If China invades Taiwan with force, Taiwan will definitely lose?

Freedomwld

Member
Messages
19
Reactions
2 21
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
China
Analyze the three keys to the success or failure of the war from the perspective of cross-strait military strength.

1.Taiwan’s strength
Although Taiwan is a small country compared with China, its strength cannot be underestimated. For example, in 2021, Taiwan's GDP ranked 22nd in the world. Taiwan's foreign exchange reserves in January 2022 were US$548.8 billion, ranking 5th in the world. Looking at the military rankings, due to different calculation standards of different organizations, although Taiwan's ranking fluctuates, it is roughly around 20th. Comparing this with Taiwan's population ranking 56th in the world and its land area ranking 137th, the performance of the above three "numbers" makes it no exaggeration to say that Taiwan is a "little giant".
Unfortunately, strength, weakness, and size are not absolutes, but contrasts. In terms of GDP in 2021, Taiwan's GDP is only 4.42% of China's. As for foreign exchange reserves, Taiwan’s is approximately 16.89% of China’s. According to the "2022 Military Power Ranking" released by the military website "Global Firepower", China ranks 3rd and Taiwan 21st.
Although there is a slight gap between "21" and "3", if we look at the same data, Ukraine ranks 42nd in the world and Russia ranks 2nd. Looking at the Russia-Ukraine war between "42" and "2", it seems that the signs are indistinguishable so far. If "numbers can speak", it seems that who will win and who will lose in the cross-strait war is still undecided.

2.The fighting spirit of Taiwanese people
Taiwan's military strength cannot be compared with China, but the victory or defeat of a war does not entirely depend on "hard power." For example, the United States has been fighting in Afghanistan for twenty years, but it was the Taliban who finally won. Compared with the US military, whether in terms of numbers or equipment, the Taliban are small and weak. Their victory depends on the tenacious fighting spirit of the Afghan people. In other words, if Taiwanese people have the same fighting spirit as Afghans, what does the CCP have to fear?

3. Don’t tease potential enemies
Fighting against gangsters, no matter whether I win or lose, I will always lose. This is the worst policy. What is the best policy? Put an end to the idea of robbers committing robbery. Or to be more precise, don't appeal to the gangster's greed, such as showing off his money, wearing a designer suit, or wearing a Rolex diamond watch. If the robber knew that he would not get the money he wanted by committing a crime, would he still commit a robbery?
Facing the possibility of military reunification, Taipei's main goal is to avoid war; and the first thing to avoid war is not to provoke the CCP and give Beijing an excuse to reunify. To achieve this goal, Taipei should actively create an atmosphere of "hope for peace and reunification", because hope will prevent despair. Once desperate, drastic measures may be taken. The definitions of "hope" and "atmosphere" are very unclear, and may even be just an illusion. However, if you can create expectations for your opponents, it can maintain the status quo.
 

legolas4444

Member
Messages
14
Reactions
8
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
It’s not that simple — while China has a much larger military, Taiwan has strong defenses, difficult terrain and possible international support, so any invasion would be extremely costly and far from a guaranteed win for Beijing.
 

slayer23

New member
Messages
2
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
It’s not that simple — while China has a much larger military, Taiwan has strong defenses, difficult terrain and possible international support, so any invasion would be extremely costly and far from a guaranteed win for Beijing.
First of all i dont see the point why would china even go for a tiny island makes no sense. China would rather just send some fighter jets over taiwan, taunt them a little and nothing else.

In worst case scenario china decides to invade i dont think much will happen, unless Japan and SK decide to join forces to stop the invasion but even then i think china will have a upper hand
 

Merzifonlu

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
772
Reactions
27 2,320
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
It all depends on how ruthless China is. If China doesn't care about civilian casualties, Taiwan won't be able to resist for long.
 

BaburKhan

Contributor
Messages
530
Reactions
6 1,197
Website
strategicreviewturkey.blogspot.com
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Germany
It all depends on how ruthless China is. If China doesn't care about civilian casualties, Taiwan won't be able to resist for long.


If China doesn't care about civilian Casualties, they would give the US the Reason to intervene. When News will reach the Public in the US about civilian Taiwanese Casualties, the public Support for an Intervention will increase.
 

Merzifonlu

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
772
Reactions
27 2,320
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
they would give the US the Reason to intervene.
The USA will be never intervene directly in that war. The USA's real goal is to drag countries like the Philippines, India, Taiwan, South Korea, and even Japan into war with China, and only engage China after it has become exhausted.

With an "expendable" Taiwan prepared to fight China and wear China down in the process, why would the USA rush to its rescue and risk engaging a resilient China? That seems to go against the broader strategy of great powers throughout all of history.
 
Last edited:

Azeri441

Contributor
Messages
460
Reactions
6 1,684
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Azerbaijan
It all depends if US can form a coalition to defend Taiwan, combined coalition of NATO + Australia, South Korea and Japan, can definitely defend Taiwan and destroy most of Chinese fleet.

However, if US has to defend Taiwan by itself then US might not have enough resources to defend Taiwan, specially at the scale China is advancing
 

Azeri441

Contributor
Messages
460
Reactions
6 1,684
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Azerbaijan
First of all i dont see the point why would china even go for a tiny island makes no sense. China would rather just send some fighter jets over taiwan, taunt them a little and nothing else.

In worst case scenario china decides to invade i dont think much will happen, unless Japan and SK decide to join forces to stop the invasion but even then i think china will have a upper hand

Thats because you don't understand the strategic importance of Taiwan, Taiwan is the center piece of 1st island chain containment of China, if they have Taiwan, then they secure open access to Pacific.
 

BaburKhan

Contributor
Messages
530
Reactions
6 1,197
Website
strategicreviewturkey.blogspot.com
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Germany
The USA will be never intervene directly in that war. The USA's real goal is to drag countries like the Philippines, India, Taiwan, South Korea, and even Japan into war with China, and only engage China after it has become exhausted.

With an "expendable" Taiwan prepared to fight China and wear China down in the process, why would the USA rush to its rescue and risk engaging a resilient China? That seems to go against the broader strategy of great powers throughout all of history.

Even in the Philipines, Japan and south Korea US Troops are deployed. China need to strike the military Infrastructure in these Countries in event of an War, this mean the US could be involved from the early beginning.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom