Latest Thread

TR Defence Exports & Updates

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,207
Solutions
2
Reactions
100 23,274
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Maybe they demand different specs from the missile. It is told the missiles will be new, thus we have no idea as of now.

But it is for sure Roketsan will be making just the missile itself. It is a good prestige to supply a tailored solution and definitely will worth the trouble in terms of demand and production. However, this contract causes a misunderstanding on Hisar and Siper and make people question "why not these but a new missile, is anything bad with Turkish missiles".
As mentioned in the original article:

Trisula-O Missile System (OMS)
Trisula-O Weapon System (OWS)
Trisula-U Missile System (UMS)
Trisula-U Weapon System (UWS)

Wonder what is difference of "Missile" and "Weapon" system here. And why are they adopting O and U which referring to orta (mid) and uzun (long) ranges.
 

Radonsider

Contributor
Messages
1,373
Reactions
13 2,583
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Bosnia & Herzegovina
As mentioned in the original article:

Trisula-O Missile System (OMS)
Trisula-O Weapon System (OWS)
Trisula-U Missile System (UMS)
Trisula-U Weapon System (UWS)

Wonder what is difference of "Missile" and "Weapon" system here. And why are they adopting O and U which referring to orta (mid) and uzun (long) ranges.
I don't think that missiles would be that different, nor the missile subsystems, the main difference will be TELs, links and radar systems
 

Fighter_35

Contributor
Messages
543
Reactions
1 739
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Having another missile design is also very good for us. We may also evaluate them in the future variant of our systems.
I think they may have asked for longer ranges than current hisar o variants.
With new design , current range may increase from 25-35 to 40-45 km and with small booster compared to siper block zero, it may reach 70-80 km ranges.
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,017
Reactions
21 12,585
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

Lool

Experienced member
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
2,734
Reactions
11 4,751
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
The TriSula Air Defense System, which is being developed for Indonesia, will use the medium and high altitude air defense missiles that Roketsan will develop with the experience gained from Hisar and Siper.
Just me trying to get this right though

So instead of buying Hisars, Indonesia asked Roketsan to build for them a new unique AD system for themselves?
 

Baris

Committed member
Messages
224
Reactions
909
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Just me trying to get this right though

So instead of buying Hisars, Indonesia asked Roketsan to build for them a new unique AD system for themselves?
They have different needs obviously
 

BalkanTurk90

Contributor
Messages
616
Reactions
5 978
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Turkey
Why not buy direct Hisar and Siper . they are aslo almost ready?
Did indonesia needs longer range ?
To be fair Hisar O looks big and its range is shorter to be medium SAM if its real range is as its told .
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,197
Reactions
67 7,782
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
Why not buy direct Hisar and Siper . they are aslo almost ready?
Did indonesia needs longer range ?
To be fair Hisar O looks big and its range is shorter to be medium SAM if its real range is as its told .
I think it is likely to be modified hisar rf and siper to meet indonesian requirement with a new name tag on it.

Otherwise, designing a two new missile in two different roles from the scratch and deliver it will take at least 4 years. ( likely more )
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,197
Reactions
67 7,782
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
Damm! It seems Turkish defence industry truly became Noah's ship for muslim majority countries!😂 literally from Morrocco to Indonesia in the actual sense!😂 nobody seems to wanna miss out!

Who would have thought something like that 20 years ago !

I don't mind if the old man in Ankara's palace woke some morning in his bed and mistake himself as a sultan for couple of moments! 😂

Jokes aside No doubt that, the spectacular rise of Turkish defence industry is a very positive development for the Republic of Turkey as a nation state.
A comparative contemporary case like Turkey can be found in other part of the world. I think it would be fair to say south korea also had a similar rise in defence industry like Turkey.

However, unlike South Korea, the rise of Turkish defence industry having ( slowly but surely ) an unprecedented impact on the geopolitical and security power dynamics between North African, central asian, south east asian, middle eastern countries and the great powers. ( Especially the west )

Think about it, ten years ago if you wanna buy any world class strategic defence equipment from the west how much geopolitical and other compromise you needed to make to the great powers for that!

Take for example KSA or other Gulf countries! They have the world's best weapons but they can't even do a shit with it ! Except serving western interests with it in expense of their very own interest. ( of course, very recently it is changing little by little )

Western power enjoyed more or less similar monopoly over mejority of muslim countries for a long time.

Except now it is started to change recently by the rise of Turkish defence industry.
Now these countries can have highly sophisticated strategic equipments like, long range air defence, modern frigate, submarine ( and fifth gen fighter in the near future ) from a brotherly country.

Thus, they don't have to make unacceptable geopolitical compromise to the west anymore to get these strategically vital equipments! Or they don't have to give up a big chunk of their national resources to big western companies! and more importantly they can now get rid of the fear that, west can cripple their strategic assets by simply cutting of the spare parts or just messing up the softwares, if they move slightly against their interest!

The more success Turkish defence industry has from Morrocco to Indonesia, the more century old western monopoly fades away.

If you loot at it in this broader sense, the extremely embargo happy behaviors of the most western countries would become more obvious!

For them, Strong Turkish defence industry not just a 'strong Turkey problem' on its own! but also, it creates hell of a lot more broader issues for them to deal with!
They definitely fear that, an strong and cooperative Turkish defence industry would fuel the rise of some other 'unfriendly' defence industries around thee world in near future!

I know, the significance of the concept i am describing here maybe little difficult for Turks to understand, given Turkey has never been colonized nor it has been under such heavy monopoly. But for others, for the first time in hundred years they are having a chance to gain more control and sovereignty from the west over their own affairs, their own national security and geopolitical choices. And this is something really special! that feeling!

Of course, all of these giving birth to 'NEW TURKIYE' in great power's geopolitics given the amount of significant influence Turkiye is gaining through these strategic security cooperation with brotherly countries.

but, overall most of the muslim countries won't mind Turkish soft power influence for the same reason most of the west by and large don't mind US influence. ( which is, having more or less similar geopolitical amd geoeconomic interests )
 
Last edited:

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,017
Reactions
21 12,585
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Damm! It seems turkish defence industry truly became Noah's ship for muslim majority countries!😂 literally from morrocco to Indonesia in the actual sense! nobody seems to wanna miss out!

Who would have thought something like that 20 years ago !

I should tell you guys, It is not just you who are experiensing something new and exceptional in a long time!
But I think in some sense, it is more or less every muslim country from morrocco to Indonesia!

No doubt that, the spectacular rise of turkish defence industry is a very positive development for the Republic of turkey as a nation state.
A comparative contemporary case like turkey can be found in other part of the world. I think it would be fair to say south korea also had a similar rise in defence industry like turkey.

However, unlike south korea, the rise of turkish defence industry having ( slowly but surely ) an unprecedented impact on the geopolitical and security power dynamics between North African, central asian, south east asian, middle eastern countries and the great powers. ( Especially the west )

Think about it, ten years ago if you wanna buy any world class strategic defence equipment from the west how much geopolitical and other compromise you needed to make to the great powrs for that!

Take for example KSA or other Gulf countries! They have the world's best weapons but they can't even do a shit with it ! Except serving western interests with it in expense of their very own interest. ( of course, very recently it is changing little by little )

Western power enjoyed more or less similar monopoly over mejority of muslim countries for a long time.

Except now it is started to change recently by the rise of turkish defence industry.
Now muslim countries can have highly sophisticated strategic equipments like, long range air defence, modern frigate, submarine ( and fifth gen fighter in the near future ) from a brotherly country.

Thus, we don't have to make unacceptable geopolitical compromise to the west anymore to get these strategically vital equipments! Or We don't have to give up a big chunk of our national resources to big western companies! Nor we have to live in constant fear that, they can cripple our strategic assets by simply cutting of the spare parts or just messing up the softwares, if we move slightly against their interest!

The more success turkish defence industry has from morrocco to Indonesia, the more century old western monopoly fades away.

If you loot at it in this broader sense, the extremely embargo happy behaviors of the most western countries would become more obvious!

For them, Strong turkish defence not just a 'strong turkey problem' on its own! but also, it creates hell of a lot more broader issues for them to deal with! They definitely fear that, an strong and cooperative turkish defence industry would fuel rise of some other 'unfriendly' defence industries around thee world in near future!

I know, the significance of the concept i am describing here maybe little difficult for turks to understand, given turkey has never been colonized nor it has been under such heavy monopoly. But for others, for the first time in hundred years they are having a chance to gain more control and sovereignty from the west over their own affairs, their own national security and geopolitical choices. And this is huge! Really really huge!

Of course, all of these giving birth to 'NEW TURKIYE' in great power's geopolitics given the amount of significant influence Turkiye is gaining through these strategic security cooperation with brotherly countries.

And of course, overall most of the muslim countries won't mind turkish influence for the same reason most of the west by and large don't mind US influence. ( which is, having more or less similar geopolitical amd geoeconomic interests )
Embargoes and threat of getting embargoed has always been the number one problem for militaries whose country that is not aligned with either China or Russia but at the same time not necessarily part of the western world.

Personally I find it took Indonesia so long to choose Turkiye as it's weapons supplier. Consider their solutions are mostly NATO standard weapons.

Overall it's a nice trajectory going forward, I want to see munitions such as SOM, Kuzgun, Teber to be integrated with our upcoming and existing fighter jet.
 

Kedikesenfare

Well-known member
Messages
330
Reactions
1 797
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Embargoes and threat of getting embargoed has always been the number one problem for militaries whose country that is not aligned with either China or Russia but at the same time not necessarily part of the western world.

Personally I find it took Indonesia so long to choose Turkiye as it's weapons supplier. Consider their solutions are mostly NATO standard weapons.

Overall it's a nice trajectory going forward, I want to see munitions such as SOM, Kuzgun, Teber to be integrated with our upcoming and existing fighter jet.
Didn't Indonesia refuse to join the Turkish drone journey even though Ankara invited your politicians publicly?
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,017
Reactions
21 12,585
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Didn't Indonesia refuse to join the Turkish drone journey even though Ankara invited your politicians publicly?
I don't remember when we are invited, but here's what I know. Indonesian defense supplier has always been dominated by European companies (Thales, MBDA etc) and historically American (during the new order era, before the embargo).

Overtime these relationship between us and the Europeans grew more and more intimate, I'm absolutely sure that years of transaction between the two has taught the Euro what Indonesian officials really want (we are corrupt as f"$#). Simply put the Euros has enough influence to ensure Indonesian officials to keep buying their products even though some of those are already outdated (exocet for example) while ignoring other contenders.

And even among Euros, some country has the veto power among others, one example is the Kornas "national corvette" tender between the Italian Orrizonte systemi navali vs the Dutch Damen schelde which was eventually won by the Dutch even though the Orrizonte was a favorite and comes with a larger offset package. The other case is why Leonardo eventually lost out to Thales in supplying the Indonesian air force radar tender, even though Leonardo actually won the original tender.

Prabowo really make a breakthrough by gradually moving away from our traditional supplier and explore new opportunities.

And as for the drones, let's say we overestimated our capabilities with Elang Hitam UAV project.
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,017
Reactions
21 12,585
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Yes, it took long but honestly, I didn't thought even now indonesia suddenly will choose turkey for strategic procurement like long range air defence and tactical balistic missile.

I mean, with malasyia, there are already preconditions in place. and lot of engagement and mutual interest emerged from both parties ( turkey and malasyia ) in recent years

But with Indonesia we didn't saw similar activities taking place at that level ( at least out door )
This is not entirely true, there had been talks between the two parties with defence minister Prabowo visiting Turkiye and its arms industry several times, its just it took so long for Indonesia from "showing interest" and the signing of deals. So long many have come to the conclusion that Indo-Turkiye cooperation will remain hot air, one huge skeptic of Indonesia signing major defense deals with Turkiye that I know is @Anmdt .🙂

Indonesia is not new to Turkish arms, our coast guard OPVs are armed SMASH remote controlled gun/cannon system, our navy operate Aselsan Zoka accoustic torpedo countermeasures in the Nagapasa submarine, while the air force operate Aselsan Acar ground surveillance radar and Aselsan SARP RWS
 

AWP

Contributor
Messages
687
Reactions
4 1,403
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Palestine
Damm! It seems turkish defence industry truly became Noah's ship for muslim majority countries!😂 literally from morrocco to Indonesia in the actual sense! nobody seems to wanna miss out!

Who would have thought something like that 20 years ago !

I should tell you guys, It is not just you who are experiensing something new and exceptional in a long time!
But I think in some sense, it is more or less every muslim country from morrocco to Indonesia!

Western power enjoyed more or less similar monopoly over mejority of muslim countries for a long time.

but, overall most of the muslim countries won't mind turkish influence for the same reason most of the west by and large don't mind US influence. ( which is, having more or less similar geopolitical amd geoeconomic interests )

I think you exaggerated here

Turkey being Islamic country has nothing to do with the defense industry . probably one day Turkey will export to Israel or China or some western country who have some agenda against Islamic countries .

it's a simple business bro . Turkey make weapons , sell it and get money for it and that's all .

Anyway I agree with you that Turkey is a gateway for countries that suffer from the US politics like KSA or Pakistan
 

AWP

Contributor
Messages
687
Reactions
4 1,403
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
Palestine
I mean, not even superpowers like usa think, 'oh hey! we can just do fine on our own. so let's sell what we have got, and make tons of money! .' If it was the case lockheed martin would have allowed to sell f35 to everybody. Because that would have been good for business!

I was 100% sure that you will bring the US into this topic

unlike Turkey , the US is a global power and the weapon selling policy is a propagation of its political power across the world . Turkey on the other hand most important agenda is more into the economic side .

let's look at Turkey F-35 issue . Simply the US played it very well on all aspects and look how :

1- they banned the F-35 sale to Turkey and then compensate the Turkish lose with massive deals from UAE , Greek , Germany , Finland , Switzerland , Norway and additional order from Japan .

2- They strengthen the political ties with Greek , Israel , some arab countries and the West with the F-35 cancelled deal .

3- they didn't lose Turkey as an ally because in general no one want to be an enemy of the US .

And you think that Turkey or China or some other country can play this like the US ? wake up bro . it's good to have Turkey rise as an asset but lets not jump to Mars .
 

dBSPL

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Ambassador
Messages
2,100
Reactions
86 10,903
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
The SSB provides a significant advantage over similar organizations of other system supplier countries through both the transfer of capabilities and the flexibility provided in the specifications. Less bureaucracy enables more solution-oriented negotiations. The direct affiliation of the SSB to the presidency is one of the details that make a significant difference in this regard. Negotiation rounds that would take a minimum of 2-3 years with a Western company can be completed within a year with the SSB, and this includes collaborations that Western companies are often reluctant to offer.

The 2nd advantage is that our system developer companies are used to working on very tight schedules. With the last example, Roketsan currently has 40 different product/sub-system development projects, most of which have not been announced. And as if all this were not enough, it will also develop specialized missile groups and related components for the system that will form the backbone of Indonesia's air defence capabilities. We are not talking about Raytheon, the munitions and related electronics giant with 40K employees and incredible amount of capital/facilities, but Roketsan.

The 3rd advantage is related to the country's soft power capabilities. In areas where Turkiye appears to be in conflict with the global hegemony, it creates a natural rapprochement with countries facing similar problems. For countries that do not have a conflict of interest with Turkiye, we are one of the leading countries to procure systems from. Turkiye's shortcoming in this regard was the lack of sufficient system development activities. Now, Our companies have difficulties in meeting external demand. the main investment expenditures of all the companies concerned are related to capacity increases, and sales negotiations for systems start while the systems are still in the project phase.

The 4th advantage is that we have become the country with the most competitive production costs among western systems in systems with a high localization rate. Western companies can take advantage of the political factors of the country they are affiliated with, they can use financial instruments, but there is nothing they can do about cost differences.

Our two main disadvantages are embargoes and financial instruments. There are important breakthroughs in both areas. When we reduce these problems to manageable levels, we will begin to see the true potential of the Turkish defense industry.

Long story short, the sector's average annual growth will remain in the 30-50% range for a long time to come, and there will even be big jumps in some years. The Turkish defense industry is the fastest growing sectoral group in the world. If it maintains this momentum for 10 years, it will certanly be among the world's top 3-4 suppliers.
 
Last edited:

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,197
Reactions
67 7,782
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
@dBSPL do you think at some point, prominent turkish defence companies should become multinational in allied countries like thales and leonardo has ?

Or should they remain turkish but develop strong cooperation with allied countries industries ?
 

dBSPL

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Ambassador
Messages
2,100
Reactions
86 10,903
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
@dBSPL do you think at some point, prominent turkish defence companies should become multinational in allied countries like thales and leonardo has ?

Or should they remain turkish but develop strong cooperation with allied countries industries ?
This is not possible for foundation companies (Aselsan, Roketsan, Havelsan, Aspilsan, TAI, etc.). However, we observe that these companies have established joint companies with the partner companies in the relevant countries. For example, Aselsan's JV in KSA. There many other examples.

Private bussineses may have more flexible investment models. For example, the BMC partnership of the Qatar fund. Or Baykar's cooperation plans in Ukraine, not for capital support, but for workforce and market expansion.
 

Oublious

Experienced member
The Netherlands Correspondent
Messages
2,041
Reactions
7 4,391
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
Damm! It seems turkish defence industry truly became Noah's ship for muslim majority countries!😂 literally from morrocco to Indonesia in the actual sense!😂 nobody seems to wanna miss out!

Who would have thought something like that 20 years ago !

I don't mind if the old man in ankara's palace woke some morning in his bed and mistake himself as a sultan for couple of moments! 😂

Jokes aside No doubt that, the spectacular rise of turkish defence industry is a very positive development for the Republic of turkey as a nation state.
A comparative contemporary case like turkey can be found in other part of the world. I think it would be fair to say south korea also had a similar rise in defence industry like turkey.

However, unlike south korea, the rise of turkish defence industry having ( slowly but surely ) an unprecedented impact on the geopolitical and security power dynamics between North African, central asian, south east asian, middle eastern countries and the great powers. ( Especially the west )

Think about it, ten years ago if you wanna buy any world class strategic defence equipment from the west how much geopolitical and other compromise you needed to make to the great powers for that!

Take for example KSA or other Gulf countries! They have the world's best weapons but they can't even do a shit with it ! Except serving western interests with it in expense of their very own interest. ( of course, very recently it is changing little by little )

Western power enjoyed more or less similar monopoly over mejority of muslim countries for a long time.

Except now it is started to change recently by the rise of turkish defence industry.
Now these countries can have highly sophisticated strategic equipments like, long range air defence, modern frigate, submarine ( and fifth gen fighter in the near future ) from a brotherly country.

Thus, they don't have to make unacceptable geopolitical compromise to the west anymore to get these strategically vital equipments! Or they don't have to give up a big chunk of our national resources to big western companies! and more importantly they can alos get rid of the fear that, west can cripple their strategic assets by simply cutting of the spare parts or just messing up the softwares, if we move slightly against their interest!

The more success turkish defence industry has from morrocco to Indonesia, the more century old western monopoly fades away.

If you loot at it in this broader sense, the extremely embargo happy behaviors of the most western countries would become more obvious!

For them, Strong turkish defence industry not just a 'strong turkey problem' on its own! but also, it creates hell of a lot more broader issues for them to deal with!
They definitely fear that, an strong and cooperative turkish defence industry would fuel the rise of some other 'unfriendly' defence industries around thee world in near future!

I know, the significance of the concept i am describing here maybe little difficult for turks to understand, given turkey has never been colonized nor it has been under such heavy monopoly. But for others, for the first time in hundred years they are having a chance to gain more control and sovereignty from the west over their own affairs, their own national security and geopolitical choices. And this is something really special! that feeling!

Of course, all of these giving birth to 'NEW TURKIYE' in great power's geopolitics given the amount of significant influence Turkiye is gaining through these strategic security cooperation with brotherly countries.

but, overall most of the muslim countries won't mind turkish soft power influence for the same reason most of the west by and large don't mind US influence. ( which is, having more or less similar geopolitical amd geoeconomic interests )


you have analyzed the situation good...(y)
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom