• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

India HAL Tejas Program

Spitfire9

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
1,270
Reactions
17 1,663
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
Too many approvals needed for anything to progress.

HAL chief on Tejas Mk1A - "The only thing awaited now is the approval for some software changes in the Astra missile."

Indian bureaucracy is a millstone around the neck of Indian fighter projects. If the Astra/Tejas Mk1A combination now works, the aircraft should be delivered, not languish in hangars waiting for bureaucrats to clear it for delivery. It might be the Indian way of getting things done but in reality it is a good way of not getting things done.
 

Spitfire9

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
1,270
Reactions
17 1,663
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
Mk2 rollout probably H1 2026?
FF probably H2 2026/H1 2027?
Testing complete 2029/2030?

I wonder where the Mk2 will be assembled. In 2030 the 2 HAL plants in Bengaluru will be busy assembling Mk1A. Nashik will be busy assembling Mk1A and possibly Su-30MKI.

Will there be a gap of a year or two between certification and start of production?
 

Ripley

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
1,431
Reactions
51 4,581
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Turkey

IC3M@N FX

Contributor
Messages
701
Reactions
3 30 1,432
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
It was probably too late for the poor pilot to eject.
This was hardly good publicity for the Tejas aircraft, regardless of whether it was pilot error or a mechanical fault.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,190
Reactions
127 19,046
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
It was probably too late for the poor pilot to eject.
This was hardly good publicity for the Tejas aircraft, regardless of whether it was pilot error or a mechanical fault.
Looks to be pilot; even if aircraft gave in midway through, too low. RIP.
 

IC3M@N FX

Contributor
Messages
701
Reactions
3 30 1,432
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
1763730012981.png

1763730031026.png


Can someone recheck the plane number if is the plane they crashed.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,190
Reactions
127 19,046
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Aircraft can leak oil, I vividly remember the US aggressor F-18s leaking oil on the ramp like drunkards. Some say that was not oil but water instead, also possible.

Regardless, it's an active duty aircraft of the air force without known issues. Tejas is many things, but it doesn't just lock up and crash. This looks like a very clear case of pilot error to me.

Was the APU smoking? Or was that smoke for the show?
APU exhaust should be up top. Smoke generators are on the wing pylons as fake missiles. Interesting.
 

Ripley

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
1,431
Reactions
51 4,581
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Turkey
Sad loss. RIP.
Tejas program was gaining some speed recently. Hope they get back on track quickly.
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
5,138
Reactions
104 10,047
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
Aircraft can leak oil, I vividly remember the US aggressor F-18s leaking oil on the ramp like drunkards. Some say that was not oil but water instead, also possible.

Regardless, it's an active duty aircraft of the air force without known issues. Tejas is many things, but it doesn't just lock up and crash. This looks like a very clear case of pilot error to me.


APU exhaust should be up top. Smoke generators are on the wing pylons as fake missiles. Interesting.

There is another video from a different angle where it seems something poped inside the engine right before it start rolling down. Maybe a bird strike...Idk. but seemed like a little explosion.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,190
Reactions
127 19,046
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
There is another video from a different angle where it seems something poped inside the engine right before it start rolling down. Maybe a bird strike...Idk. but seemed like a little explosion.
But there's nothing to indicate any loss of power from the aircraft.

I kind of agree with general's statement:

"Today's HAL Tejas Mk1A crash in Dubai. Sadly, the pilot lost his life. RIP.

It's a situation similar to the crash in Poland. Meanwhile, our F-4 pilots narrowly escaped disaster in Cyprus. Air shows are endlessly beautiful to watch, but they're no joke. A very high level of flight discipline is required. You can't do this job without careful planning and training... The pilots selected for this job are special pilots. They all have to be experienced. The Indian pilot was also very experienced, but accidents can still happen.

The first comment on this accident has come in: they say there was an oil leak. However, oil leak malfunctions that could cause a plane to crash without sudden structural damage (collision, etc.) do not occur instantly. They develop slowly. The pilot would cancel the mission at that point and land safely. There would be no problem. Therefore, I do not believe the cause of this accident is as simple as "there was an oil leak."

Based on the 3-5 second footage, there was no attempt to save the aircraft. There was no strong descent. There is also no footage expected from an exit maneuver that should normally occur at 4-5G. There does not appear to be a pilot-induced situation either. There must have been a control malfunction preventing a safe exit, or the pilot was "mesmerized" by something on the ground, his focus remained there, and he did not give the exit command sufficiently and in time. There is a "lazy" situation... Whatever happened, unfortunately, it did not end well."

 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
5,138
Reactions
104 10,047
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
But there's nothing to indicate any loss of power from the aircraft.

I kind of agree with general's statement:

"Today's HAL Tejas Mk1A crash in Dubai. Sadly, the pilot lost his life. RIP.

It's a situation similar to the crash in Poland. Meanwhile, our F-4 pilots narrowly escaped disaster in Cyprus. Air shows are endlessly beautiful to watch, but they're no joke. A very high level of flight discipline is required. You can't do this job without careful planning and training... The pilots selected for this job are special pilots. They all have to be experienced. The Indian pilot was also very experienced, but accidents can still happen.

The first comment on this accident has come in: they say there was an oil leak. However, oil leak malfunctions that could cause a plane to crash without sudden structural damage (collision, etc.) do not occur instantly. They develop slowly. The pilot would cancel the mission at that point and land safely. There would be no problem. Therefore, I do not believe the cause of this accident is as simple as "there was an oil leak."

Based on the 3-5 second footage, there was no attempt to save the aircraft. There was no strong descent. There is also no footage expected from an exit maneuver that should normally occur at 4-5G. There does not appear to be a pilot-induced situation either. There must have been a control malfunction preventing a safe exit, or the pilot was "mesmerized" by something on the ground, his focus remained there, and he did not give the exit command sufficiently and in time. There is a "lazy" situation... Whatever happened, unfortunately, it did not end well."


I agree that we didn't see any apparent power loss. But see this one. Dunno what is it.

 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
11,082
Reactions
153 22,637
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Aircraft can leak oil, I vividly remember the US aggressor F-18s leaking oil on the ramp like drunkards. Some say that was not oil but water instead, also possible.

Regardless, it's an active duty aircraft of the air force without known issues. Tejas is many things, but it doesn't just lock up and crash. This looks like a very clear case of pilot error to me.


APU exhaust should be up top. Smoke generators are on the wing pylons as fake missiles. Interesting.

Yup pretty much open shut case of severe pilot error at low altitude if you ask me.

It bears uncanny resemblance to the Polish F-16 crash at an airshow rehearsal a couple months ago. Again what looks to be major pilot misjudgement in that one.

Sad.

Shoreham aircrash also comes to mind, that was again a loop with too little altitude for the thrust the old warbird (Hawker Hunter) was capable of. What was wild was the (blacked out) pilot survived the impact (being thrown out of canopy during impact) and was prosecuted for manslaughter of the casualties on the ground. I think he was acquitted.

But really pilots, however well trained they are, shouldnt let rush of blood get too much....its not worth it.
 

Ahlatshah

Committed member
Messages
164
Reactions
19 728
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Aircraft can leak oil, I vividly remember the US aggressor F-18s leaking oil on the ramp like drunkards. Some say that was not oil but water instead, also possible.
Of course aircraft leaks oil. But there are limits for that, depending on engine. I remember maintanence guy counted the drops, if it is (lets say) under 15 drops a minute while the engine running idle, the aircraft is good to go for (lets say again) 2 hours of flight and inspect further after that, over 15 drops no go.

It can not be water btw. If it was there was no can to collect. Because while water is harmless, oil is however, clear FOD (Foreign Object Damage) and can be very harmful even dangerous when sucked into engines. So leaked oil has to be removed and cleaned from the apron. In civil airports, airlines have to call the airport authority when leaked on the ground and pay for the oil cleaning service, if you dont there is severe penalty for leaving oil build up. For the military airports (in our AF case), there are always airport maintenance crew to take care of such FODs.
 
Top Bottom