Pakistan PAF Reveals Bayraktar Akinci and TB2 drones in their official presentation video

the

Well-known member
Messages
321
Reactions
756
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
I hope this is not true. At least not for Akinci.

No offence to Pakistan, but what does Baykar and more widely the Turkish government gain from exporting arguably the most high-tech equipment in possession to Pakistan other than revenue?

1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
2. Has the potential to enter the hands of Chinese officials who will no doubt take it apart and analyse it to make their own domestic version. (One of the reasons why the US has refused to approve the export of ATAK-129, fearing Chinese possession of US engine technology)
3. Realistically, Pakistan does not need to possess drones of this scale, so Turkey has essentially given Pakistan a sort of propaganda tool.

The only justification for exporting to Pakistan would be the expectation that they would provide some from of nuclear technology. Though this is highly unlikely, given the legality of such actions.
(See: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, )
 

Batman22

Member
Messages
14
Reactions
16
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
I hope this is not true. At least not for Akinci.

No offence to Pakistan, but what does Baykar and more widely the Turkish government gain from exporting arguably the most high-tech equipment in possession to Pakistan other than revenue?

1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
2. Has the potential to enter the hands of Chinese officials who will no doubt take it apart and analyse it to make their own domestic version. (One of the reasons why the US has refused to approve the export of ATAK-129, fearing Chinese possession of US engine technology)
3. Realistically, Pakistan does not need to possess drones of this scale, so Turkey has essentially given Pakistan a sort of propaganda tool.

The only justification for exporting to Pakistan would be the expectation that they would provide some from of nuclear technology. Though this is highly unlikely, given the legality of such actions.
(See: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, )
Setting ground for tfx co operation ?
 

TR_123456

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
5,090
Reactions
12,691
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
Nothing to do with India,it cant and wont have any effect on any relationship.
 

Lool

Experienced member
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
2,918
Reactions
13 5,030
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
I hope this is not true. At least not for Akinci.

No offence to Pakistan, but what does Baykar and more widely the Turkish government gain from exporting arguably the most high-tech equipment in possession to Pakistan other than revenue?

1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
2. Has the potential to enter the hands of Chinese officials who will no doubt take it apart and analyse it to make their own domestic version. (One of the reasons why the US has refused to approve the export of ATAK-129, fearing Chinese possession of US engine technology)
3. Realistically, Pakistan does not need to possess drones of this scale, so Turkey has essentially given Pakistan a sort of propaganda tool.

The only justification for exporting to Pakistan would be the expectation that they would provide some from of nuclear technology. Though this is highly unlikely, given the legality of such actions.
(See: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, )
Pakistan possess what Turkey doesnt
1- Advanced Ballistic missiles
2- Nuclear technology


Iam 100% sure that Turkey is already obtaining one or both of these under the table so that the West or Russia doesnt start bitching like kids

Moreover, the Akinci exported is probably of A variant since the first prototype of Akinci B just flew few days ago; thus, the most advanced variants are still within Turkey's hands
 

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
10,857
Reactions
6 18,707
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
I hope this is not true. At least not for Akinci.

No offence to Pakistan, but what does Baykar and more widely the Turkish government gain from exporting arguably the most high-tech equipment in possession to Pakistan other than revenue?

1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
2. Has the potential to enter the hands of Chinese officials who will no doubt take it apart and analyse it to make their own domestic version. (One of the reasons why the US has refused to approve the export of ATAK-129, fearing Chinese possession of US engine technology)
3. Realistically, Pakistan does not need to possess drones of this scale, so Turkey has essentially given Pakistan a sort of propaganda tool.

The only justification for exporting to Pakistan would be the expectation that they would provide some from of nuclear technology. Though this is highly unlikely, given the legality of such actions.
(See: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, )

We can sell Anka and Aksungur to India.

Tb2 and Akinici vs Anka and the Aksungur
 

crixus

Contributor
Messages
1,021
Reactions
1,160
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Pakistan possess what Turkey doesnt
1- Advanced Ballistic missiles
2- Nuclear technology


Iam 100% sure that Turkey is already obtaining one or both of these under the table so that the West or Russia doesnt start bitching like kids

Moreover, the Akinci exported is probably of A variant since the first prototype of Akinci B just flew few days ago; thus, the most advanced variants are still within Turkey's hands
Both ballistic missile and nukes are 1940s technology and I bet Turkey has enough technical knowhow to develop both and your TB2 is most cost effective UCAV in medium to low range category. Pakistan can use them only on tactical level

The funny thing will be , Chinese will come up with similar copy which looks exactly same and selling in the market
 

the

Well-known member
Messages
321
Reactions
756
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Both ballistic missile and nukes are 1940s technology and I bet Turkey has enough technical knowhow to develop both and your TB2 is most cost effective UCAV in medium to low range category. Pakistan can use them only on tactical level

The funny thing will be , Chinese will come up with similar copy which looks exactly same and selling in the market
exactly, its not worth risking all that time and effort to make such a drone if one can expect a copy of it to be available at a cheaper price once China reverse-engineers it. Especially after all the attention Baykar has recieved in the past few months.
 

Oublious

Experienced member
The Netherlands Correspondent
Messages
2,163
Reactions
8 4,676
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
I hope this is not true. At least not for Akinci.

No offence to Pakistan, but what does Baykar and more widely the Turkish government gain from exporting arguably the most high-tech equipment in possession to Pakistan other than revenue?

1. On the flip side, all this does is anger India/ worsen relations with a potentially huge export market.
2. Has the potential to enter the hands of Chinese officials who will no doubt take it apart and analyse it to make their own domestic version. (One of the reasons why the US has refused to approve the export of ATAK-129, fearing Chinese possession of US engine technology)
3. Realistically, Pakistan does not need to possess drones of this scale, so Turkey has essentially given Pakistan a sort of propaganda tool.

The only justification for exporting to Pakistan would be the expectation that they would provide some from of nuclear technology. Though this is highly unlikely, given the legality of such actions.
(See: Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons, )


1 who the fak cares? We are going to sell countries who have problems with China, so we should not sell them?

2 IF Chinese are not capable to make something like TB2 should stop making drones.

3 How do you now that they don't need?
 

Batman22

Member
Messages
14
Reactions
16
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
Pakistan possess what Turkey doesnt
1- Advanced Ballistic missiles
2- Nuclear technology


Iam 100% sure that Turkey is already obtaining one or both of these under the table so that the West or Russia doesnt start bitching like kids

Moreover, the Akinci exported is probably of A variant since the first prototype of Akinci B just flew few days ago; thus, the most advanced variants are still within Turkey's hands
Aren't Pakistani missile are known to be bulkier and in same generation of Iranian and north korean missiles .

Not know much about Turkish ones ,but one Bora missile looks a good base to develop upon specifications wise
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
4,683
Reactions
7 7,389
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
There is no point in not selling Akıncı to Pakistan.
It will probably be the one that is powered by the 450hp Ukrainian engines.
Neither Pakistan nor China would want to get caught red handed trying to copy Turkish technology.
If that happens it will add more appeal to Turkish products as a bonus.
Turkey will have progressed to further levels before anyone can successfully copy an Akıncı plane.
 

Jackdaws

Experienced member
Messages
2,759
Reactions
1 1,583
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
This thread made me curious. What's the Turkish take on India and Pakistan - from a State perspective and from a general population perspective? Do they take a preference for one over the other?
 

Batman22

Member
Messages
14
Reactions
16
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
Indians hate turks but we don't care about indians
Not allbut Erdogan policies has changed perception , earlier it was viewed as a good location for addition to travel itinerary , now it acquired bad rep here about meddling into our internal affairs , average indian with not much interest in international affairs may struggle to locate turkey on map .
 
Top Bottom