Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Indonesia still has wide margin to be playing at, unless the politician above doesn't fiddle much on political stunts based economy policy just like Dana Desa and 1000 magic cards program

You Know what, I just notice thus programm is ridicullously miraculous. How the hell in earth they have so much money to be put on Covid mitigation, magic & trap cards, Dana Desa, and so on but not so eager in Defence Spending.

Those resources mostly goes unnoticed and doesn't tranlated into real hard power and increasing the talent cultivation too much
Well, yes.
Those money I confidiently say 50% or more has gone to private pocket and less realization. Roughly you can buy at least 10 America-class each fiscal year by using Dana Desa budget alone.


The highest ceilling for percentage of military spending over their gdp is around four percentage in history means the highest ceilling for military expenditure of around 24 to 28 billion US Dollar.
Just realize their Defence budget today is not even exceed Indonesia, but for our case is it right most portion of defence budget goes to salary and maintenance ?

Somehow, I didn't even think todays defence budget is fix. Somehow they just can fetch random billion dollar money out of nowhere.
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
489
Reactions
3 411
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
They get F35, U-218, etc..
kenapa insecure...
udah lama mereka ga ada yang nandingi di kawasan SEA, indonesia beli ini itu malah panik.
they do what they must do, masalahnya, resource yg udah mereka keuarkan/ % PDB untuk militernya sudah besar, singapore itu 2023 sudah mencapai 2,3 % PDB, ruang sudah sempit, sedangkan Indonesia, baru 0,73 %. dengan 0,73 % sudah bisa beli rafale senilai 8 BIllion US dollars, apalagi jadi 2 %. masalahnya, fokus rezim ini ekonomi no 1, dan yg dibangun adalah proyek jangka panjang semua, tidak mudah membelokkan anggarannya.
 

Parry Brima

Contributor
Messages
982
Reactions
1 1,057
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
They get F35, U-218, etc..
kenapa insecure...
udah lama mereka ga ada yang nandingi di kawasan SEA, indonesia beli ini itu malah panik.

Who says that they are insecure? They don't have any single reason whatsoever to be insecure of us.

We publicly announce our budget every year. Everybody knows (not just them) that our budget is minuscule.

It should be us who feel insecure of them. Sadly apart from TNI & MoD, it seems that nobody cares.
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
489
Reactions
3 411
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
Who says that they are insecure? They don't have any single reason whatsoever to be insecure of us.

We publicly announce our budget every year. Everybody knows (not just them) that our budget is minuscule.

It should be us who feel insecure of them. Sadly apart from TNI & MoD, it seems that nobody cares.
simply logic, small one always afraid/insecure to the big one, even the big only had big bone no muscle
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
2,924
Reactions
3 2,496
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Well we sent bomb to them in the past, and also there was konfrontasi that's why Singapore (and also Malaysia) have the right to be ketar ketir, although our relationship with them is good and very unlikely that there will be a war.
More likely a frequent war on the internet between netizens.
 

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,589
Reactions
1 2,530
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Well we sent bomb to them in the past, and also there was konfrontasi that's why Singapore (and also Malaysia) have the right to be ketar ketir,
Also we named one of the surface combatant as KRI Usman Harun
 

Soman45

Well-known member
Messages
301
Reactions
569
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
kalo di-pikir" pendapat ini make sense juga, dengan bobot full load segitu pasti harus dipanjangin dan dirombak habis desain-nya (Singapore ada duitlah) atau kalo masih keukeuh dengan ukuran Absalon maka ada resiko overweight kaya kasus Baden-Württemberg class nya jerman padahal panjang F125 udah 149 m dan bobotnya "cuma" 7.200 t, tapi apapun itu kalo kapal ini jadi sesuai kontraknya 6 unit, bakalan jadi mini carrier dan memperkukuh posisi Singapore di antara tetangga dan sulit disalip kalo nggak bener" niat
 
Last edited:

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,589
Reactions
1 2,530
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
kapal ini jadi sesuai kontraknya 6 unit, bakalan jadi mini carrier dan memperkukuh posisi Singapore di antara tetangga dan sulit disalip kalo nggak bener" niat
habis itu tahun depan Singapore ngumumin mulai bikin 3 LHD/JMMS gantiin LPD mereka wkwk, ALRI tambah ketinggalan
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
kalo di-pikir" pendapat ini make sense juga, dengan bobot full load segitu pasti harus dipanjangin dan dirombak habis desain-nya (Singapore ada duitlah) atau kalo masih keukeuh dengan ukuran Absalon maka ada resiko overweight kaya kasus Baden-Württemberg class nya jerman padahal panjang F125 udah 149 m dan bobotnya "cuma" 7.200 t, tapi apapun itu kalo kapal ini jadi sesuai kontraknya 6 unit, bakalan jadi mini carrier dan memperkukuh posisi Singapore di antara tetangga dan sulit disalip kalo nggak bener" niat
sebetulnya jika galangan mampu dan desainer kapal bisa mengatasi Flaws yg mungkin akan terjadi bisa saja dibuat dengan bobot 10k ton.

Pelebaran dan pemanjangan dari basis kapal yg sudah ada juga possible kok, cuma mungkin tidak terlalu viable untuk beberapa sisi. Mungkin aku bisa ambil contoh Collins class, gotland yg diperbesar dengan ekspektasi bisa sebagai proyeksi blue water navy malah banyak problem.
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
2,924
Reactions
3 2,496
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Gak terlalu bikin ketar ketir sih tapi bikin pengen aja.
Tapi kalo yang belinya itu kita, banyak yang bakalan langsung panas dingin ketar ketir.
 

R4duga

Experienced member
Messages
1,670
Reactions
2 2,367
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Spesifikasi FREMM NG seperti apa?
1680018376877.png
 

Parry Brima

Contributor
Messages
982
Reactions
1 1,057
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Well we sent bomb to them in the past, and also there was konfrontasi that's why Singapore (and also Malaysia) have the right to be ketar ketir, although our relationship with them is good and very unlikely that there will be a war.
More likely a frequent war on the internet between netizens.

Malaysia have every reason to be insecure even ketar-ketir of us. Their leaders quality and defense commitment are similar or even worse than us.

Singapore is totally different case.
 
Top Bottom