Indonesia Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

[Parry Brima]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1527195597203476481

Arguably the most cinematic aircraft (both fixed & rotary wing) ever produced by men. They look really beautiful on the big screen.

 

[Lordimperator]

Arguably the most cinematic aircraft (both fixed & rotary wing) ever produced by men. They look really beautiful on the big screen.

Wait till chinese made copy for their LHD

 

[Van Kravchenko]

This is Indonesia. If there are European alternatives, choose the European. FMS is only for cool stuff that European doesn’t have (and they think that’s good) lol

other than this helos debate, the most insane case were while most of Medium Lift Helos of Indonesian uses H22M family tech tree, the Army all of sudden want to acquire UH-60 which in this case didn't make any sense. since they are both have same capability.

 

[Umigami]

Can we access it?

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1528183147329748992

 

[wahyu845]

View attachment 44052

412 has already order 30
AW 101 1 :d

 

[R4duga]

kongsberg MSI-90U MK2 CMS in ardadedali
https://koarmada2.tnial.mil.id/2022...n-binopslat-bagi-prajurit-kri-ardadedali-404/

"KRI 404 Shadowing liaoning battlegroup in SCS"
"Redmi Note 8 inside the crew pocket"

 

[schuimpjes]

Can we access it?

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1528183147329748992

This kind of intel is possibly shared between India and US because of BECA. To ASEAN maybe included in ASEAN-US meeting about weeks ago? Or maybe shared by Singapore to the other ASEAN countries. No word spoken by Indonesian official

 

[Mandala]

NSM or RBS15 MK3 for KRI Golok-688? Credit to Lembaga Keris.

Video:

https://m.facebook.com/lembagakeris/videos/weekly-activities-kri-golok-688periode-minggu-ketiga-mei-20221-dalam-rangka-peni/677640099996030/

 

[Van Kravchenko]

NSM or RBS15 MK3 for KRI Golok-688? Credit to Lembaga Keris.

View attachment 44190

Video:

https://m.facebook.com/lembagakeris/videos/weekly-activities-kri-golok-688periode-minggu-ketiga-mei-20221-dalam-rangka-peni/677640099996030/

i think the party before this also do the same thing, to get comparison data of wich AShM better suite to be installed in such FAC .

 

[FPXAllen]

i think the party before this also do the same thing, to get comparison data of wich AShM better suite to be installed in such FAC .

One NSM (+/- 407 kg) roughly weighs half as much as one RBS 15 (+/- 810 kg) though...

Or from other perspective, if KRI Golok can be armed with four NSMs, then it probably only able to carry two RBS 15.

 

[Gary]

Indonesia omits major procurement programmes from 2022 ‘Green Book'

The Indonesian Ministry of National Development Planning has omitted major defence procurement programmes from the register of priority projects approved for foreign...

www.janes.com

Navy wants mid life upgrades for the FPB-57, Sigma 9013 and F2000, understandable....but what's with the 1st batch KCR-60 ? they wanna do mid life upgrade already ? LOL

 

[Madokafc]

Indonesia omits major procurement programmes from 2022 ‘Green Book'

The Indonesian Ministry of National Development Planning has omitted major defence procurement programmes from the register of priority projects approved for foreign...

www.janes.com

Navy wants mid life upgrades for the FPB-57, Sigma 9013 and F2000, understandable....but what's with the 1st batch KCR-60 ? they wanna do mid life upgrade already ? LOL

Those KCR 60 first batch is not good (the later batch is not good enough too in my opinion), during their first appearance in TNI anniversary years ago they already run into problem.

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Those KCR 60 first batch is not good (the later batch is not good enough too in my opinion), during their first appearance in TNI anniversary years ago they already run into problem.

then, entire batch isn't suited much for Indonesian water operation ?
kinda curious why the ship builder ended up no do much improvisation for the last 2 batch.

 

[FPXAllen]

we lacks human resources

No.

money for research

More fundamental than that, actually. It's about the widespread views of looking down on research - or long time/strategic views and planning - to prioritize short-term gains instead. Even in this forum, you can easily spot replies that pooh-pooh any opinion arguing for long term planning and strategic research and to start trying designing and developing defense technology on our own, delivered completely with reasons such as "we don't need unproven systems for our troops" or the likes.

Hell, how can a system be proven if there's not even a slight interest to start developing, testing, producing, deploying, and receiving feedback from the users themselves?

But yeah, the irony is lost in those kinds of replies since it's quite impossible to remain objective when one already has a vested interest behind their words.

 

[Madokafc]

No.

More fundamental than that, actually. It's about the widespread views of looking down on research - or long time/strategic views and planning - to prioritize short-term gains instead. Even in this forum, you can easily spot replies that pooh-pooh any opinion arguing for long term planning and strategic research and to start trying designing and developing defense technology on our own, delivered completely with reasons such as "we don't need unproven systems for our troops" or the likes.

Hell, how can a system be proven if there's not even a slight interest to start developing, testing, producing, deploying, and receiving feedback from the users themselves?

But yeah, the irony is lost in those kinds of replies since it's quite impossible to remain objective when one already has a vested interest behind their words.

They already lost in translation on why we need to developed our own weapon system by ourselves, those in charge of SOE and Komite Industri Pertahanan feels as long as Karya Anak Bangsa being stamped this enough for any products to be shoved to the end user, and results in user must using sub par products at their own peril. Such bad practices results in resistance from the user to use local products by using battle proven reason, thus created vicious circle.

Such bad practices already happened since long time ago, the license production of BM59 as SP1 battle rifle is an glaring example, followed by other Cases.

 

[Gary]

Just curious what will an MLU Diponegoro class look like.

Thales SMART S MK2 will likely be chosen to replace earlier LW08.​

Will we add VLS for SAM this time. For me the choice of MANPADS for ship air defense are a poor decision.​

Remote controlled autocannon to replace 20mm gun in the stern ??​

Towed sonar ??​

​

Moroccan navy 9813 are a good standard for upgrades.

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Will we add VLS for SAM this time

Unless they want to do heavy maintenance by drilling some hole in superstructure and have enough time to do wiring and weapon integration then it will be OK.

It's just not gonna fit the budget.

 

[schuimpjes]

BUMN being BUMN with shitty management as usual.

As they said, BUMN is a corporate with government institution flavor.

USAF: “F*ck SOE. We doing business with oligarch capitalist MICs. Just give the RnD budget and personnels like Paul Kaminski to the oligarch capitalists”

 

[Lordimperator]

It's just not gonna fit the budget.

And not fit for the ship hull, Moroccan 9813 vs KRi9113

 

[Madokafc]

If TNI & PT PAL amended the contract for the length of Arrowhead 140 from 143 m to 138-140 m of the original design, can the original design accommodate the weapon specs that PT PAL has released a few months ago?

The original Itver Huitveld class is already has space for 32 mk41 +24 mk56 VLS plus space for the harpoon Missiles up to 4x4 config. They are already enough....