• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

TR Air-Force TF-X KAAN Fighter Jet

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,654
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I wonder what people expect Kale to put in the TF35 project while TEI already have 300 engineers working on the job for several years now. It is not about making Kale useful for the project but making the project useful for Kale. TEI only need to be pressured to work faster if need be.
 
Last edited:

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
4,277
Reactions
263 22,342
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
The best possible scenario is; SSB encouraged TEI/TrMotor to start working on preliminary design stage and As a result, they have been working since 2/3 years and the number of engineers in program exceeded to 300. Later, SSB likely announce the winner as TrMotor/TEI/IP partnership, and later Kale also join the big club as development partner for Tf35K.
Ivchenko Progress was asked by TRMotor, to design an APU for KAAN-TFX. It is most likely that their input is limited with that contribution.
I honestly can’t see a company that has no working engines that they may have designed since Soviet era, to be able to contribute anything to a design that is 35-40 years ahead of anything that they already have.

If SSB were to award the TF35K engine to Kale-RR consortium with TEI being a party to produce parts, then we may have just about a chance to see a locally produced engine powering and flying KAAN by 2028.
Otherwise if we are to faff around with TRMotor/Ivchenko Progress etc, it won’t be before early 2030s when we have an indigenous engine powering our KAAN-TFX.
In RR, we are talking about a company that can turn around a working demonstrator prototype engine for FCAS, from nothing within 18 months.
Having been a party to the development of F136 engine with GE and have the right tools such as additive production techniques for Blisk manufacturing and single crystal turbine blades, they are the right address to achieve what we want in this late hour of the day!

 

Cabatli_TR

Experienced member
Administrator
Messages
5,362
Reactions
81 45,473
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Ivchenko Progress was asked by TRMotor, to design an APU for KAAN-TFX. It is most likely that their input is limited with that contribution.
I honestly can’t see a company that has no working engines that they may have designed since Soviet era, to be able to contribute anything to a design that is 35-40 years ahead of anything that they already have.

If SSB were to award the TF35K engine to Kale-RR consortium with TEI being a party to produce parts, then we may have just about a chance to see a locally produced engine powering and flying KAAN by 2028.
Otherwise if we are to faff around with TRMotor/Ivchenko Progress etc, it won’t be before early 2030s when we have an indigenous engine powering our KAAN-TFX.
In RR, we are talking about a company that can turn around a working demonstrator prototype engine for FCAS, from nothing within 18 months.
Having been a party to the development of F136 engine with GE and have the right tools such as additive production techniques for Blisk manufacturing and single crystal turbine blades, they are the right address to achieve what we want in this late hour of the day!


I think Things aren't going as expected with UK. The contribution of BAE in TFX Phase-1 was very mediocre with mostly inexperienced engineers and Tusaş complained about this situation a few times. As for engine to be likely developed with RR, RR put strong cards on table both in terms of license rights and production since they feel that Turkiye don't have an alternative way out of their offer. Also, Some reluctant statements by Turkish officials regarding possible deal with BAE for TFX Phase-2 were reflected in the press. Turkiye's cooperation offers for Tempest were also rejected by UK. The withdrawal of British royal air force which was said to join the last AnatolianEagle exercise also created question marks. Apart from this, there is a serious political confrontation and embargo from the West in almost every field, be them enlargement of NATO, terror operations or Russia/Ukraine war. Considering these conditions, TEI/TrMotor must have been given an unofficial development task for Tf35K engine as a precautionary measure. If everything was fine with the RR, no one would work with 300 engineers on the design of the engine on an engineer/day basis. RR's capability is indisputable but we all know what we are going to face when it comes to matters related with Turkiye bro.
 

Quasar 

Contributor
Moderator
Messages
920
Reactions
54 4,037
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
TF35K is in a way our Manhattan project guess so we need to gether all enginers and infrastructure available in a single pool
 

Eagleeye

Member
Messages
13
Reactions
49
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
At this point I am considering to establish my own company Afif-Motor, and submitt my offer to SSB before tender ends.

Jokes aside, this tender is taking too long. It is already 2023 and KAAN gonna make its maiden flight soon, yet the Engine development is not officially awarded.
it doesn't matter it's only a formality tr motor and tei has already begun with the development of the engine 2 years ago.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,654
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
TF35K is in a way our Manhattan project guess so we need to gether all enginers and infrastructure available in a single pool
Gathering engineers is good but gathering companies is wrong. TEI will subcontract parts development when necessary and they actually do, like when they cooperate with Ivchenko or Motor Sich of the Ukraine or when TAI subcontract parts development of Hürjet to a Brazilian company. But project ownership should stay in solely the possession of TEI.
 
Last edited:

buraktunahan

Active member
Messages
48
Reactions
9 369
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
The first reason that comes to my mind for this cooperation; this decision may be a "political" decision between countries rather than a "technical" one. As you know, at the moment we are connected to Ukraine in terms of engines (kızılelma, atak2, etc.), and they are connected to us in terms of drones. This decision may be a political decision to further deepen relations between the two countries.

Another reason is; As you know, there are already some components that slow down the project, that you can normally obtain from the market, but that you cannot obtain due to implicit embargoes, so you have to design yourself, which do not require critical technology (for example, the famous oil pump, which is required for the TF-6000 but not sold to us, etc.). It may have been aimed to save time by having such engine side components manufactured in Ukraine.
 

GoatsMilk

Experienced member
Messages
4,251
Reactions
33 11,292
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
I think Things aren't going as expected with UK. The contribution of BAE in TFX Phase-1 was very mediocre with mostly inexperienced engineers and Tusaş complained about this situation a few times. As for engine to be likely developed with RR, RR put strong cards on table both in terms of license rights and production since they feel that Turkiye don't have an alternative way out of their offer. Also, Some reluctant statements by Turkish officials regarding possible deal with BAE for TFX Phase-2 were reflected in the press. Turkiye's cooperation offers for Tempest were also rejected by UK. The withdrawal of British royal air force which was said to join the last AnatolianEagle exercise also created question marks. Apart from this, there is a serious political confrontation and embargo from the West in almost every field, be them enlargement of NATO, terror operations or Russia/Ukraine war. Considering these conditions, TEI/TrMotor must have been given an unofficial development task for Tf35K engine as a precautionary measure. If everything was fine with the RR, no one would work with 300 engineers on the design of the engine on an engineer/day basis. RR's capability is indisputable but we all know what we are going to face when it comes to matters related with Turkiye bro.

I guess beggars cannot be choosers, but when the USA has a geopolitical agenda against Turkiye its never a good idea to rely on the British, since its pretty much known here in the UK we do whatever the USA wants.
 

buraktunahan

Active member
Messages
48
Reactions
9 369
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I guess beggars cannot be choosers, but when the USA has a geopolitical agenda against Turkiye its never a good idea to rely on the British, since its pretty much known here in the UK we do whatever the USA wants.

Turkey's motto is: "If anyone can do anything, I can do it too."

Maybe we'll make that engine a little late on our own. It will be a difficult process. But we'll build that engine eventually. Türkiye sought ways to cooperate with RR to shorten this process. Therefore, even if there is no RR, Türkiye continues on its way. It will take a long time, but eventually Türkiye will make its own engine.

It's always been like that. Years ago, we wanted to buy an armed Predator from the USA, it was not given to us. We started making our own drones 20 years ago. Today we export our own drones to 30 countries. Along with our own developed missiles.

We wanted to buy Patriot from the USA, we couldn't. We bought S400 from Russia. The United States imposed an embargo. We built our own air defense system. (Siper, Hisar, Sungur etc.)

We were building ships, but we couldn't get Harpoon from the USA. We've made an effort for years. We built our own anti-ship missile Atmaca.

Our "ally" USA no longer sells us F-16s or F-35s. He kicked us out of the F-35 project. So we started making Kaan. Hopefully this plane will be made eventually. But on the day this plane was built, we will not forget those who supported us and those who hindered us.
 

GoatsMilk

Experienced member
Messages
4,251
Reactions
33 11,292
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Turkey's motto is: "If anyone can do anything, I can do it too."

Maybe we'll make that engine a little late on our own. It will be a difficult process. But we'll build that engine eventually. Türkiye sought ways to cooperate with RR to shorten this process. Therefore, even if there is no RR, Türkiye continues on its way. It will take a long time, but eventually Türkiye will make its own engine.

It's always been like that. Years ago, we wanted to buy an armed Predator from the USA, it was not given to us. We started making our own drones 20 years ago. Today we export our own drones to 30 countries. Along with our own developed missiles.

We wanted to buy Patriot from the USA, we couldn't. We bought S400 from Russia. The United States imposed an embargo. We built our own air defense system. (Siper, Hisar, Sungur etc.)

We were building ships, but we couldn't get Harpoon from the USA. We've made an effort for years. We built our own anti-ship missile Atmaca.

Our "ally" USA no longer sells us F-16s or F-35s. He kicked us out of the F-35 project. So we started making Kaan. Hopefully this plane will be made eventually. But on the day this plane was built, we will not forget those who supported us and those who hindered us.

No doubts about it, but we shouldn't be surprised by such things. When temil kotil mentioned the tempest cooperation that was refused, he sounded bitter over it. Why would you act surprised? Are they ignorant to what's happening today towards Turkiye? Are they ignorant of British history? British history is rife with deception and duplicity.

My issue is the "surprise" when things don't pan out how they imagined. If I'm Turkiye and I'm dealing with the former imperial powers of Britain, France, Germany, etc I'm not expecting good things, I'm planning for the worst and hoping for the best. I'm not not planning for the best and hoping the worst doesn't happen.

We are not new to their games.

You know i've said it before but if you want to know what a nation really thinks about your nation, pay attention to their media. The British media is completely hostile to Turkiye. The British media portrays us as a two faced enemy of the west and great ally of Russia. While promoting the PKK always as "kurdish separatists fighting for freedom" never terrorists. When we kill PKK they report it as "killing Kurds". Deciving the international population that some kind of ethnic genocide is taking place.

The british state is on board with the american agenda against Turkiye. When you deal with them you must deal with them under this understanding.
 

MADDOG

Contributor
Türkiye Correspondent
Professional
Messages
1,224
Reactions
33 8,047
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Cyprus
KAAN's ground tests are ongoing

Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.43.53.png

Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.40.38.png

Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.44.44.png



Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.43.35.png


Hürjet

Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.41.17.png


Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.45.30.png


Screen Shot 2023-05-31 at 15.46.05.png


 

GoatsMilk

Experienced member
Messages
4,251
Reactions
33 11,292
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
on other forums people are claiming that Malaysia partnered on the KAAN project, does anyone have any news on this?
 

GoatsMilk

Experienced member
Messages
4,251
Reactions
33 11,292
Nation of residence
United Kingdom

Vice President of Defence Industry Agency Serdar Demirel claimed so.

Excellent, lets see other nations have some confidence and join the project. This potentially is a great opportunity for many naitons of the world that cannot buy american or doesnt want to be held under duress when they buy american.

Do we have any idea what Azerbaijans feelings are towards this KAAN project?
 

TheInsider

Experienced member
Professional
Messages
4,894
Solutions
1
Reactions
51 17,040
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
There is nothing concrete yet but there are serious interests from several countries.
 
Top Bottom