Search results

  1. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Ya kalo gak mau dikorupsi suruh KPK dan BPK buat audit seluruh TNI, kalo berani. Simpel. Blockchain tertulis disana untuk E-Katalog, mengolah data pengadaan barang pemerintah, gitu aja. Orang heran kenapa negara begini dan begitu, tapi dibantu dijelasin tidak mau, tidak peduli.
  2. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Ya begitulah birokrasi, ada untuk ada, bukan untuk tujuannya. Suruh itu si Menkeu bikin skema pendanaan yang bisa buat pengadaan multi-years diluar anggaran tahunan. Wong dia sendiri yang bikin sistem semua urusan keuangan lembaga negara dibuat seragam, strukturnya dibuat sama, mekanisme...
  3. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Ini bukan "update", tapi udah jadi historical documentary
  4. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    F-18 fungsinya mirip dengan IFX, mestinya tidak terlalu perlu. F-15 bisa gantiin EW Growler. Wedgetail lebih urgent. F-15 masalahnya ada di biaya, terlalu mahal per airframe. Tapi punya kapabilitas buat EW dan sebagai fighter-bomber. Dilema, tapi ya mau bagaimana lagi.
  5. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Very good video, it shows how the war progressed in wargaming style animation
  6. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Just fortify and militarize the place. Honestly, this exercise sounds similar to the sentence "recovery of Hawaii occupied by enemy forces", which is pretty absurd. Hawaii won't be occupied by any foreign military forces, and neither should Natuna. The priority is to make the place unassailable...
  7. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    This book is a quite an informative take on the Japanese invasion of the Dutch East Indies Map of Japanese invasion route in Java: Some points that interested me: 1. Shock effect on opposing forces from mobile firepower. Tactically, the aggressive and mobile Japanese put the RNEI Army on...
  8. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Mengenai Negeri vs Swasta Ini dilema. Memang industri senjata swasta mestinya lebih didukung lagi karena jika mengandalkan BUMN saja, apalagi jika hanya perusahaan2 itu lagi, kapasitas produksi pasti gak akan bisa besar. Di sisi lain, doktrin orang2 pemerintah itu masih Negeri-sentris, apalagi...
  9. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Well, they got outmaneuvered by China in "economic funding". Like wth the US is only fast satset when the military-industrial complex is involved. Wth 150 million USD donation for entire ASEAN, 20 billion USD weapon package for Ukraine alone. Meanwhile, some Chinese BUMN banks and construction...
  10. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    I think we can simplify the idea by simply making "A battalion, that has more kompi bantuan of greater proportion compared to a regular infantry battalion, and especially equipped heavily with anti-tank weapons". Though tbh I kind of don't like the term "kompi bantuan" as if a single heavy...
  11. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    I mean such kompi is nearly half of the battalion's personnel and is an inseparable part of the battalion as a whole. So when upper-up guys want some AT capability, they will see that it is the battalion that has the capability and deploys them as a whole and not just the specific company or...
  12. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Well, I only propose a battalion, not so much "specializing" (implying capable of only one task), but simply being "equipped and organized well enough to have increased effectiveness against armored units" (dubbed AT battalion), because obviously a simple rifle platoon/ all rifle battalion is...
  13. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Firepower is the issue. I mean the idea of a composite force originated during the time of Napoleon when the Corps acted as a mini-army with so-called composite capability/ combined arms. The point is that each Corps unit can be flexible and able to act independently, hence increasing...
  14. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Benar, tapi konteksnya disini adalah skenario vs armored column melawan peer enemy, bukan melawan insurgent level threat. Jadi keperluan untuk firepower sudah sangat berbeda lagi, apalagi jika AT yang dimaksud adalah yang tipe berat, tidak bisa digunakan perorangan tapi penting jika lawannya...
  15. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    I know how a few hundred men look like, combined with all their equipment and vehicles, that's just one small stadium in size or so, I've seen a queue bigger than that. Honestly, a battalion is big? Name me a major military operation conducted with less than a battalion in size. Even a brigade...
  16. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    A battalion is not that big in terms of relative size, just a few hundred men. I don't think assigning a specific task to a battalion makes them inflexible, quite the contrary IMO. Of course, we can try giving all rifle units in the Army some form of AT weapon or have a dedicated AT platoon in...
  17. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    We need dedicated anti tank battalions really Tbh I was skeptical at first with "older" weapons like Carl Gustav and RPGs, as they have a small caliber and that "experts" on the internet really undermine their projected effectiveness against "invincible" tanks like Abrams and Merkava, or even...
  18. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    I think with this case, we know what China is thinking right now: island chains strategy is fragile, these "allied" countries can't always be politically influenced to stay in the US camp and their alignment can sway either way at any moment. So China will push more attempt at ruining the island...
  19. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Well, yes he is too scatterbrained for anything, attempted to study everything but missed more than half the points. Yeah, he's not good at focusing on one thing and drawing a conclusion. I think often if the topic is religion, people generally cannot differentiate between faith (subjective...
  20. RadenSudirman

    Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

    Btw are you Ice Flare?

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom