I wouldn't get too caught up on this 5 Billion amount when we don't even know its capabilities or design. Its a place holder just as the 29 Billion amount was initiually given for the river class when we didn't even know what the design would be.
As I double check on my assessment as to what Corvette class warships cost, I took a look at some current corvettes around the world, dug up a bit on their procurement costs, and then added to such the cost for initial munitions, spares, support, and ship specific shore infrastructure).
I should also qualify this by saying I have a very very rough rule of thumb, the cost for a warship consists of:
- hull and warship platform - 20 to 35% of the cost
- mission systems (sensors, c3, fire-control, EW) - 45 to 60% of the cost
- weapons & initial munition - 10% to 20% of the cost
- training/spares/support/integration - 10% to 20% of the cost
And further, mission systems may exceed 60% of the costs by a substantial margin for highly specialized AAW or ASW combatants.
Clearly what I have is a very rough estimate in regard to the costs, but I do believe it supports what I suspect in regards to $5-billion CDN $. Its not enough for 15 to 20 corvettes. perhaps as mentioned to me elsewhere it may only be for the first batch, or for the costs ignoring initial munitions, spares, support, and ship specific shore infrastructure, although even then, I suspect $5-billion Canadian not enough (ie ~$ 3.7-billion US$).
Not most articles (IMHO) don't include initial munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure in their per ship costs. However Canada tends to price things differently. Further, Canada is likely to modify any corvette with weapons and sensors selected by Canada, which typically always drives up the cost signficantly.
Anyway, arbirarly selecting different corvettes, my rough estimates of different corvette costs, including initial munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure if not built in Canada (which clearly won't be the case) but delivered to Canada (with initial munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure work) is below:
Visby-class corvette (Sweden) 650 tons.
- My estimated cost estimate (including munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $250-to-$380 US$ million per ship
Gowind 2500 / 3100 (France/Egypt/UAE/Malaysia):
- estimated cost estimate GoWind 2500 (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $400 to $600 million per ship
- estimated cost estimate GoWind 3100 (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $$550 to $750 million per ship
Ada-class corvette (Turkey/Pakiston/Ukraine/Malaysia) 2,400 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $350-to-$450 million/ship
Tuo Chiang-class corvette (Flight-II onwards) (Taiwan) 732 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $250 to $400 million/ship
K130 Braunschweig-class corvette (Germany)
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $500 to $700 million/ship
Baynunah-class corvette — (UAE) - 915 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $300 to $450 million/ship
Khareef-class corvette — Oman (built by BAE) - 2,660 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $280 to $360 million per ship
Sigma Corvette 9113 (Diponegoro-class corvette) — Indonesia - 1,700 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $250 to $350 million/ship
Sigma Corvette/Frigate 10514 - Martadinata-class (3,000 tons, 105 meter length)
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : US$ $400 to $500 million per ship
Daegu-class frigate (South Korea) — 3,600 to 3,800 tons
- estimated cost (incl munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure) : approximately US$ $500 million to $750 million per ship
Caveat:
Again, those costs are my estimates of total procurement plus initial munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure averaged into per ship cost. And each of those corvettes have very different capabilities. I chose NOT to include a list of their capabilities, where the price dfferences start to make more sense when one looks at the capabilities of each class of corvette.
The least expensive appear to be the
- Visby class (Sweden)
- Tu Chiang class (Taiwan)
- Diponegoro-class corvette (Indonesia)
I note thou:
- Visby class (Sweden) - I think it has a range of 4,600 km which, I believe, is definitely on the short side for endurance (arctic patrols may require more) and it is being upgraded to include a Sea Ceptor / CAMM air defence system - where has no anti-air missile without such an upgrade.
- Tu Chiang class (Tawiwan) - range of 3,700km is likely too short for Canada. The ASW capability of this class is not very good.
- Diponegoro-class corvette (Sigma Corvette 9113) of Indonesia -
possibly the best cost/capability ratio (from above list) if one wants both ASW and self defence AAW (ie missile/drone short range defense). And also one needs to assume my speculative numbers are correct. But this does not take into account Canadianization.
Having typed the above,
my cost estimates could be very wrong. If one reads costs on the internet, typically such do NOT include initial munitions, spares, support, ship specific shore infrastructure in their estimates. I tried to include those costs.
I think thou I concluded (again) $5-billion Canadian (ie $3.7 billion US$) won't buy 20 corvettes.
If an off the shelf Diponegoro-class corvette (Sigma Corvette 9113) was chosen it might buy 14 corvettes. However once 'Canadianization' equipment plus building in Canada applied I suspect the number would fall to 10 or less.