TR UAV/UCAV Programs | Anka - series | Kızılelma | TB - series

UkroTurk

Experienced member
Land Warfare Specialist
Professional
Messages
2,729
Reactions
55 4,868
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
AFAIK even most of frigate warships are not combat operational at 5 seastate. Just survive mode.
@Anmdt

✈️ Aircraft Carrier Flight Operations – Up to What Sea State?

Modern nuclear-powered aircraft carriers (e.g., Nimitz-class, Ford-class – USA):

Typically capable of conducting flight operations up to Sea State 5 (about 4 meters wave height).

At Sea State 6 or higher, flight operations are usually suspended or highly restricted, due to:

Increased ship movement (roll and pitch), making takeoff and landing dangerous.

Difficulty in maintaining optimal wind alignment for launch and recovery.



Lighter or STOBAR-type carriers (Short Take-Off But Arrested Recovery – e.g., Russia’s Admiral Kuznetsov):

Usually effective up to Sea State 4.

At higher sea states, deck motion becomes too severe for safe aircraft operations.




---




In higher sea states, it becomes difficult to maintain a steady position.

The flight deck can pitch and roll dangerously, making both launch and recovery operations risky.
Considering flight deck structure of TCG Anadolu, 5SS is challenge.
 
Last edited:

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
3,518
Reactions
188 18,023
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Sea State conditions are assessed by an experienced and trained marine observer via actually measuring and by using instruments like electronic weather buoys to measure wave height and wave radar or remote sensing satellites that can assess wave height as well as degree of spray which constitutes part of the measurement process. (Not by catching a glimpse of a bit of water in a video)

Carrier operational limit is Sea State 5. But this is for a large and heavier carrier. Larger, heavier carriers generally experience less motion in rough seas, allowing for more consistent flight operations and reduced operational limitations. Smaller ships, on the other hand, are more susceptible to the effects of sea state, leading to more frequent disruptions in their ability to launch and recover aircraft

Sea state is characterised by wave height, wave period, and few other factors like wind speed which impacts a ship's motion in all three dimensions. Sea State is measured by taking all these factors in to consideration.

A 27000 ton LHD and a 100000ton super carrier will have very different sea state tolerances if they are both used for same type of carrier operations. (Also it has to be remembered that one is essentially designed to be an Amphibious Assault Vessel, where as the Carrier’s design is such that it is engineered for specifically to withstand rough seas. It has big electronically controlled gyroscopes and ballast tanks that are no match for those used in smaller ships. )
 

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
3,518
Reactions
188 18,023
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Sea states have been traditionally judged by visual clues. That's why in the video often parts showing a flag flying and an empty stretch of water showing waves and sometimes both included as much as possible while no instrument is shown surprisingly. Metering by instruments only adds precision to the judgement. So you can very well judge sea state by visual clues in a video. Please stop disrespecting members and start showing your way of judging what sea state the ship is operating in; oh yes there is non. A yes sea states is a range of values not a single value metered by an instrument.
First of all you can not tell me that I am disrespecting any member. I am not.
I don’t need to agree with what you write. Especially when it is illogical and petty.

Quote
Sea state conditions for a ship can be determined through a combination of visual observations by experienced personnel, instrumental measurements using weather buoys and wave radar, and remote sensing satellites.
Unquote.

Have you done any of that to come to a conclusion of sea state 4?

Please read below article. Especially this paragraph:

quote

How to determine the sea state?​

The simplest way is through visual observation by experienced seafarers.

In addition, specialized observation ships carry out sea state observations, including water temperature, salinity, chemical composition, marine pollutants, marine life, ocean currents, and other parameters from the surface to the deep layers.

Nowadays, instruments such as meteorological buoys, wave radars, or remote sensing satellites can be used to assess sea state. For example, modern autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs) can make accurate measurements and sea state forecasts in complex ocean environments.

It is worth mentioning that sea state can be quickly judged based on the actual ocean conditions, but we cannot quickly determine the wind and wave conditions on the sea surface according to the Beaufort wind scale. Wind scale cannot fully represent the sea state, and in windy conditions, this state may take several hours to develop.

unquote


 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
3,186
Reactions
102 14,534
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Looks like the Anka-3 PT-2 crash landed during Anatolian Eagle 25. Looks mostly intact.

1750871799173.png

 

Rooxbar

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
904
Reactions
70 2,749
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
3,186
Reactions
102 14,534
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Shit, probably sets back testing phase somewhat. It's oft repeated that flying these flying wing configurations is hard, so probably bound to happen for a firm doing it for the first time. Hopefully it's not damaged too much (doesn't look like it).
I don't like speculation, we have no idea what happened. Looks like a controlled landing without power, maybe engine gave out. We'll have some idea of what to expect by watching future flight testing. Official explanations will be useless as usual.
 

Strong AI

Experienced member
Messages
1,822
Reactions
48 6,248
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Looks like the Anka-3 PT-2 crash landed during Anatolian Eagle 25. Looks mostly intact.

View attachment 76093

Shh, it needs some rest. (video)


1750873091700.png
 
Last edited:

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
3,186
Reactions
102 14,534
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Shh, it needs some rest.

Looks almost AI, uncanny. Must be quite the spectacle for watchers.

I think it's PT-2 but that gray tone could also be from the dust on it and maybe it's PT-1?

Regardless, nothing to cry about, it's a prototype for a reason. Lots of lessons to be learned from the mishap for the future.
 

Strong AI

Experienced member
Messages
1,822
Reactions
48 6,248
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Looks almost AI, uncanny. Must be quite the spectacle for watchers.

I think it's PT-2 but that gray tone could also be from the dust on it and maybe it's PT-1?

Regardless, nothing to cry about, it's a prototype for a reason. Lots of lessons to be learned from the mishap for the future.

The thing is, it could have just crashed. But they/it managed to do an emergency landing without bursting into flames. That's a plus.
 

No Name

Contributor
Messages
538
Reactions
8 549
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Afghanistan
The thing is, it could have just crashed. But they/it managed to do an emergency landing without bursting into flames. That's a plus.

I cannot tell if it is its weapons bay that is open or the landing gear. Can someone tell the difference?
 

Angry Turk !!!

Contributor
Messages
567
Reactions
5 1,332
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
I'd keep an eye on the people that immediately show those pictures to the open. I know it's the Anatolian Eagle but still. Maybe some skulls need to be cracked to be fair.
 

Strong AI

Experienced member
Messages
1,822
Reactions
48 6,248
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
I'd keep an eye on the people that immediately show those pictures to the open. I know it's the Anatolian Eagle but still. Maybe some skulls need to be cracked to be fair.

It landed next to a public road, what do you mean? (look at the picture on the right, it is visible between the last trees there)

1750874912311.jpeg
 

uçuyorum

Contributor
Messages
1,086
Reactions
14 1,731
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Could have been much worse. Tusaş had a good run of very few crashes even with prototypes. Remember YF22 crashes or B2 crash due to humidity in altitude sensor or whatever
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,604
Solutions
2
Reactions
127 25,564
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I see sea state 3 at least at later sorties; breaking waves with white foam is no less then state 3. A state 5 sorti should be achievable without much risk. I wonder how much weather the ship will risk sailing but the TB3 can not fly. Like if the ship can sail at sea state 6 but TB3 can fly at SS 4 max then it is 2 SS difference. But if TB3 can fly at SS 5 then it is just one SS difference. I wonder if they will test the plane to see how much weather it can take at the cost of causing some accidents. They do it in aviation and fly planes until they break. I think I have sailed at SS 6 and maybe even touched SS 7 in my cargo ship days.

View attachment 76082
This is significant wave height we are speaking, most military ships have survivability limit at sea state 7. Beyond sea state 5 they only care about surviving it out. (Unless it is a whooping 100K tonnes carrier, or a submarine). Above sea state 3 requires inhumane piloting skills at helicopter operations.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,604
Solutions
2
Reactions
127 25,564
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Could have been much worse. Tusaş had a good run of very few crashes even with prototypes. Remember YF22 crashes or B2 crash due to humidity in altitude sensor or whatever
Lost the engine, autopiloted, landed smoothly. Kudos to engineers, a flying lost the engine but not flight stability.
It is the engine, again.
 

Follow us on social media

Latest posts

Top Bottom