Indonesia Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

Parry Brima

Contributor
Messages
982
Reactions
1 1,057
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
We used to have an aspiration for Su-35 and now look at our situation, don't put your expectation too high.

Su-35's obstacles 100% coming from the outside to be fair. This "Margot Robbie's like aspiration" from PT PAL has all the obstacles from ourselves.
 

Cromwell

Committed member
Messages
217
Reactions
271
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Su-35's obstacles 100% coming from the outside to be fair. This "Margot Robbie's like aspiration" from PT PAL has all the obstacles from ourselves.
We could've solved the acquisition long ago. The plan was coming sometime around 2013 - 2014, long before CAATSA bill passed House of Representative ( 2017 ) into Act.
 

FoodSoldier

Active member
Messages
67
Reactions
93
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
TCG Anadolu is not that expensive. Technology wise also not that super complex rocket science-like.

PAL can definitely make one.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,502
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,884
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
TCG Anadolu is not that expensive. Technology wise also not that super complex rocket science-like.
1 Bil+ without the air wing. Have you ever dared to check sensors, EW, comms, C4I payloads? It is the flagship, can manage joint-force operations and a flotilla.
 

FoodSoldier

Active member
Messages
67
Reactions
93
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
1 Bil+ without the air wing. Have you ever dared to check sensors, EW, comms, C4I payloads? It is the flagship, can manage joint-force operations and a flotilla.
We bought 3 overprice underperformed submarines for $1.3 bio, so?

PAL also can copy similar roadmap, 1 built in Turkey + 1 assembled in Surabaya.

It’s doable with the current budget (and expertise). It’s not overreach (or some say “a wet dream”).
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,913
Reactions
4 10,053
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
We bought 3 overprice underperformed submarines for $1.3 bio, so?

PAL also can copy similar roadmap, 1 built in Turkey + 1 assembled in Surabaya.

It’s doable with the current budget (and expertise). It’s not overreach (or some say “a wet dream”).

Overpriced? Damn no, they are even more cheaper than some second hand article out there , those money already including overhead development Costs, some ILS, training , maintenance facilities, simulator and other stuff.

But still, ada harga ada rupa!!
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,361
Reactions
22 12,853
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
TCG Anadolu is not that expensive. Technology wise also not that super complex rocket science-like.

PAL can definitely make one.
Not that simple. PAL had years of experience building the Luursen designed FPB-57 but when they try their hands on homegrown KCR-60. The first batch are seen as defective.

LHD are miles ahead when it comes to complexity and a lot of learning curves to be learned by PAL
 

Cromwell

Committed member
Messages
217
Reactions
271
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
1665642586032.jpg

1665642589035.jpg

Mid-Life Modernisation on KRI Usman Harun.
 

FPXAllen

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,126
Reactions
4 1,702
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
but when they try their hands on homegrown KCR-60. The first batch are seen as defective.
This is a very important lesson that must be taken since there's no instant success. It would be unnatural if every first attempt to create something on your own always resulted in a perfect product.

On the other hand, many if not most of the problems in the first batch of products - in this case, the KCR-60 - can be avoided if PT PAL has developed its own truly comprehensive testing methods and equipment, or at least acquired these two from more established shipyards.

LHD are miles ahead when it comes to complexity and a lot of learning curves to be learned by PAL
True that. But there will be no progress whatsoever if no first step is going to be taken. Since they seem to have gathered enough confidence after developing and building LPDs, it's natural if they want to get their hands on something bigger.

Of course, they should never take anything for granted since the LHD is still something new for them.
 

FoodSoldier

Active member
Messages
67
Reactions
93
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Not that simple. PAL had years of experience building the Luursen designed FPB-57 but when they try their hands on homegrown KCR-60. The first batch are seen as defective.

LHD are miles ahead when it comes to complexity and a lot of learning curves to be learned by PAL
Are we talking about having a LHD or PAL capability?

Most of the talking here is about the possibility of we’re having a LHD. And I think (realistically) it’s 100% possible, considering the cost of the targeted ship concept (ie Navantia-Sedef TCG Anadolu).

Whether PAL can produce it domestically or not is a different question. They can just follow Changabogo production roadmap, and still they can claim it as domestically assembled.
 
Top Bottom