• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

TR UAV/UCAV Programs | Anka - series | Kızılelma | TB - series

UkroTurk

Experienced member
Land Warfare Specialist
Professional
Messages
2,966
Reactions
61 5,300
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Also 20 kizilelma for one f16 like say something realistic like 3 or 4
If one F-16 costs 500 million USD in long term, why not?, it is highly possible. Of course it is just for Turkish Air Force not for foreigners.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,189
Reactions
127 19,045
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Actually it is according to Mr. Akşit
TEI of course doesn't have its capital in a bank. Money they make from build to print parts is good enough to keep the lights on but they can hardly handle more than one self funded project at the same time.

There's no fiscal sense in building a PT6 competitor in this market, TEI would be idiots to fund one themselves. Baykar and SSB have the required money though. Hence my comment that money itself is not the issue.
If one F-16 costs 500 million USD in long term, why not?, it is highly possible. Of course it is just for Turkish Air Force not for foreigners.
What's Kızılelma's lifecycle cost? Or Akıncı even. Drones for example require as many if not more ground staff to handle than jets. Unmanned does not necessarily require less manpower. All that gets added to the lifecycle costs. Pilots too. UCAV pilots don't get LIFT training so they are cheaper to train, but there are more of them per airframe. When we talk about lifecycle costs, these numbers all get added in.
 
Last edited:

TR_123456

Active member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
102
Reactions
330
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
I never said they did, they are working on it. If they can make a turbofan, they should be able to convert a turboshaft to turboprop.
The way you wrote it it means they already did,maybe rephrase it?
Lets see first if they can.
 

TR_123456

Active member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
102
Reactions
330
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
This is what i wrote. Context matters.
Are you joking or what?

''If you can build a turbofan engine from scratch you should be able to convert an already existing turboshaft into a turboprop.''


What does this sentence mean?
 

boredaf

Experienced member
Messages
2,268
Solutions
1
Reactions
42 6,654
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
He literally says Baykar will develop an engine for KIZILELMA. If you can build a turbofan engine from scratch you should be able to convert an already existing turboshaft into a turboprop.
I never said they did, they are working on it. If they can make a turbofan, they should be able to convert a turboshaft to turboprop.
He can say whatever he likes, until they actually show the capability to do more than put together an engine with off-the-shelf parts, it means jack shit, it is just talk. First let's see him invest the billions necessary to create the ecosystem and expertise needed specifically for a turbofan jet engine.
 

Strong AI

Member
Messages
12
Reactions
2 27
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Are you joking or what?

''If you can build a turbofan engine from scratch you should be able to convert an already existing turboshaft into a turboprop.''


What does this sentence mean?

Are you for real now?

Look at my first sentece. "They will develop it"
Look at my second sentence. "If you can make it, you should be able to do ..."

first sentence will, second sentence if.

Actually you know what.
I wanted to write this for some time personally to you but since you do this publicly i will write this here.
How many members have this forum but how many are active?
And most of them come here only for news.
It is really funny that sometimes the politics thread is more active than defence realated threads on this defence related forum.
Also you guys said several times that old well known members will return, which didn't happen.

Once i post something to start a discussion, i get critisized for god knows what.

Kindly please delete all my posts and my account. Thank you. I wanted already to do this for some time and you gave me another reason now.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,653
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
TS1400 is a radial flow engine while the new TS3000 engine is likely to be an axial flow engine which is more suitable for conversion into a turboprop engine. You still need to wait for it to be made though.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,653
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
If Baykar think they can make a turbofan engine which is evident from the fact that they are supposedly working on it then they can be considered to be very well qualified to convert a turboshaft engine into a turboprop one. The fact that they believe they can make and they actually make are two different situations but with 9000 personnel and counting they are almost guarantied to be able to make it.
 

Huelague

Experienced member
Messages
5,380
Reactions
19 5,413
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
I never said they did, they are working on it. If they can make a turbofan, they should be able to convert a turboshaft to turboprop.
What do they need to build one?
Maybe the political/company will?
Maybe money? Maybe innovation. Maybe employees? Maybe experience (must not be from inside Baykar). I can’t see big hurdles except time.
 

boredaf

Experienced member
Messages
2,268
Solutions
1
Reactions
42 6,654
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey

Watched by 18 Countries: Demo of ASELSAN’s ANTIDOT and FULMAR Pods

The ASELSAN-manufactured ANTIDOT Electronic Support and Warfare Pod and FULMAR 200 Synthetic Aperture Radar Pod, integrated into Bayraktar TB2 UAVs, successfully performed their missions during an international demonstration event attended by 18 different countries.
Within the scope of the activity, ANTIDOT and FULMAR pods operating on Bayraktar TB2s worked in coordination and demonstrated their electronic support, electronic attack, reconnaissance and surveillance capabilities in the same operational scenario.

During the demonstration activity, ANTIDOT 2ES 100 and ANTIDOT 2EA 200 pods were integrated onto one Bayraktar TB2, while a FULMAR 200 pod was integrated onto another. In the initial test, the ANTIDOT system successfully detected the target radar system and pinpointed its location during flight. After the ANTIDOT ED pod transmitted the acquired target data, an electronic attack was launched against the target using the ANTIDOT ET pod. This enabled the ANTIDOT-equipped Bayraktar TB2 to approach the target undetected.

In the second phase of the demonstration activity, a different target was detected and its location determined by the ANTIDOT System. Subsequently, a high-resolution SAR image of the target was generated by the FULMAR 200 Radar, and high-precision positional data regarding the target was obtained.

 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,189
Reactions
127 19,045
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
This openness to show every fucking foreign military how and what we do is pissing me off...
We have a decent sized military rearming at decent pace but our defence industry is growing exponentially. MSB simply cannot feed SSB. This structure doesn't work without exports. Hardly anything actually secret is shown during these semi public tests.
 

Angry Turk !!!

Contributor
Messages
722
Reactions
7 1,718
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
We have a decent sized military rearming at decent pace but our defence industry is growing exponentially. MSB simply cannot feed SSB. This structure doesn't work without exports. Hardly anything actually secret is shown during these semi public tests.
I think showing anything related to EW is too much, show a rifle or manpad or whatever but not these kind of things.
 

AlperTunga

Committed member
Messages
251
Reactions
5 330
Nation of residence
Switzerland
Nation of origin
Turkey
I think showing anything related to EW is too much, show a rifle or manpad or whatever but not these kind of things.
They are just showing that EW works, not revealing really anything about how it works and certainly not the underlying software. We also need to be deterrent such that some adventurous countries do not attempt attacking us. Showing a rifle or manpad would not deter anyone.
 

Lool

Experienced member
Messages
3,547
Reactions
20 5,862
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
4,274
Reactions
261 22,324
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
The Akinci drone is becoming more effective day by day
Baykar should initiate plans to develop an even bigger Akinci capable of carrying even more payloads. It is slowly becoming a cheap and excellent bomber as well as a lethal MALE drone killer
They don’t need to build a “bigger” Akinci.
They just need to improve it’s structural construction and aerodynamic performance.
Just look at the below difference between MQ-9 Reaper Advanced specs and Akinci-C specs.

Akıncı C with its 2 x 850HP engines has the same maximum payload limit as the Akinci-A with 2 x 450HP engines. Why? Because the structure can’t handle any more.

Akıncı C should outclass the Reaper Advanced with its more powerful engines. But it doesn’t. Because the design needs to be changed. It can neither carry more payload than Reaper Advanced nor can it go higher in altitude. Yet they are similar in length and wing span.
The Reaper outperforms Akinci-C nearly in all aspects.

Head-to-Head Specifications

FeatureMQ-9A Reaper (Advanced / ER / Block 5)Baykar Bayraktar Akıncı-C (2 x 850HP)
Power Plant1 × Honeywell TPE331-10GD Turboprop2 × 850 HP Turboprop Engines (Total: 1700 HP)
Total Engine Power~900 Shaft Horsepower (SHP)~1,700 Horsepower
Max Takeoff Weight (MTOW)Up to 5,307 kg for ER variant6,000 kg
Total Payload Capacity1,701 kg (3,750 lbs)1,500 kg (~1,350 kg weapons + 150 kg internal sensors)
Max Speed / Cruise Speed240 KTAS / ~200 KTAS~240 KTAS / 150 KTAS
Service Ceiling50,000 feet (15,240 m)40,000 feet (12,192 m)
Max Endurance27 hours (34 hours for Extended Range with wing pods)24+ hours
Wingspan / Length20.1 m / 11 m20 m / 12.2 m
Primary ArmamentAGM-114 Hellfire, GBU-12 Paveway II, GBU-38 JDAMMAM-L/C/T, SOM Cruise Missile, Gökdoğan & Bozdoğan Air-to-Air missiles, TRG-230-UAV
Core Avionics & RadarLynx Multi-mode Radar, MTS-B EO/IR turretAselsan MURAD Multi-Mode AESA Radar, Indigenous EO/IR, SIGINT
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom