E
Naturally - because aside from oil and gas - Russia has been a main spot for Western investments - and no one incl. the EU can afford to lose that market.For some peculiar reason, European leaders want to preserve Putin's face. Nobody wants to mess with the gas station which will fall into small states and not be able to secure its nuclear potential.
Initiate? you mean to stop or slow down?So far the help has been sufficient to initiate Russian Army advance toward its borders from Kyiv and Harkov.
Come on let's stay realistic.10 Caesars more will ruin the Russian Army for sure.
My analysis is purely based on economic and military data - Russian aggression, human rights violations, etc. do not factor into this analysis, that would be a different topic.Butcha and Irpin have been convincing examples of how the Russian Army will treat civilians after Russia visits any country.
No it isn't - and especially not if this war drags on for another 12-24 monthInflation is a bearable price to pay.
I was referring to Russia's military reserves - not the reserves of it's Central BankPlease present your evidence,? As of my knowledge, about 500 billion USD worth of RU central bank reserves are frozen in west.
According to several Western media reports via NATO sources - it's no secret and can be read upon.Hmm, any proof about that?
Sorry - again the analysis of the military situation, is a different topic from freedom, rape, etc.Do you really think it is a blessing to become a part of Russki Mir? Estonians learned it a hard way- surrender does not help, a big part of the nation will be killed, imprisoned, enslaved, and raped anyway. Finns did not surrender in the 1940-s and lost fewer people, eventually. Why should it be different in the current case?
Blackmail? Russia isn't forcing the USA or the EU to buy precious minerals. It was and presently remains their choice of supplier. Dumb Trump regarding such "dependency" issues already declared Billion $ investments 4-5 years ago. Obviously nothing has been done. Because in the end all this rethoric ends up in $ and cents.Kind of blackmailing, is it not? So let them enjoy it until they can.
Democracies entirely depend on the goodwill and economic well being of their citizens, that is why usually every 4 years the government's intentions shift, or is replaced by another ruling party beholding another agenda.Hereby you might be right. Still, the timing for price blackmail is the worst there can be. In the middle of the heat wave? Thing is, Europe pays well, and China not so well at all. Should one kill a goose laying golden eggs? Kind of stupid, if anyone asks from me...
Enough to bleed out Russia, look how much Russian advancement in Ukraine slowed.In form of drippings? USA maybe 12 instead of 4 MLRS systems? France sending another 5 Caesar's?
Oh really? A bnig chunk of Russian monetary assets are frozen, apart from that they started sending old gear to Ukraine, if they still have reserves then what are they waiting for. Where are the T90's? The airforce? why did Rocket and Artillery strikes decrese? Where is Russian navy? What happened to amphibious attack on Odessa?According to who? western Media? - or substantial confirmed evidence? Russia so far hasn't even begun to substantially tap it's reserves.
Same can be said about Russian army, add to that the huge humiliation in the first month of the invasion and failed capture of Kiev and Khakiv. So far Ukraine has been holding way better agains a much stronger enemy than anyone expected, first and foremost the Russians can comfirm that.The Ukraine forces are facing increased desertion and lowering moral issues (according to Western media and NATO sources) and it is going to get worse since so far the UAF can't see any viable success or achievements.
Decreasing Russian gas share on european market will take time but is definitely doable in the next couple years, all the west has to do is to keep Russia in chek in the mean time which is easy to do seeing the performance of their armed forces.Would you have any confirmed figures as to the $ value of oil and gas - reduced by EU and possible value of oil and gas being supplied by Russia to other customers?
In regards to e.g. titanium and other precious minerals both the EU and the USA keep buying - just as before.
Are you sure that the EU citizens will just simply accept e.g. Euro 2.60+/l at the gas station and continious rising inflation without causing repercussions towards their present government's and their internal political coalitions?
Bleeding out Russia will take years - years that NATO and the Ukraine don't have.Enough to bleed out Russia, look how much Russian advancement in Ukraine slowed.
yes, Russia is bound to take an economical it - but it's nowhere going to be near a collapse.Oh really? A bnig chunk of Russian monetary assets are frozen,
Old gear for the DNLR forces to rearguard occupied territoryapart from that they started sending old gear to Ukraine,
Waiting for the time where they might need them - presently Russia is obviously not in need and therefore not making use of themif they still have reserves then what are they waiting for.
Kept in reserve in case NATO decides to escalate - just as NATO is not willing to give away it's part of deterenceWhere are the T90's? The airforce?
Would you have a source or statistic to proof that?why did Rocket and Artillery strikes decrese?
Not really existing in force in the Black-Sea and obviously far to vulnerable to missile or drone attacks. But their Sub's are continually engaged in firing missiles and taking on new ones.Where is Russian navy?
When was that supposedly planed? and with what non-existing Russian amphibious forces is it supposed to take place? - excluding some possible commando raids.What happened to amphibious attack on Odessa?
Certainly the RF and the DNLR aren't in high spirits - but they are not "freedom" and "democracy" oriented military units - unlike those of the Ukraine.Same can be said about Russian army, add to that the huge humiliation in the first month of the invasion and failed capture of Kiev and Khakiv.
Taking into account that the UAF had almost 8 years time to plan, setup and fortify it's defensive lines and positions and that both the UAF and the RF with their DNLR forces are more or less equally matched - I really don't see the UAF "holding way better".So far Ukraine has been holding way better agains a much stronger enemy than anyone expected, first and foremost the Russians can comfirm that.
i wasn't refering to the gas and oil business that Russia might lose from end of 2022 onward, but as to how much of that loss are they able to compensate via new customers.Decreasing Russian gas share on european market will take time but is definitely doable in the next couple years, all the west has to do is to keep Russia in chek in the mean time which is easy to do seeing the performance of their armed forces.
A Share of 35% can be replaced until 2025.
How Europe can cut natural gas imports from Russia significantly within a year
View attachment 45101
Why not? Who do you think is on the shorter end when its about financing the conflict? Ukraine has no problem here, the west will supply them whatever is needed, its Russia thats running out of time.Bleeding out Russia will take years - years that NATO and the Ukraine don't have.
Indeed there is only a slow-motion-steamroller advance by Russia if at all - however Ukraine hasn't been able to stop it, not to mention regaining any significant territory size since April.
Doesnt need a collapse to loose the war.yes, Russia is bound to take an economical it - but it's nowhere going to be near a collapse.
Is its russian plan to stall in kind of a stalemate?Waiting for the time where they might need them - presently Russia is obviously not in need and therefore not making use of them
The T90's will be sitting ducks if NATO truly decides to escalate, Russian gear is simply no match against western equivalents.Kept in reserve in case NATO decides to escalate - just as NATO is not willing to give away it's part of deterence
There was a graph that was posted a month or so ago by a member in this thread, could be @500 im not sure, other than that i obviously didnt make my own stats yet anyone who followed the war from the beginning can confirm the intensity of missile attacks has great decreased, so did the use of airforce.Would you have a source or statistic to proof that?
Russia deployed three tank landing ships in Black sea early february this year, those are not there for decoration, they were sailing close to Odessa for weeks until Moskva disaster happened.When was that supposedly planed? and with what non-existing Russian amphibious forces is it supposed to take place? - excluding some possible commando raids.
Ukraine didnt really prepare, what they need is modern airforce and air defence with ABM capabilities which is not being suplied by the west, heck even manpads and anti tank got supplied after Russian invasion.Taking into account that the UAF had almost 8 years time to plan, setup and fortify it's defensive lines and positions and that both the UAF and the RF with their DNLR forces are more or less equally matched - I really don't see the UAF "holding way better".
According to military doctrine an attacker needs to field approx. 3 times the numbers of a defender. I don't see Russia having 700-800,000 men in action. But due to their missile forces and artillery superiority they are able to hold ground and gain considerable ground since end of April.
As said diversifying energy sources and investing in modern technologies, heating for exsample, it can be done by heat pumps, the new buildings rarely get a gas or oil heating system, if anything only as backup system but not main system.i wasn't refering to the gas and oil business that Russia might lose from end of 2022 onward, but as to how much of that loss are they able to compensate via new customers.
Lenin said it well- useful idiots. Capitalists will sell hanging rope meant for themselves if it will bring 300% profit. Regarding the investments in Russia- it is lost already, but probably have been fully paid off decades ago.Naturally - because aside from oil and gas - Russia has been a main spot for Western investments - and no one incl. the EU can afford to lose that market.
Two words: wishful thinking. Obviously, you do not imagine how rich European societies are. Imagine a choice: to be brutally raped, robbed, and killed or not to buy a new car this year? That will be an easy sale for politicians.No it isn't - and especially not if this war drags on for another 12-24 month
Right, you mean the rare pieces of equipment which are still not looted by Russians themselves? As they say: мечтат не вредно (nothing bad comes from dreaming). Dumb bombs remain the Russian strongest assets and just because it is useless to steal those.I was referring to Russia's military reserves - not the reserves of it's Central Bank
Somewhat true, but not entirely. The military is very costly and free societies do not like to spend on it too much unless absolutely necessary. Sweden has given up 200 years of neutrality and chose to join NATO just because of Russian aggression in Ukraine. Israel, a democratic country, by all means, has the most advanced military setting in the region because of the imminent threat from Iran and alike. Finland has the most advanced artillery in Europe because of- how to put it nicely- truly beloved peacemongering eastern neighbor. It will take time for a democratic society to step out of the convenience zone, but it will happen inevitably if there is an urgent necessity. Miracles will happen, otherwise, democracy has been wiped out thousands of years ago.Democracies entirely depend on the goodwill and economic well being of their citizens, that is why usually every 4 years the government's intentions shift, or is replaced by another ruling party beholding another agenda.
And this is what makes a long term planing (beholding specific agendas) more or less impossible.
ravenman you are an zaza and pro akp please keep your Ideas to yourself. You might have those sweet sweet euros but average turk doesn't we cant even afford meat ffsSome (Western) social media fairytales:
1.- 'Russia's economy will fall!'
2.- 'Turkish people are hungry!'
3.- 'Homosexuality is genetic!'
4.- 'Humans are causing climatechange!'
Nearly $100 billion worth of deals signed in Saint Petersburg
Nearly 700 deals worth almost $100 billion were signed during the annual economic forum in Russiawww.rt.com
Imagine your air force still doing WW2 style rockets runs because you lack the technology this isn't some third world country Its the strongest second army in the world even small Turkey has better PGMs.Russian POW allegedy captured at Sievierodonetsk:
Ru SU-25 pilot captured:
72 ОМБр ім.Чорних Запорожців
А ось і пілот намалювався. Живий трофеї 72-ї ОМБ. ім Чорних Запорожців. Наші військовики надали знімання пілота збитого російського Су-25, який встиг катапультуватися. Чоловік живий, має травми через "м'яке" приземлення, йому надали першу допомогу, він в надійних та дбайливих руках ЗСУ. @ombr72t.me
Ravenman we got it you like WW2 era germany and hate westerners lmaoUkraine is lost. Its game over but nobody wants to admit it.
Well - let's wait and see as to how the situation presents itself by October - till then we simply agree to disagree.Why not? Who do you think is on the shorter end when its about financing the conflict? Ukraine has no problem here, the west will supply them whatever is needed, its Russia thats running out of time.
Doesnt need a collapse to loose the war.
Is its russian plan to stall in kind of a stalemate?
The T90's will be sitting ducks if NATO truly decides to escalate, Russian gear is simply no match against western equivalents.
There was a graph that was posted a month or so ago by a member in this thread, could be @500 im not sure, other than that i obviously didnt make my own stats yet anyone who followed the war from the beginning can confirm the intensity of missile attacks has great decreased, so did the use of airforce.
Russia was sending choppers and fighters in waves in the first weeks which is obviously not the case anymore.
The fact that they still didnt establish air superiority yet, nor conduct night missions or at least use precision giuded munition is a great reminder of the limited capabilities of their forces.
Russia deployed three tank landing ships in Black sea early february this year, those are not there for decoration, they were sailing close to Odessa for weeks until Moskva disaster happened.
View attachment 45102
Ukraine didnt really prepare, what they need is modern airforce and air defence with ABM capabilities which is not being suplied by the west, heck even manpads and anti tank got supplied after Russian invasion.
How is Russia gonna field that many men when even the current forces walk around with rubber wests and steel helmets? They cant supply their troops on the frontline, soldiers get expired rations and those are the lucky ones who get food at all.
As said diversifying energy sources and investing in modern technologies, heating for exsample, it can be done by heat pumps, the new buildings rarely get a gas or oil heating system, if anything only as backup system but not main system.
The share of Russian energy can be decreased significantly in short and middle term.
View attachment 45103
View attachment 45104
https://www.energymonitor.ai/policy/how-can-the-eu-end-its-dependence-on-russian-gas