermore, if Russia finds that it is facing stiff resistance and insurgent attacks, it is likely to ramp up the use of firepower in urban areas. While this may remove tactical obstacles, it is unlikely to win the trust of a politically distrustful population. If Russia cannot prevent a prolonged insurgency commanded from Western Ukraine, it is possible that Russian forces may become stretched, increasing their vulnerability and presenting Putin with the prospect of a bloody failure. If the examples of Chechnya and Syria are any guide, Russian planners will likely transition from promising good governance to applying ruthless repression.
This article is based on documents commissioned by Russian intelligence and seen by the authors in the original. The authors were granted access to these papers by the Ukrainian authorities, and have taken all reasonable measures to verify the authenticity of the documents. Pictures of the documents are kept on file but reproduction is withheld, to protect the identity of the persons involved.
The views expressed in this Commentary are the author’s, and do not represent those of RUSI or any other institution.
Ukraine Through Russia’s Eyes
The Kremlin’s pre-invasion research suggested Ukraine was fertile ground for subversion, but the shock of war may transform Ukrainians’ willingness to resist in unpredictable ways.
rusi.org
- Messages
- 232
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Russian site "Military review" https://topwar.ru
The use of TOS "Solntsepyok" leaves no chance for militants in the workshop complex of the Mariupol enterprise "Azovstal"
The operation to liberate Mariupol continues. And the more civilians leave the city, the more information the command of the RF Armed Forces and the People’s Militia of the DPR has on the deployment of firing points of Ukrainian armed formations, including Azov militants (*an extremist organization banned in Russia).
One of the locations for the Azov workers* is the territory of the Azovstal plant. This is a huge space with dozens of workshops, where it is difficult to get from one site to another without transport. Azovstal has a large number of underground structures, many of which have turned into headquarters and locations for extremist groups.
To neutralize the enemy in such conditions, various weapons are used.
So, footage appeared on the network with the destruction of the places of deployment of the Azov militants in the shops of Azovstal using heavy flamethrower systems. We are talking about TOS "Solntsepyok", which, with their 220-mm ammunition, are capable of causing volumetric explosions with inevitable damage to the enemy in manpower and equipment.
At one time, the commander of the federal forces in Chechnya and Dagestan, Colonel-General Alexander Troshev, noted that heavy flamethrower systems are a weapon option with particular accuracy and efficiency, which makes it possible to achieve success in an operation where other weapons were powerless.
On the footage, you can see volumetric explosions taking place in one of the Azovstal workshop complexes and leaving no chance for the militants who have settled there. Realizing that being in one place at one time in large groups is fatal, the militants of the Ukrainian national battalions resort to the tactics of dispersal - mainly in the residential areas of Mariupol. At the same time, among their main tasks are not only attempts to resist the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation and the NM of the DPR, but also shelling of humanitarian corridors in order to prevent the civilian population from leaving the city. After all, the more people leave Mariupol, the less the militants have the opportunity to use human shields. In this regard, the “Azovites”* more often retreat to those quarters where civilians remain, in fact using them as hostages.
The use of TOS "Solntsepyok" leaves no chance for militants in the workshop complex of the Mariupol enterprise "Azovstal"
The operation to liberate Mariupol continues. And the more civilians leave the city, the more information the command of the RF Armed Forces and the People’s Militia of the DPR has on the deployment of firing points of Ukrainian armed formations, including Azov militants (*an extremist organization banned in Russia).
One of the locations for the Azov workers* is the territory of the Azovstal plant. This is a huge space with dozens of workshops, where it is difficult to get from one site to another without transport. Azovstal has a large number of underground structures, many of which have turned into headquarters and locations for extremist groups.
To neutralize the enemy in such conditions, various weapons are used.
So, footage appeared on the network with the destruction of the places of deployment of the Azov militants in the shops of Azovstal using heavy flamethrower systems. We are talking about TOS "Solntsepyok", which, with their 220-mm ammunition, are capable of causing volumetric explosions with inevitable damage to the enemy in manpower and equipment.
At one time, the commander of the federal forces in Chechnya and Dagestan, Colonel-General Alexander Troshev, noted that heavy flamethrower systems are a weapon option with particular accuracy and efficiency, which makes it possible to achieve success in an operation where other weapons were powerless.
On the footage, you can see volumetric explosions taking place in one of the Azovstal workshop complexes and leaving no chance for the militants who have settled there. Realizing that being in one place at one time in large groups is fatal, the militants of the Ukrainian national battalions resort to the tactics of dispersal - mainly in the residential areas of Mariupol. At the same time, among their main tasks are not only attempts to resist the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation and the NM of the DPR, but also shelling of humanitarian corridors in order to prevent the civilian population from leaving the city. After all, the more people leave Mariupol, the less the militants have the opportunity to use human shields. In this regard, the “Azovites”* more often retreat to those quarters where civilians remain, in fact using them as hostages.
- Messages
- 232
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
People of the Donetsk People's Republic gave an interview to a Belarusian travel blogger (He visited Haiti, Afghanistan, Pakistan and other countries). They are afraid to openly give interviews, so they ask to cover their faces and change their voices.
- There was no Russophobia in Ukraine until 2014.
- Until 2014, 60% spoke Russian, 40% spoke Ukrainian. But after 2014, the Ukrainian language was banned.
- There were no Nazis. It's all Russian propaganda. They showed fake pictures. We, of course, do not have independent media.
- The girl is pro-Russian. She also says that there was no harassment. But during the Maidan, the revolution of 2014, one politician spoke out that from now on all documentation will be in Ukrainian. She also says that the Ukrainian authorities glorified Stepan Bandera, who in 1945 killed innocent people. Ukraine is no longer the Ukraine that I loved, it is already forbidden to express a pro-Russian opinion there. Nobody wants war, but it was impossible to do otherwise.
- Nobody wants war. Most of the men in Donetsk hide because they don't understand why they go to war. In the last 5-6 years there were no explosions, yes, people lived in the unrecognized republic, but they lived relatively calmly.
- The Russian authorities have been shouting for 8 years that we are being bombed, but for 8 years they did absolutely nothing for us. That is, for them (Moscow) we were citizens of Ukraine.
- Of course, there are people who support the war, who are in a certain information field, who watch TV, who have no acquaintances in Ukraine, no Internet.
- People are offended that they were shot at.
- For 8 years, they stopped studying the history of Ukraine, the Ukrainian language.
- On the street, people are taken away and forcibly sent to war. I've been at home for 20 days now, I don't want to go out
- Now the youth does not want to fight. They do not understand what they will fight for, they do not want to die. - For 8 years Donetsk ceased to function. Our industry is not developing in any way, everything is stolen from us. - Even rolled back. Some factories work at a percentage of 5 of their capacities, some do not work at all. - The miners are a disaster. These are the guys who have become useless to anyone. - Since 2014, we have not elected anyone. There was not a single head whom we chose, there was not a single minister whom the people would choose.
- The average salary in Donetsk is about $130. People are forced to survive, but impregnated with propaganda, they believe in something, blindly believe. - For all these years, Ukraine continued to pay pensions to Donetsk pensioners, but Ukraine is still bad.
- All this time Ukraine has been bombing civilians, is this a fact? Yes, a fact, but there were a lot of provocations for anger. They also need to justify their actions. I am more than sure that in 8 years not only civilians from our side, but also civilians from Ukraine are dying.
- The Russian world started the war in 2014. The Russian army came here and shelled Ukraine. All people know this very well. People in Donbas don’t come out on their own to protest there. That is, someone gave people an order, someone supported.
- People want to be part of Ukraine. Even the girl who is pro-Russian.
- There was no Russophobia in Ukraine until 2014.
- Until 2014, 60% spoke Russian, 40% spoke Ukrainian. But after 2014, the Ukrainian language was banned.
- There were no Nazis. It's all Russian propaganda. They showed fake pictures. We, of course, do not have independent media.
- The girl is pro-Russian. She also says that there was no harassment. But during the Maidan, the revolution of 2014, one politician spoke out that from now on all documentation will be in Ukrainian. She also says that the Ukrainian authorities glorified Stepan Bandera, who in 1945 killed innocent people. Ukraine is no longer the Ukraine that I loved, it is already forbidden to express a pro-Russian opinion there. Nobody wants war, but it was impossible to do otherwise.
- Nobody wants war. Most of the men in Donetsk hide because they don't understand why they go to war. In the last 5-6 years there were no explosions, yes, people lived in the unrecognized republic, but they lived relatively calmly.
- The Russian authorities have been shouting for 8 years that we are being bombed, but for 8 years they did absolutely nothing for us. That is, for them (Moscow) we were citizens of Ukraine.
- Of course, there are people who support the war, who are in a certain information field, who watch TV, who have no acquaintances in Ukraine, no Internet.
- People are offended that they were shot at.
- For 8 years, they stopped studying the history of Ukraine, the Ukrainian language.
- On the street, people are taken away and forcibly sent to war. I've been at home for 20 days now, I don't want to go out
- Now the youth does not want to fight. They do not understand what they will fight for, they do not want to die. - For 8 years Donetsk ceased to function. Our industry is not developing in any way, everything is stolen from us. - Even rolled back. Some factories work at a percentage of 5 of their capacities, some do not work at all. - The miners are a disaster. These are the guys who have become useless to anyone. - Since 2014, we have not elected anyone. There was not a single head whom we chose, there was not a single minister whom the people would choose.
- The average salary in Donetsk is about $130. People are forced to survive, but impregnated with propaganda, they believe in something, blindly believe. - For all these years, Ukraine continued to pay pensions to Donetsk pensioners, but Ukraine is still bad.
- All this time Ukraine has been bombing civilians, is this a fact? Yes, a fact, but there were a lot of provocations for anger. They also need to justify their actions. I am more than sure that in 8 years not only civilians from our side, but also civilians from Ukraine are dying.
- The Russian world started the war in 2014. The Russian army came here and shelled Ukraine. All people know this very well. People in Donbas don’t come out on their own to protest there. That is, someone gave people an order, someone supported.
- People want to be part of Ukraine. Even the girl who is pro-Russian.
- Messages
- 3,041
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
War is awful, and regardless of which side becomes the victor in the end, both sides suffer and experience pain one way or another.
Thanks for sharing.
Спасибо!
- Messages
- 232
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
I am not Russian. I am from the Turkic autonomy inside Russia
- Messages
- 1,522
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
- Messages
- 1,522
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Meanwhile rapes have been reported by Russian soldiers in Ukraine.
This killed russian soldier had condoms on him. His commanders probably promised him free Ukrainian bobs and vagene.
This killed russian soldier had condoms on him. His commanders probably promised him free Ukrainian bobs and vagene.
Protection is important especially against Ukrainian artillery.
Hexciter
Experienced member
- Messages
- 2,575
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Which region?
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Radar Interference Tracker:
A New Open Source Tool to Locate Active Military Radar Systems
https://www.bellingcat.com/resource...tool-to-locate-active-military-radar-systems/
Hexciter
Experienced member
- Messages
- 2,575
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Russians benefits from Orlan-10 UAV
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
I realy like this gorup of locals in "Chernihiv"
They able to ambush one supply convo yesterday
Today they able to ambush other ruski
Chernihiv partisans have destroyed a Russian "Tiger-M"
They able to ambush one supply convo yesterday
Today they able to ambush other ruski
Chernihiv partisans have destroyed a Russian "Tiger-M"
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Stolen russian BTR 702 from teenagers
Gone in 60 seconds.......
Gone in 60 seconds.......
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
somehting going on......................
russian Defence Minister Shoigu missed since nearly 2 weeks
russian Defence Minister Shoigu missed since nearly 2 weeks
Ecderha
Experienced member
- Messages
- 4,552
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Belarus unit fighting in Irpin western suburb of Kyiv alongside Ukraine army against russian occupation army
