Search results

To get them back there? Nothing. To get justice? The guilty should be identified, arraigned and put on trial.

No.

This is the part of your post that was difficult to handle. EVERYBODY with a passing interest in Kashmir knew about this incident. Perhaps your point is that this 'EVERYBODY' is not that large a number of people, and you might be right in thinking that - I don't know. It was far from unknown...

It is to be hoped that you are right.....

Is this a carry-over from some other forum?

Are you referring to my post? Have you understood it in the first place? How do you @crixus and @Paro have a role in forming your opinions? Do frame your answers carefully.

Brilliant summary.

Two different things - first, Agnihotri, who tried to promote his films at NALSAR while I was teaching there, and so is a person whose views I have heard myself, and whom I have interrogated myself, is a piece of shit, and his movies are so focussed on hammering away at the fault lines in Indian...

@Amardeep Mishra Glad to see you posting here.

On a difficult note, that may not be understood even in a very sensitive group such as insaniyat, the impression sometimes that seeps across is that this is a deep Brahmin conspiracy, an Indian version of Q-ANON. The scumbag who made the film is an Agnihotri. OTOH, the lady who wrote the...

@T-123456

The Tragedy of ‘The Kashmir Files’ https://rollingstoneindia.com/the-tragedy-of-the-kashmir-files-film-review/ The Tragedy of ‘The Kashmir Files’ The recent history of the Kashmir and Kashmiris — Pandits and Muslims — deserves a humane film by an honest and skilled writer-director. This is...

I'd like to take these themes further, perhaps, as an example, exploring what combinations of doctrine, formations, equipment and training could enable us to fight a defensive offensive battle on all fronts, at the least possible . What would we call a front, for that matter? What could...

I don't know if I reproduced the review of the film on insaniyat. May I do that here?

I don't agree with two points here, but need to think the whole thing through.

Need to think about this. Incidentally I have a format that might stimulate discussion, that has elements of this but perhaps a different orientation. Perhaps later; at the moment, I am interested in thinking about this.

First reaction, I think I've got it, but will re-read it to be sure: This is what the Chinese PLA GF did to IV Corps in 1962 in NEFA (=Arunachal Pradesh)(=south Tibet). Gave me a chill to read your description. You were obviously defining things as you moved forward into the concept; if you...

I need to chew on this a bit. Fascinating!

AHA!

I liked the discussion but seriously wish you would tear my arguments to bits. Seriously.