Live Conflict Ukraine-Russia War
- Thread starter Kartal1
- Start date
Ukrainians demand heavy weapons to be able to counter Russia's new attempt in the East.
The Ukrainian Airforce even tweets and literally begs for ammunition.
The Ukrainian Airforce even tweets and literally begs for ammunition.
Hexciter
Experienced member
- Messages
- 2,575
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Situation on the ground seems to be really intense at the moment.
Kremlin advisor Sergei Karaganov's two latest interviews provide an insightful window into how the Kremlin views the Ukraine war and Russia's future:
I will unpack his main conclusions in this thread /1
Karaganov justifies invading Ukraine as a pre-emptive war on two grounds
The first is that Ukraine has become like Nazi Germany in 1936-37
The second is that Ukraine was a "spearhead of NATO" /2
To explain why Russia invaded Ukraine even though NATO membership was unlikely, Karaganov strips all ethics way from Western foreign policy
He quips that if Russia and China were democracies, and the West was a monarchy, the West would attack "godless liberalism" /3
Karaganov develops this point further by saying that the West regretted not destroying Russia in the 1990s and was compensating now
He claims that Western isolation of Russia has created Russophobia unseen since Hitler's time /4
Karaganov compares Russophobia to historical European anti-Semitism
He argues that the COVID-19 pandemic distracted the West from its obsession with hating Russia, and that the end of the COVID-19 pandemic caused the West to start a war in Ukraine. The West is the aggressor /5
Karaganov then calls the freezing of Russian Central Bank assets "a bandit act directed at a nuclear superpower"
He predicts that the Russia-West conflict will move to a "whole new level" and says the lack of strategic vision and Western irresponsibility caused this /6
Karaganov makes it clear that the current crisis is much more dangerous than the Cold War
During the Cuban Missile Crisis, Karaganov says the West had responsible politicians, which don't exist now /7
Karaganov argues that Russia is better positioned geopolitically now than in the Cold War as it has no Warsaw Pact satellites or a rival in China
Russia has close ties with both China and India, he predicts that the West will be the loser from the war in Ukraine /8
On Ukraine, Karaganov defends the use of the phrase "denazification"
He argues that Nazism isn't just about killing Jews, but its about supremacy and humiliation. Karaganov argues the U.S. is humiliating Russia by pushing Ukraine towards the West, hence Ukraine is Nazi /9
Karaganov foresees a scenario in which several Ukraines are created, so a partition where the east falls into Russia's hands and people's republics are created
He says annexing all of Ukraine is counter-productive and does not rule out Zelensky staying in power /10
Karaganov envisions the "denazification" of Ukraine could follow the trajectory of Germany after 1945 or Chechnya after the early 2000s
Ukraine will be friendlier than Russia after the war. Seems like a contradiction of his earlier denial of a complete takeover /11
Nevertheless, Karaganov argues that economics could pare back Russia's campaign in Ukraine
He says that Ukraine is impoverished and investments in Siberia or the Russian Far East are better. So expect no nation-building or reconstruction aid /12
Karaganov attributes Russia's isolation from Western information networks to its embrace of traditional values, including a rejection of homosexuality
Very much in line with the views of the Russian Orthodox Church and Putin's conservatism /13
Karaganov warns of a "horizontal and vertical escalation" with the West
So a disturbingly high likelihood of "terrible weapons" being used (WMDs presumably), he believes NATO isn't serious about Article 5 and predicts the war will spill over beyond Ukraine /14
Overall, Karaganov seems less maximalist on territory in Ukraine than most in the Kremlin, but his views on other issues align with the consensus
On domestic politics, he is a fierce critic of democracy and champion of Russia as authoritarian, which fits the current view /END
threadreaderapp.com
I will unpack his main conclusions in this thread /1
Karaganov justifies invading Ukraine as a pre-emptive war on two grounds
The first is that Ukraine has become like Nazi Germany in 1936-37
The second is that Ukraine was a "spearhead of NATO" /2
To explain why Russia invaded Ukraine even though NATO membership was unlikely, Karaganov strips all ethics way from Western foreign policy
He quips that if Russia and China were democracies, and the West was a monarchy, the West would attack "godless liberalism" /3
Karaganov develops this point further by saying that the West regretted not destroying Russia in the 1990s and was compensating now
He claims that Western isolation of Russia has created Russophobia unseen since Hitler's time /4
Karaganov compares Russophobia to historical European anti-Semitism
He argues that the COVID-19 pandemic distracted the West from its obsession with hating Russia, and that the end of the COVID-19 pandemic caused the West to start a war in Ukraine. The West is the aggressor /5
Karaganov then calls the freezing of Russian Central Bank assets "a bandit act directed at a nuclear superpower"
He predicts that the Russia-West conflict will move to a "whole new level" and says the lack of strategic vision and Western irresponsibility caused this /6
Karaganov makes it clear that the current crisis is much more dangerous than the Cold War
During the Cuban Missile Crisis, Karaganov says the West had responsible politicians, which don't exist now /7
Karaganov argues that Russia is better positioned geopolitically now than in the Cold War as it has no Warsaw Pact satellites or a rival in China
Russia has close ties with both China and India, he predicts that the West will be the loser from the war in Ukraine /8
On Ukraine, Karaganov defends the use of the phrase "denazification"
He argues that Nazism isn't just about killing Jews, but its about supremacy and humiliation. Karaganov argues the U.S. is humiliating Russia by pushing Ukraine towards the West, hence Ukraine is Nazi /9
Karaganov foresees a scenario in which several Ukraines are created, so a partition where the east falls into Russia's hands and people's republics are created
He says annexing all of Ukraine is counter-productive and does not rule out Zelensky staying in power /10
Karaganov envisions the "denazification" of Ukraine could follow the trajectory of Germany after 1945 or Chechnya after the early 2000s
Ukraine will be friendlier than Russia after the war. Seems like a contradiction of his earlier denial of a complete takeover /11
Nevertheless, Karaganov argues that economics could pare back Russia's campaign in Ukraine
He says that Ukraine is impoverished and investments in Siberia or the Russian Far East are better. So expect no nation-building or reconstruction aid /12
Karaganov attributes Russia's isolation from Western information networks to its embrace of traditional values, including a rejection of homosexuality
Very much in line with the views of the Russian Orthodox Church and Putin's conservatism /13
Karaganov warns of a "horizontal and vertical escalation" with the West
So a disturbingly high likelihood of "terrible weapons" being used (WMDs presumably), he believes NATO isn't serious about Article 5 and predicts the war will spill over beyond Ukraine /14
Overall, Karaganov seems less maximalist on territory in Ukraine than most in the Kremlin, but his views on other issues align with the consensus
On domestic politics, he is a fierce critic of democracy and champion of Russia as authoritarian, which fits the current view /END
Thread by @SamRamani2 on Thread Reader App
@SamRamani2: Kremlin advisor Sergei Karaganov's two latest interviews provide an insightful window into how the Kremlin views the Ukraine war and Russia's future I will unpack his main conclusions in this thread /1 ...…
threadreaderapp.com
There's no city left. It's gone. Razed to the ground.
M
These vehicles can give hell to russian armour stormer vehicles are very dangerous If they can get through behind of the russians
- Messages
- 232
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Soyuzmultfilm bashfully removed a 1973 Soviet cartoon from YouTube. There, 3 children on the bathyscaphe "Neptune" find a sunken fascist ship with the designation Z 29. There, one child says that fascist ships were designated with the letter Z
- Messages
- 232
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
I think that Russia has grown old, while Turkey and the Turkic countries have become younger.
- Messages
- 3,041
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Russia should, and by the look of it will become like China or even worse. They deserve it.
Russia going all in...
One of the tactical reasons behind Ukraine's unwillingness to give up Mariupol
schuimpjes
Experienced member
- Messages
- 2,522
- Reactions
- Nation of residence
-
- Nation of origin
-
Another great guy join the fight
