Indonesia Navy Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

flogger

Contributor
Messages
494
Reactions
1 448
Nation of origin
Indonesia
All the subsystems(16 strike length cells, MKE 76mm gun, Gökdeniz CIWS, radars etc) are already contracted; not clear if includes "perishables" like missiles and torpedoes, munitions etc or not; which is the same for any deal; totally dependent.
Roger and understood brother thx..
 

Aassdimenso

Active member
Messages
42
Reactions
1 104
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Which was and still is a surprise to me; as no one is selling a frigate for 500m apiece with this kind of loadout; especially one that is already built.
I guess the problem for Indonesian military enthusiasts is that the Istif-class has pretty much the same price tag as our PPA Light+ deal, which features much more advanced radar and a larger hull. But to be fair, this is what our government wanted. I can also understand why the Turkish government decided to let them go, given the significant profit they stand to make from this deal.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,694
Solutions
2
Reactions
135 26,194
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
All the subsystems(16 strike length cells, MKE 76mm gun, Gökdeniz CIWS, radars, EW etc) are already contracted; not clear if includes "perishables" like missiles and torpedoes, munitions etc or not; which is the same for any deal; totally dependent.
Imo missiles are excluded, specifically for MIDLAS since there is no planning, or roadmap on the otherside, as which to fire from MIDLAS.
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
608
Reactions
3 524
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
All the subsystems(16 strike length cells, MKE 76mm gun, Gökdeniz CIWS, radars, EW etc) are already contracted; not clear if includes "perishables" like missiles and torpedoes, munitions etc or not; which is the same for any deal; totally dependent.
so full system, but unclear info regarding amo, which if we calculate not far from sigma 105 with "kopongan/empty" configuration reaching 220 US mio per hull.
 

kanalkanan

Active member
Messages
138
Reactions
1 75
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Indonesia
so full system, but unclear info regarding amo, which if we calculate not far from sigma 105 with "kopongan/empty" configuration reaching 220 US mio per hull.
For your information, Turkey itself has never fully operated midlas on high intensity situation in its navy. They only conducted midlas trials in 2024 and 2025 with successfully status

Therefore, some public's doubts about cms Advent and Midlas are understandable for our FMP and this newly acquisition
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
608
Reactions
3 524
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
For your information, Turkey itself has never fully operated midlas on high intensity situation in its navy. They only conducted midlas trials in 2024 and 2025 with successfully status

Therefore, some public's doubts about cms Advent and Midlas are understandable for our FMP and this newly acquisition
as per first customer, indo had traumatic memory regarding NAVY procurement from SOKOR, mindef must be calculated well before doing same thing to Turks products.. but once agains, geo politics take bigger part regarding acquititions weaponary from Turks. hope the Turks not so stubborn like others suplier when came a problem.
 

kanalkanan

Active member
Messages
138
Reactions
1 75
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Indonesia
as per first customer, indo had traumatic memory regarding NAVY procurement from SOKOR, mindef must be calculated well before doing same thing to Turks products.. but once agains, geo politics take bigger part regarding acquititions weaponary from Turks. hope the Turks not so stubborn like others suplier when came a problem.
Yap, I agree geopolitics has had a major influence on arms purchases lately.
But rather than strengthening our current fleet, don't you think this will lead to low interoperability of our navy?

let count how many system and subsystems are used by most of our fleet, and how big impact for our readiness
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
608
Reactions
3 524
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
Yap, I agree geopolitics has had a major influence on arms purchases lately.
But rather than strengthening our current fleet, don't you think this will lead to low interoperability of our navy?

let count how many system and subsystems are used by most of our fleet, and how big impact for our readiness
thats why, 08 choose italy, french n turks as a new suplier, those 3 knew for their "flexibility", and all 3 are NATO member. don't forget, indo mindef choose greek consultant for interoperability things.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom