Live Conflict War in Afghanistan

Deliorman

Contributor
Messages
931
Reactions
5 3,722
Nation of residence
Bulgaria
Nation of origin
Bulgaria
And i say, even if that's all true. It's still American's fault as their trainers. They could have selected capable men as their commanders. You can create a capable fighting force from anyone. As i seen in the Turkish military.

Not that i'm saying it was the duty of Americans. Afghans should decide their fate not foreign powers. If they want to live in the middle-ages with backward fanatics in the power.... so, be it.

They could have... but Americans are out of touch with reality. Washington, CIA, the Pentagon is all being run by idiots without any knowledge neither on the geopolitics of the world nor on the realities in Afghanistan (or Iraq, Syria, Libya... even Turkey as we see daily). They think that by following their outdated text books, and throwing billions on something they will solve a problem. They see the world through their American Liberal or Neo-Con lens and that's it.

I am more than sure that if Turkish officers and generals were training the Afghan forces they would have made an 100 times better job than the Americans. Even without their resources the fact that Turks are closer to the region historically and to some extent culturally would have helped much more than supplying Humvees and Drones etc. :D
 

Jackdaws

Experienced member
Messages
2,759
Reactions
1 1,583
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
Very true. Burqas, Sati, killing of unborn girls are curse or were of the most of developing world and needed/needs European intervention.
Obviously not an exhaustive list - should including beheadings, forced incestuous marriages, kidnappings and forced conversions amongst others. If I am not mistaken the UK has a task force for its own citizens to deal with some of these issues.
 

Kaptaan

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
1,734
Reactions
4,073
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Pakistan
Both Taliban and those trained by US are Afghan nationals. We saw how Taliban mow down government forces. So, it basically means that Taliban is much more better than US in terms of training Afghan combat force.
With respect it's more than that. Typical Talib recruit is a volunteer. He does not join the movement for a monthly salary, uniform, regular food, pension or prospects of promotion. The Talib is foremost a deeply religious man and who has been conditioned or has iman depending on your POV. He fights for Allah and is prepared to lay his life down for the cause. Such a force is highly motivated, fearless and make great combat soldiers.

Whereas ANA recruit was just a guy looking for a secure wage and possibility of graft on the side - like selling US supplied equipment etc. He was in fact a mercenery of a foreign power and Afghan in name only.

He was the Quisling.
 

Jackdaws

Experienced member
Messages
2,759
Reactions
1 1,583
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
5000 US troops on the ground assisted by 1000 troops from UK And now US is sending 1000 more troops (But no indian troops in sight while their embassy staff is still stranded their), to waste further resources on these no goods. US should Just take the Taliban's offer to keep desired troops max up to 1000 and should keep and operate their embassy.

Indians don't send troops as a matter of policy unless requested or if there is a surfeit of refugees pouring into India.
 

Kaptaan

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
1,734
Reactions
4,073
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Pakistan
Obviously not an exhaustive list - should including beheadings, forced incestuous marriages, kidnappings and forced conversions amongst others. If I am not mistaken the UK has a task force for its own citizens to deal with some of these issues.
I don't want to deviate from this thread but if I began it would exhaust the alphabet. I already covered the "S" so will leave it at that.
 

VCheng

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
488
Reactions
536
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Pakistan
They could have... but Americans are out of touch with reality. Washington, CIA, the Pentagon is all being run by idiots without any knowledge neither on the geopolitics of the world nor on the realities in Afghanistan (or Iraq, Syria, Libya... even Turkey as we see daily). They think that by following their outdated text books, and throwing billions on something they will solve a problem. They see the world through their American Liberal or Neo-Con lens and that's it.

Nothing in that rant is correct. The US military must fulfill what they are asked to do by the civilian leadership in pursuit of national interests. That is all.

(Let us all also keep in mind why USA needed to go to Afghanistan in the first place.)
 

VCheng

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
488
Reactions
536
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Pakistan
With respect it's more than that. Typical Talib recruit is a volunteer. He does not join the movement for a monthly salary, uniform, regular food, pension or prospects of promotion. The Talib is foremost a deeply religious man and who has been conditioned or has iman depending on your POV. He fights for Allah and is prepared to lay his life down for the cause. Such a force is highly motivated, fearless and make great combat soldiers.

Are the above fawning descriptives for the good or the bad Taliban?
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom