TR Propulsion Systems

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,503
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,896
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Yes he does, good you noticed. Most of those opening their mouth and speaking to the public in SSB are most likely not experts, but politicians who wants to look good.

Lol @Anmdt you beat me to the reply :)
There are highly experienced people but most of the business they do is the project management, that is duty of SSB in overall. Managing the on-going projects, coordinating industry and academia, inspecting facilities and industrial organizations and so on. Some people believes that SSB serves as a research organization similar to DARPA.
 

zio

Well-known member
Messages
392
Reactions
7 540
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
"Potential"
any engine that matches in power output and rpm has a potential. I haven't denied possibility of BATU being used as a marine generator.

Yes i am a naval architect and been so for more than a decade, and most of people in SSB are project managers, they don't do engineering if this is your point. I am in contact with them more frequently than you may imagine, there more than few non naval-architect engineers in Naval systems division of SSB.

First of all your 700 kW was wrong, Milgem has 750 kVA generators. You don't list kW, but kVA or kWe while speaking of a marine generator.

Your following statement was also off point, since the diesels on Milgem generators run at lower MCR (if you have read my post you would have found out)



My point is UTKU can not be used to generate 750 kVA at the desired continous rate. Also it is not more powerful than MTU or MAN generators, it is less. Read my post, and do some reading on marine engines, generators.

Turning an engine into a marine generator simply requires more modifications and adjustments than turning an engine into a marine engine. A generator runs even after the engines stop and at varying loads, non-stop.

Existence of an engine does not automatically make it marine generator. BMC is still yet to test their first marine engines on the USVs (Levend), integration is still going on and tests will commence. You need years of experience to build up to make a generator since a failed generator is not something you can't make up at the open seas.

Tübitak's latest DE is more promising but not sure if people influenced by BMC will allow it through. Tübitak RUTE is far ahead in terms of understanding marine engines.

As for you other attached image;
The listed values are for 100% MCR, a high density engine runs at 50 to 60% MCR. Consider the conversion losses and power factor while converting from DE's power output to kVA. We don't simply adapt an engine just because it fits to required power with its 90-95% MCR, the engine is run at lower MCR purposefully, run at lower MCR, less load, less wear, higher MTBF and relaxed maintenance schedule and also; a spare of 60% at your will to boost up engine when you need, in case of emergency. Yes marine engines on naval platforms can run up to 110, 120% MCR for a limited time (sometimes a day). This is a compact engine is not preferred simply for being compact, in comparison to a medium density engine, more or less it occupies the same space, but it provides a better maintenance schedule and spare power.

Yes we should eventually adapt BATU or RUTE engines for marine generators and i am not against the idea, or in fact i support more than you do; at least to begin with this is a nice roadmap to follow, but it can't be rushed. I don't recall if follow up Istanbul Class orders or ADKG orders are planned to be equipped with these engines, either.

It will start with USVs and non critical platforms in service at the navy ports (pusher port tugboats) and from there they can move on to generators.
If the germans do not sell generator engines to Türkiye what would happen to our istif class project,we have to ready for that and hurry up and work hard and for the main engines,shafts,etc… should be on our agenda.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1463.jpeg
    IMG_1463.jpeg
    256.6 KB · Views: 55
  • IMG_1462.jpeg
    IMG_1462.jpeg
    306.5 KB · Views: 52

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,503
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,896
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
If the germans do not sell generator engines to Türkiye what would happen to our istif class project,we have to ready for that and hurry up and work hard and for the main engines,shafts,etc… should be on our agenda.
If Germans don't sell RENK transmission then what happens? Who else makes cross-connect gears? Are you aware that the generators are literally the faintest concern you must have there.

Had problem issues with MTU, switched to MAN, problem solved. If another problem occurs then alternative suppliers are considered, this is as far as it goes.

If the germans do not sell generator engines to Türkiye what would happen to our istif class project,we have to ready for that and hurry up and work hard and for the main engines,shafts,etc… should be on our agenda.
Look, don't keep attaching images that you can't understand. MTU's output is given at 50-60 MCR, BATU's given at much higher. That is different. You can't run Mavi BATU at that MCR for long durations. Learn what an MCR is to begin with. Also if you are familiar with MTU's engine taxonomy, you would know that M91 is the drive (propulsion) optimized version of M51 that is capable of 1200 kW.

That means, the DE installed in the MTU's generator generates 1200 kW in normal loads, but only 700 kW is utilized, hence the 50-60 MCR. That's how SSB's report is slightly wrong. While BATU's output is given for an ideal condition, at 50-60 MCR it will be capped.
 

Zoth

Active member
Messages
89
Reactions
5 156
Nation of residence
Greece
Nation of origin
Turkey
Only a few countries produce combat trainers. The American ones are clearly outdated. Nobody is interested in the Russian ones. Although the Italian ones are in favor today, it seems to me that the Hurjet will be bought like hot cakes :)
The main limitation with Hurjet is it's engine, you can't sell it to anyone outside of US allies, and there is no program or even any slight talk or hint about a domestic engine for Hurjet(at least not yet) so even if it has the possibility of selling like hot cakes, Turkey won't be able to sell it as hot cakes for the reason i mentioned.

Which is really weird, Hurjet is already finished and will become a mature program much sooner than Kaan, i wonder why they don't consider a domestic engine for it?
 
Last edited:

Fairon

Well-known member
Messages
410
Reactions
6 1,023
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
The main limitation with Hurjet is it's engine, you can't sell it to anyone outside of US allies, and there is no program or even any slight talk or hint about a domestic engine for Hurjet(at least not yet) so even if it has the possibility of selling like hot cakes, Turkey won't be able to sell it as hot cakes for the reason i mentioned.

Which is really weird, Hurjet is already finished and will become a mature program much sooner than Kaan, i wonder why they don't consider a domestic engine for it?

Simply, we don't have the manpower and money for the Hurjet engine.
 

boredaf

Contributor
Messages
1,414
Solutions
1
Reactions
16 3,929
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
That should raise questions about the KAAN engine,questions that most people outside Turkyie enthusiasts have already answered ,most people on this forum won't like the answer.....
What answer? That we prioritised an engine for Kaan and put all available people with expertise and experience on that project?
 

hugh

Active member
Messages
103
Reactions
3 319
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
That should raise questions about the KAAN engine,questions that most people outside Turkyie enthusiasts have already answered ,most people on this forum won't like the answer.....
Active TEI Turbine Engine Programs:

- TS1400(1400 shp turboshaft engine): in flight tests
- TF6000(6k lbf turbofan engine): on test bench
- TF35000(35k lbf thrust, 5th gen engine for KAAN): in preliminary design phase
- TS3000(3000shp turboshaft engine for T925 and T929 helicopters): newly initiated project

As you can see, we are already stretched thin. We can't afford to launch another major engine project.
 
Last edited:

dBSPL

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Ambassador
Messages
2,296
Reactions
96 11,842
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Active TEI projects(turbine engines):

- TS1400(1400 shp turboshaft engine): in flight tests
- TF6000(6k lbf turbofan engine): being tested on bench
- TF35000(35k lbf thrust, 5th gen engine for KAAN): in preliminary design phase
- TS3000(3000shp turboshaft engine for T925 and T929 helicopters): newly initiated project

As you can see, we are already stretched thin. We can't afford to launch another major engine project.
++
Additionally, a turboprop is planned over the TS1400, and an afterburner variant for the TF-6000.
 

Fairon

Well-known member
Messages
410
Reactions
6 1,023
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
That should raise questions about the KAAN engine,questions that most people outside Turkyie enthusiasts have already answered ,most people on this forum won't like the answer.....

Not exactly. Kaan engine is one of the projects that money and manpower is directed.

Besides Kaan engine, there is TF6000/10000, TS1400, TS3000(Maybe not this exact name but engine for 10t helicopter) and various small engines that in design process. There might be derivetives from this engines as well(Maybe a marine engine from TF6000 or turboprop based on TS1400)

So when I say we don't have manpower or the money for the Hurjet engine, I mean TEI's hands are already full with the ongoing projects.
 

dBSPL

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Ambassador
Messages
2,296
Reactions
96 11,842
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Not exactly. Kaan engine is one of the projects that money and manpower is directed.

Besides Kaan engine, there is TF6000/10000, TS1400, TS3000(Maybe not this exact name but engine for 10t helicopter) and various small engines that in design process. There might be derivetives from this engines as well(Maybe a marine engine from TF6000 or turboprop based on TS1400)

So when I say we don't have manpower or the money for the Hurjet engine, I mean TEI's hands are already full with the ongoing projects.
How many countries in the world, other than China and the United States, have so many simultaneous aviation engine programs?
 

hugh

Active member
Messages
103
Reactions
3 319
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
++
Additionally, a turboprop is planned over the TS1400, and an afterburner variant for the TF-6000.
Those are derivative engines. They're not trivial but they don't require a new core design, which is the bulk of the difficulty, imho.

Is turboprop version of TS1400 a certainty? Has TEI confirmed it?
 

Fairon

Well-known member
Messages
410
Reactions
6 1,023
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Those are derivative engines. They're not trivial but they don't require a new core design, which is the bulk of the difficulty, imho.

Is turboprop version of TS1400 a certainty? Has TEI confirmed it?

Not at the moment but couple of days ago there was a news that said Baykar showed interest. So it might happen if the news were true.
 

somegoodusername

Committed member
Messages
217
Reactions
2 362
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
That should raise questions about the KAAN engine,questions that most people outside Turkyie enthusiasts have already answered ,most people on this forum won't like the answer.....
There is no money or manpower available to develop an engine equivalent to the F-404 because Turkish Engine Industries is dedicating all its resources to the TF-35000. The second version of the Kaan will be produced with TF-35000 engines in first half of 2030's.
 

Costin1984

Active member
Messages
25
Reactions
48
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Romania
Dude comes from his reddit echo chamber and thinks he knows what's up. You better worry about your own Country @Costin1984
Actually no,I've been on defence related forums for almost half my adult life,which,obviously, doesn't make an expert.I did caution Turkish members in a now defunct forum that I can't see the Altay as a series manufactured tank, even back in 2014.I got the same violent response.
My opinion is mine alone,but I'm sticking to it,Turkiye doesn't have the expertise to serially manufacture a 4,let alone 5 generation, engine for the next 15 years,at least....
 

hugh

Active member
Messages
103
Reactions
3 319
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
My opinion is mine alone,but I'm sticking to it,Turkiye doesn't have the expertise to serially manufacture a 4,let alone 5 generation, engine for the next 15 years,at least....
maybe you should shed a little light on it and come up with actual technical rationale?
 

Costin1984

Active member
Messages
25
Reactions
48
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Romania
maybe you should shed a little light on it and come up with actual technical rationale?
My rationale is,that if you couldn't develop a tank engine in 10-12 years ,a jet engine for a 5th generation fighter is obviously a bridge to far.
Alas, I'm just a forumer but,as I've said in the old Pakistani forum 10 years ago,hopefully we'll all be here in 10 years to have the same chat.
In no way do I think, or know the truth about it all.
 

somegoodusername

Committed member
Messages
217
Reactions
2 362
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Actually no,I've been on defence related forums for almost half my adult life,which,obviously, doesn't make an expert.I did caution Turkish members in a now defunct forum that I can't see the Altay as a series manufactured tank, even back in 2014.I got the same violent response.
My opinion is mine alone,but I'm sticking to it,Turkiye doesn't have the expertise to serially manufacture a 4,let alone 5 generation, engine for the next 15 years,at least....
Altay is a political failure. Kaan and TF-35000 is an engineering challenge. Both TAI and TEI has world class expertise. TAI was one of the most important suppliers of the F-35 project, TEI supplying advanced engine parts for other engines for decades now. If you fly regularly, you probably flew with an TEI produced engine part. Neither of them starts from 0.
 

Costin1984

Active member
Messages
25
Reactions
48
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Romania
Altay is a political failure. Kaan and TF-35000 is an engineering challenge. Both TAI and TEI has world class expertise. TAI was one of the most important suppliers of the F-35 project, TEI supplying advanced engine parts for other engines for decades now. If you fly regularly, you probably flew with an TEI produced engine part. Neither of them starts from 0.
I don't want to derail the thread with other examples,so,I wish you the best of luck.
From a geopolitical point of view,as a Romanian altough long living abroad, a strong Turkiye offers a good counterpoint to our current position, so....cheers!
To each his own opinion
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom