• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

Live Conflict Syria After the Civil War

begturan

Well-known member
Messages
346
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Its over for Syria
Syria's startegic heights, and fresh water reserves, will forever be annexed by Israel


Israel's main goal was to completely occupy Damascus and establish a connection with the PKK via Deir ez-Zor, thus directing the wave of migration back to Turkey and gradually occupying all of Syria and planning to start a civil war in Turkey.

However, due to Turkey's rapid move and timely operation, they could not take Damascus, they were only able to occupy the Golan Heights at the moment.

Despite all of Israel's provocations, the current government of Syria is acting according to international law and legally seeking to remove the Israeli army from this region, which I believe is the right thing to do.

When a new war breaks out, Turkey will have to intervene in the situation, which will lead to the start of World War III and the necessity of using nuclear weapons.

Turkey and Syria will work with all their might to take back the Golan, which is a Turkmen region, and we will take back this right. Israel's lawless attitudes will soon be met with a reaction from all countries in the world.
 

Tonil

Committed member
Messages
168
Reactions
378
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Qatar
Israel's main goal was to completely occupy Damascus and establish a connection with the PKK via Deir ez-Zor, thus directing the wave of migration back to Turkey and gradually occupying all of Syria and planning to start a civil war in Turkey.

However, due to Turkey's rapid move and timely operation, they could not take Damascus, they were only able to occupy the Golan Heights at the moment.

Despite all of Israel's provocations, the current government of Syria is acting according to international law and legally seeking to remove the Israeli army from this region, which I believe is the right thing to do.

When a new war breaks out, Turkey will have to intervene in the situation, which will lead to the start of World War III and the necessity of using nuclear weapons.

Turkey and Syria will work with all their might to take back the Golan, which is a Turkmen region, and we will take back this right. Israel's lawless attitudes will soon be met with a reaction from all countries in the world.

Israel is actully damaging US foreign relations and actully secretly setting back the US interests decades and handing over allies to the other camp Russo-Sino indirectly. They are damaging western interests at this point and acting as 5th element against western interests and basically becoming a burden to them.

The US will have to eventually come to terms with that Israel is thorn in US interests especially as the US and EU have mended ties with Syria and Syria also want to be in the western camp. The US will have to eventually cut their losses short on Israel and sacrificing them to their fate if they do not change course.

They will have to exist the buffer zone or otherwise face military action and an all out war there is nothing in between really. Syria has accepted to honor the 1974 agreement if Israel refuses Syria reserves the right to attack and militarily bring the fight to Israel.
 

Saithan

Experienced member
Moderator
Denmark Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
9,857
Reactions
67 22,002
Nation of residence
Denmark
Nation of origin
Turkey
Israel is actully damaging US foreign relations and actully secretly setting back the US interests decades and handing over allies to the other camp Russo-Sino indirectly. They are damaging western interests at this point and acting as 5th element against western interests and basically becoming a burden to them.

The US will have to eventually come to terms with that Israel is thorn in US interests especially as the US and EU have mended ties with Syria and Syria also want to be in the western camp. The US will have to eventually cut their losses short on Israel and sacrificing them to their fate if they do not change course.

They will have to exist the buffer zone or otherwise face military action and an all out war there is nothing in between really. Syria has accepted to honor the 1974 agreement if Israel refuses Syria reserves the right to attack and militarily bring the fight to Israel.
Unfortunately, I can say you are wrong, only if you manage to institutionalize those relations can you truly make anything long term. Anything other than that, is short term, and short term is 20 years or so.

You need proper state institutions and education and doctrins to truly manifest a long lasting policy.

For instance the institutionalized hatred Armenia had for Türkiye is the way to do it, but since they were stuck in between that policy can only backfire on them. Whilst Israel with access to sea and trades can easily survive and keep their doctrin alive.
 

Tonil

Committed member
Messages
168
Reactions
378
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Qatar
Unfortunately, I can say you are wrong, only if you manage to institutionalize those relations can you truly make anything long term. Anything other than that, is short term, and short term is 20 years or so.

You need proper state institutions and education and doctrins to truly manifest a long lasting policy.

The Western policy is complex and sophisticated. The world is a multi-polar world currently and the Western policy is playing world hegemonic game which is looking at the bigger picture and gathering more allies which is pragmatic because in that way you starve the other camp and increases their stay. Israel has lately been thorn in their way for petite reasons that the US deems to be irrelevant. If it was up to them they would have asked right now the Americans to go into war with Turkey, Iran, Saudi arabia, Egypt and everybody they are not rational but at the end of the day Isreal is only a US outpost and nothing more if they fail to thaw the line they can face consequences because the Americans ain´t gonna fight for Israel over a small territory with Syria in what could potentially be the biggest war the region has ever seen.

Really not logical for the US foreign policy or western in that matter. The US is working on making something called the deal of the century which will include huge defense treaty signing with Saudi and others in the region. If the outpost Israel fails to recognize it´s role it will be gone if it pushes it´s luck further in places and areas it should not
 
Last edited:

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
Keep in mind that Natenyahu will visit Trump soon and will 100% try to force the US troops to remain in Syria since this will keep the PKK alive and in return aid in providing legitimacy for the annexed Syrian lands by Israel. I wont go and say how important and strategic the lands that Israel annexed from Syria are but I will tell you that it will be the bridgehead for annexing more lands in line with the greater Israel project

Finally, Natenyahu needs a victory to remain in power and we all know that he got semi-defeated in Gazza and Lebanon without being able to annex any lands yet.... the Israeli public needs gains on the ground to forgive Natenyahu and keep him in power
 

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
Translation:

Middle East Monitor:
"Israel is expected to provide military support to the PKK/YPG."

This support can be provided indirectly through the US and Western countries, or directly through intelligence, military training or advanced technologies.

Israel may seek to weaken Turkey and other regional rivals by supporting the PKK/YPG with military equipment.

 

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
11,418
Reactions
13 19,762
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Translation:

Middle East Monitor:
"Israel is expected to provide military support to the PKK/YPG."

This support can be provided indirectly through the US and Western countries, or directly through intelligence, military training or advanced technologies.

Israel may seek to weaken Turkey and other regional rivals by supporting the PKK/YPG with military equipment.


Remember when I said Israel is a bigger threat to Turkiye than the Arab countries and Iran put together.

Instead we had a lot of people foaming over some bullshit non existent Turkiye-Israel alliance.
 

Saithan

Experienced member
Moderator
Denmark Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
9,857
Reactions
67 22,002
Nation of residence
Denmark
Nation of origin
Turkey
Remember when I said Israel is a bigger threat to Turkiye than the Arab countries and Iran put together.

Instead we had a lot of people foaming over some bullshit non existent Turkiye-Israel alliance.
It's is only because the government doesn't seem to clean up the PKK in Syria, giving our adversaries time to shuffle the cards and get better hands against us.

I've said it before unless you change the facts on the grounds with force you can not expect the good cards in our hands to remain good.
 

Mis_TR_Like

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
1,981
Reactions
50 7,515
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Northern Cyprus
Remember when I said Israel is a bigger threat to Turkiye than the Arab countries and Iran put together.

Instead we had a lot of people foaming over some bullshit non existent Turkiye-Israel alliance.

Israel is the only smart nation in a region of idiots.

Iran became an Islamic shithole overnight and Türkiye has been put to sleep by the Erdoğan regime.

Israel now has free rein to do whatever it wants. And guess what, we won't do anything about it. Israel will complete its goal of expanding, possibly even gaining a second KRG in Syria. Meanwhile, we will make peace with PKK because AKP can no longer pretend that it is a nationalist party. For the next few years nationalist opposition will be silenced and jailed whilst PKK and AKP shake hands. Islamists will continue to vote for AKP because CHP and Zafer partisi are run by the devil, meanwhile AKP will also get kurdish votes. All while Israel's influence grows. But hey, that doesn't matter because Erdoğan will warn them and also accuse the opposition of being supported by Mossad, and thus bring back any naughty Islamists who even dared to think of voting for someone else.

Israel isn't the enemy, Iran isn't the enemy, Russia isn't the enemy and nor is the US the enemy. The enemy is within.
 

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
11,418
Reactions
13 19,762
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Israel is the only smart nation in a region of idiots.

Iran became an Islamic shithole overnight and Türkiye has been put to sleep by the Erdoğan regime.

Israel now has free rein to do whatever it wants. And guess what, we won't do anything about it. Israel will complete its goal of expanding, possibly even gaining a second KRG in Syria. Meanwhile, we will make peace with PKK because AKP can no longer pretend that it is a nationalist party. For the next few years nationalist opposition will be silenced and jailed whilst PKK and AKP shake hands. Islamists will continue to vote for AKP because CHP and Zafer partisi are run by the devil, meanwhile AKP will also get kurdish votes. All while Israel's influence grows. But hey, that doesn't matter because Erdoğan will warn them and also accuse the opposition of being supported by Mossad, and thus bring back any naughty Islamists who even dared to think of voting for someone else.

Israel isn't the enemy, Iran isn't the enemy, Russia isn't the enemy and nor is the US the enemy. The enemy is within.

Turkiye beats around the bush far too much.

The inaction really pisses me off now the Pkk terrorists are utilising fpv drones blew up a T155.

Erdogan doesnt care because his a paranoid fckwit because if the Turkish military is strong he fears he will be brought down. Then again you have corruption that can be rife in Turkish republic. 100% sure any politician or civilian worker are like who needs countermeasures against fpvs when we can pocket the money and spend it on w*ores.

If he cant do anything about the pkk he might as well resign. Pathetic just like Davutoglu.
 

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
It's is only because the government doesn't seem to clean up the PKK in Syria, giving our adversaries time to shuffle the cards and get better hands against us.

I've said it before unless you change the facts on the grounds with force you can not expect the good cards in our hands to remain good.
"Doesnt seem to clean the PKK"?

To change the facts on the ground, you need to confront the US soldiers protecting the PKK
That is why Erdogan is trying to make the US leave so that he can confront the PKK however Israel, the PKK, and the pentagon wants to remain on ground because they know that if a US soldier got injured during the upcoming Turkish-PKK war, the US will have a reason to obtain massive concessions from Turkey or raze it to the ground

Rather than blindly attacking the govt, you should appreciate that they managed to kick Russia, Iran, and Assad out and increase its control over the Syrian lands from 10-15% to a massive 70%

I understand ppl's hatred towards Erdo but give credit where its due
 

Saithan

Experienced member
Moderator
Denmark Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
9,857
Reactions
67 22,002
Nation of residence
Denmark
Nation of origin
Turkey
"Doesnt seem to clean the PKK"?

To change the facts on the ground, you need to confront the US soldiers protecting the PKK
That is why Erdogan is trying to make the US leave so that he can confront the PKK however Israel, the PKK, and the pentagon wants to remain on ground because they know that if a US soldier got injured during the upcoming Turkish-PKK war, the US will have a reason to obtain massive concessions from Turkey or raze it to the ground

Rather than blindly attacking the govt, you should appreciate that they managed to kick Russia, Iran, and Assad out and increase its control over the Syrian lands from 10-15% to a massive 70%

I understand ppl's hatred towards Erdo but give credit where its due

What you are saying is TSK is unable to conduct operation in regions where the US has bases, as if their influence is big enough to warrant as deterrent.

Because of the civilian control over the military, TSK speed to conduct operations has been rendered obsolete. So the politicians have found out that Erdogan is afraid of consequences of not being reelected or AKP losing control, so it's easier to passify Turkey by threatening the economy.

That is a mistake, because while RTE chickens out the cards in his hand become obsolete.

EU won't ease sanctions unless Syria accepts refugees back. So EU will be free of their burden, while Türkiye will have some 3-4 million refugees in camps. And on top of that they will sanctions us if we start an operation.

It would be best to do these operations as soon as possible.
 

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
What you are saying is TSK is unable to conduct operation in regions where the US has bases, as if their influence is big enough to warrant as deterrent.
Yes Iam
Turkey, no matter how strong it is rn, cant conduct an operation where the US troops are located and without US approval. Facts are facts and Turkey isnt on par with the US yet to warrant going against each other
Because of the civilian control over the military, TSK speed to conduct operations has been rendered obsolete. So the politicians have found out that Erdogan is afraid of consequences of not being reelected or AKP losing control, so it's easier to passify Turkey by threatening the economy.
Please give me one strong, properly advanced, nation whose military isnt controlled by a civilian administration? An independent army is literally a fertile ground for corruption; just look at Africa as a reference

Pls tell me what guarantee will such a power structure not warrant coups? Havent you learned from FETO or previous coup attempts in the history of the republic? What on earth will you do when a corrupt dictator rules the military and make Turkey a living hell?

The West have been utilising this power structure to attempt coups worldwide against those leaders who dont meet their agendas. Why do you think the West plotted a coup against Erdo in the first place? Its because he went against their narrative and stimulated the defence industry as well as went against the PKK. Just look at Gabar which has been freed from terrorism and the potential oil reserves it has
That is a mistake, because while RTE chickens out the cards in his hand become obsolete.
Let me tell you something mate.....
The army is just one side of the nation. If the army acted independently while the rest of the nation suffers, then what is the use of acting out in the first place

Lets say, hypothetically, that the army is independent and that it acted and destroyed the PKK which will obviously prompt sanctions that may cripple the current Turkey and increase poverty even more than the horrid situation Turkey is in rn.... then what? People will revolt due to bad living conditions and they will put a leader who listens to the West in order to cease sanctions which will prompt a retreat from Syria and the PKK will just grow back
EU won't ease sanctions unless Syria accepts refugees back. So EU will be free of their burden, while Türkiye will have some 3-4 million refugees in camps. And on top of that they will sanctions us if we start an operation.
Fq Europe, its era is over!.... Turkey can resist Europe to a degree and its sanctions will damage but not cripple Turkey but not the US.
The US is still the monolithic structure in the Western hegemony. Just look at the events regarding Trump desire to acquire greenland; did Denmark state that they will resist even if it meant using force? Did Denmark announce or even move their military to secure Greenland? NO!! It is because all of Europe knows that if the US wants Greenland, then it will get it whether Europe likes it or not.
It would be best to do these operations as soon as possible.
Agreed a million percent💯💯💯
However, a president (regardless of whether its Erdo or not) must consider the issue from all of its sides in order to gain the most and reduce the losses since terrorism and people's general economic affairs are both a part of his job description

Honestly, even I am fuming over the fact that TSK can go and finally destroy the PKK yet cant but I also understand how big of a deterrent and a monster the US actually is and I respect Erdo for even managing to play his hands and increase his influence in Syria amidst those conditions. Iam on pins and needles but all what I can say is lets see what will happen within the next month or so

If the US retreats, its over for the PKK and all warring factions in Syria knows that and Turkey has been increasing the number of troops located close to Ayn Al Arab (Kobani) for a while now
 

AlperTunga

Committed member
Messages
253
Reactions
5 335
Nation of residence
Switzerland
Nation of origin
Turkey
"Doesnt seem to clean the PKK"?

To change the facts on the ground, you need to confront the US soldiers protecting the PKK
That is why Erdogan is trying to make the US leave so that he can confront the PKK however Israel, the PKK, and the pentagon wants to remain on ground because they know that if a US soldier got injured during the upcoming Turkish-PKK war, the US will have a reason to obtain massive concessions from Turkey or raze it to the ground

Rather than blindly attacking the govt, you should appreciate that they managed to kick Russia, Iran, and Assad out and increase its control over the Syrian lands from 10-15% to a massive 70%

I understand ppl's hatred towards Erdo but give credit where its due
American soldiers were there when we conducted the previous operations. I think the reason is rather Erdogan wanting to be reelected again. He is not Ecevit who weighed country‘s long term interests more heavily. Türkiye has suffered so much in the last 15 years because of personal view focused international politics as well as religious based economic decisions. In general, Türkiye has suffered so much from instrumentalisation of religion. Both Atatürk and CHP was wrong because they went so much against it and AKP was also wrong in its reaction. We as a nation couldnt learn that we need to respect religion but it is something that should be personal and not imposed on the society.
 

AlperTunga

Committed member
Messages
253
Reactions
5 335
Nation of residence
Switzerland
Nation of origin
Turkey
Yes Iam
Turkey, no matter how strong it is rn, cant conduct an operation where the US troops are located and without US approval. Facts are facts and Turkey isnt on par with the US yet to warrant going against each other

Please give me one strong, properly advanced, nation whose military isnt controlled by a civilian administration? An independent army is literally a fertile ground for corruption; just look at Africa as a reference

Pls tell me what guarantee will such a power structure not warrant coups? Havent you learned from FETO or previous coup attempts in the history of the republic? What on earth will you do when a corrupt dictator rules the military and make Turkey a living hell?

The West have been utilising this power structure to attempt coups worldwide against those leaders who dont meet their agendas. Why do you think the West plotted a coup against Erdo in the first place? Its because he went against their narrative and stimulated the defence industry as well as went against the PKK. Just look at Gabar which has been freed from terrorism and the potential oil reserves it has

Let me tell you something mate.....
The army is just one side of the nation. If the army acted independently while the rest of the nation suffers, then what is the use of acting out in the first place

Lets say, hypothetically, that the army is independent and that it acted and destroyed the PKK which will obviously prompt sanctions that may cripple the current Turkey and increase poverty even more than the horrid situation Turkey is in rn.... then what? People will revolt due to bad living conditions and they will put a leader who listens to the West in order to cease sanctions which will prompt a retreat from Syria and the PKK will just grow back

Fq Europe, its era is over!.... Turkey can resist Europe to a degree and its sanctions will damage but not cripple Turkey but not the US.
The US is still the monolithic structure in the Western hegemony. Just look at the events regarding Trump desire to acquire greenland; did Denmark state that they will resist even if it meant using force? Did Denmark announce or even move their military to secure Greenland? NO!! It is because all of Europe knows that if the US wants Greenland, then it will get it whether Europe likes it or not.

Agreed a million percent💯💯💯
However, a president (regardless of whether its Erdo or not) must consider the issue from all of its sides in order to gain the most and reduce the losses since terrorism and people's general economic affairs are both a part of his job description

Honestly, even I am fuming over the fact that TSK can go and finally destroy the PKK yet cant but I also understand how big of a deterrent and a monster the US actually is and I respect Erdo for even managing to play his hands and increase his influence in Syria amidst those conditions. Iam on pins and needles but all what I can say is lets see what will happen within the next month or so

If the US retreats, its over for the PKK and all warring factions in Syria knows that and Turkey has been increasing the number of troops located close to Ayn Al Arab (Kobani) for a while now
The easiest way out is to give security guarantees to Israel but otherwise warn them very severely that if they stick to the pkk project then they will be considered enemy number one. They have to decide which one is better: pkk state with dubious marginal benefits to them or Türkiye as enemy. This should be made clear to US as well. We will converge in terms of technology and grow so not a wise choice for them. But I am sure they are also betting on Imamoglu type gov in the future, so we need commitment from the deep state here,
 

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
American soldiers were there when we conducted the previous operations. I think the reason is rather Erdogan wanting to be reelected again. He is not Ecevit who weighed country‘s long term interests more heavily. Türkiye has suffered so much in the last 15 years because of personal view focused international politics as well as religious based economic decisions. In general, Türkiye has suffered so much from instrumentalisation of religion. Both Atatürk and CHP was wrong because they went so much against it and AKP was also wrong in its reaction. We as a nation couldnt learn that we need to respect religion but it is something that should be personal and not imposed on the society.
I agree that US soldiers where there when Turkey conducted its operation long ago

However, what you dont know is that just before the operation was conducted, Erdogan and Trump both reached a deal in which the US would retreat a certain number of kilometers and from certain areas where PKK activities was the highest since at that time, suicide bombings and terrorist attacks within Turkish soil was just way too much that Turkey had the legitimacy and the excuse to intervene while Trump didnt have any excuse to reject Turkey and didnt want to make an enemy of the Turkish public at the time

Even Trump admitted that he allowed Turkey to conduct its previous operation as he couldnt say no to Turkey's reasons
 

AlperTunga

Committed member
Messages
253
Reactions
5 335
Nation of residence
Switzerland
Nation of origin
Turkey
I agree that US soldiers where there when Turkey conducted its operation long ago

However, what you dont know is that just before the operation was conducted, Erdogan and Trump both reached a deal in which the US would retreat a certain number of kilometers and from certain areas where PKK activities was the highest since at that time, suicide bombings and terrorist attacks within Turkish soil was just way too much that Turkey had the legitimacy and the excuse to intervene while Trump didnt have any excuse to reject Turkey and didnt want to make an enemy of the Turkish public at the time

Even Trump admitted that he allowed Turkey to conduct its previous operation as he couldnt say no to Turkey's reasons
It is unbearable that a country 10000km away comes to our backyard and tells us what to do. If its interests here are essential then yes they will have the upper hand. But if their gain here is only marginal whereas for us it is almost life or death then we should be able to dictate whst happens in our backyard. Are you saying we cannot harm them at all so that they will overrule us even for a peny? You may be right. But then as a nation we should work like crazy. America should know if they bring their air carriers to Med then we will destroy at least the half.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,055
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
American soldiers were there when we conducted the previous operations
American soldiers were there with us in 2016. But in 2019 in Peace Spring, they pulled back from the operation area 3 days before with Trump's command.
 
Top Bottom