Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

schuimpjes

Experienced member
Messages
2,164
Reactions
3 1,398
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
The predecessor of BAIS had a name of PSiAD. During that time, Special Operation under the control of Psychological Warfare office was not weird, for example, early formation of US Army SF was under the Pentagon’s Psychological Warfare McClure’s office.
 

norman88

Committed member
Messages
169
Reactions
124
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Jujur agak kaget juga denger pemikiran bapak Jend satu ini, cukup diluar nalar statement2 nya😅

Beberapa statement dari beliau di podcast ini:

1. Jangan beli tank, beli drone aja lebih efektif, dan di laut juga bisa diawasi pakai drone lebih murah dari kapal (kaum droniyah garis keras ternyata 😆).

2. Anggaran pertahanan dibawah 1% GDP sudah cukup tidak perlu ditambah, karena ada sektor lain yg lebih memerlukan seperti sektor ekonomi.

3. Indonesia ada "kawan", saat diserang kenapa gak memanfaatkan mereka (lol 🤣).

 

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,599
Reactions
1 2,543
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Jujur agak kaget juga denger pemikiran bapak Jend satu ini, cukup diluar nalar statement2 nya😅

Beberapa statement dari beliau di podcast ini:

1. Jangan beli tank, beli drone aja lebih efektif, dan di laut juga bisa diawasi pakai drone lebih murah dari kapal (kaum droniyah garis keras ternyata 😆).

2. Anggaran pertahanan dibawah 1% GDP sudah cukup tidak perlu ditambah, karena ada sektor lain yg lebih memerlukan seperti sektor ekonomi.

3. Indonesia ada "kawan", saat diserang kenapa gak memanfaatkan mereka (lol 🤣).

poin ke-2 bisa diasumsikan pelemahan dari dalam kah ini?
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
492
Reactions
3 411
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
Jujur agak kaget juga denger pemikiran bapak Jend satu ini, cukup diluar nalar statement2 nya😅

Beberapa statement dari beliau di podcast ini:

1. Jangan beli tank, beli drone aja lebih efektif, dan di laut juga bisa diawasi pakai drone lebih murah dari kapal (kaum droniyah garis keras ternyata 😆).

2. Anggaran pertahanan dibawah 1% GDP sudah cukup tidak perlu ditambah, karena ada sektor lain yg lebih memerlukan seperti sektor ekonomi.

3. Indonesia ada "kawan", saat diserang kenapa gak memanfaatkan mereka (lol 🤣).

lah baru tahu, kenapa penggiat formil rada anu ama beliau kan soal ini, klo personal, intelektualitasnya mah banyak yg suka..
 

schuimpjes

Experienced member
Messages
2,164
Reactions
3 1,398
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
With Saif al-Adl under Iran house arrest, it is possible for Iran to just use him. Instead of seeking refuge to Pakistan like Osama post 9/11, he and some went west to Iran, which we can see now, a better place for hiding than Pakistan.

Started during Soviet Invasion of Afghanistan, when many people went to Afghanistan, even Grand Mufti of Saudi, Bin Baz, also encouraged people to went there. Saudi, Filipino, Egyptian, Indonesian, you name it, all went there. US and western world, including Indonesia with Operasi Bubat Mabur backed them to fought the Soviets. CIA with the help of Pakistani ISI more heavily chose the most radical of the groups there, especially located in Af-Pak region. British chose a more friendly ally in Panjshir.

Makhtab al-Khidamah was where many foreigners were in Afghanistan. In Egypt, place where political Islam was rampant at the 20th century, started by the influence of Hasan Al-Banna with its IM, they experienced a blow from the killing of Sadat. No joke, Egypt was full of history during the Cold War era. Sadat was killed because of his more friendly attitude with Israel. Some of those Egyptian also went to joined the MAK, Ayman al-Zawahiri and this Saif al-Adl two of the examples. Because of Egyptian heavy exposure to political Islam, not weird if they were more political or have more spirit than the others, that some even said Azzam was killed by Egyptian clique of the jihadists in Afghanistan-Pakistan.

Then export the influence everywhere, like Saif al-Adl effort to started movement in Somalia, became Al-Shabbab. Some Indonesian and others Southeast Asian with its Jemaah Islamiyah or Abu Sayyaf.

One kind of the political Islam, the armed one and rooted from 80s Afghanistan. The other one is different, even they could see the armed one with cynical, rooted from Egypt also combined with Najdi (Salafi), the unarmed version of it. Al-Islah of UAE, Sahwah of Saudi, or pengajian-pengajian kampus or Tarbiyah during the 70s-80s of Indonesia, that its teaching now even become the mainstream. Eventhough armed, Hamas is closer with the unarmed version of it.
 

schuimpjes

Experienced member
Messages
2,164
Reactions
3 1,398
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
If the influence pure Najdi, kind of weird, is less political, some even Madhkali like, where protest movements is wrong.

Meanwhile combined it with others, you have full blown political Islam operators.
 

kantokuukai

Active member
Messages
53
Reactions
14
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
poin ke-2 bisa diasumsikan pelemahan dari dalam kah ini?
Sebenarnya bukan pelemahan, hanya prioritas saja. Pada akhirnya kalau ekonomi besar walaupun 1% akan jadi besar juga nantinya. Poin 1 juga bagaimana mengalokasikan anggaran yang terbatas dengan membeli yang punya efek lebih besar, masuk akal juga. Poin 3 out of the box ini, prinsipnya kan take and give, kita beri apa supaya kawan bisa beri.
 

Umigami

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
6,006
Reactions
5 4,855
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Btw UN arms embargo buat Iran berakhir hari ini. Artinya kita bisa tenang copy Hellfire KW ya?
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom