If war broke out between Morocco and Algeria.

Lool

Experienced member
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
2,908
Reactions
13 5,003
Nation of residence
Albania
Nation of origin
Albania
Hm......
There are many factors to be considered tbh
Since Morrocco and Algeria have shared land borders, I dont think the navy will be the decisive factor in a possible confrontation; especially when such nations are buying weapons from abroad and not producing them domestically

Now, for land forces I think Algeria has the edge considering their massive numbers while Morroco may have a better airforce or lets say "more effective and effecient" airforce by using better drones and planes

Many members are already talking about the technical factors of the armies in such a scenario and thus I wanna share a new point of view

However, IMO, the true factor in this war will be MONEY!
A war between Algeria and Morocco wont only be bloody but way too long as well and war cost money; from maintaining troops to stockpiling ammunitions. Thus, the country with the most stable source of income will have the edge in such war of attrition. Typically, such sources of income are either Food or Gas! (yes production isnt that amazing during wartime!) And since Algeria has gas and a greater land area; hey do have an edge in a possible warfare scenario. Therefore, if Morroco wanna win it needs to be quick and decisive which is quite difficult since Algeria is just way too big for it to be conquered quickly
 

Chakib larbi

Contributor
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Algeria Moderator
Messages
1,208
Reactions
14 3,092
Nation of residence
Algeria
Nation of origin
Algeria
Hm......
There are many factors to be considered tbh
Since Morrocco and Algeria have shared land borders, I dont think the navy will be the decisive factor in a possible confrontation; especially when such nations are buying weapons from abroad and not producing them domestically

Now, for land forces I think Algeria has the edge considering their massive numbers while Morroco may have a better airforce or lets say "more effective and effecient" airforce by using better drones and planes

Many members are already talking about the technical factors of the armies in such a scenario and thus I wanna share a new point of view

However, IMO, the true factor in this war will be MONEY!
A war between Algeria and Morocco wont only be bloody but way too long as well and war cost money; from maintaining troops to stockpiling ammunitions. Thus, the country with the most stable source of income will have the edge in such war of attrition. Typically, such sources of income are either Food or Gas! (yes production isnt that amazing during wartime!) And since Algeria has gas and a greater land area; hey do have an edge in a possible warfare scenario. Therefore, if Morroco wanna win it needs to be quick and decisive which is quite difficult since Algeria is just way too big for it to be conquered quickly
I still do not see any superiority of the Moroccan Air Force over Algeria Especially since Algeria will operate after the year of 2025 the modernized Su-30 + Su-57E + Su-34 and MiG-29M2 fighters with large number of locally made chinese drone Protected by our air defense forces, which are the first without a doubt in Africa..Personally, I see that the air superiority is in the favor of Algeria, and what we really lack is the AWACS planes
 

TR_123456

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
5,076
Reactions
12,632
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
lol what does it mean (NATO standard is 0, minus 1/2/3 etc)
NATO standard is a way to rate the forces compared to NATO forces,except the new members from the old soviet states.



@500 can you make comparison between the Armed Forces of Algeria and Morocco?
 
Last edited:

Oublious

Experienced member
The Netherlands Correspondent
Messages
2,152
Reactions
8 4,644
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
I have looked globally both countries when it comes to landforces i think both countries have state of the art weapons like SAM. Artillery and rest of the equipment is equal, but when it comes to Command and Control or Radar systems Morocco do it better. Still do not believe Turkey have sold Koral to Morocco, if that is correct then the edge will shift to Marocco. Both countries do not have strategic EW/ED systems, nobody will give that for sure.

With airforces Morrocan do it better, Algerians do not have AWACS. You can have the best fighter but if you don't have Eye in the Sky then it does not mean much against a enemy with Eye. Both have UAV but how many do have is not clear, air to air weapons and all other stuff is equal. Both do not have cruise missiles, or ther is not information about it.

Navy is a bit strange, Morroco have good ships but do not have submarine so the Algerian navy is stronger.

Outcome looks like in favor of Morrocco, i hope a war never break out between two countries.
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,361
Reactions
22 12,853
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Can you go more in depth? Perhaps mention main systems and weapons. I will come back to you regarding the training and experience part.
Air force : While Moroccan air force is relatively smaller, but the F-16s Morocco has just blows the competition, it has a better engine (F100-PW-229) , better avionics (AN/APG-68v(9) + APG-83 AESA radar) and a more advanced and diverse armament.

#ENGINE

The engine on the Moroccan Vipers is the powerful and tested Pratt F100-PW-229 with 130kN thrust and most importanly a far longer mean time between overhaul (MTBO) than the Su and MiG Lyulka AL-31 and Klimov RD-33 series.

Engine life comparison

  1. Pratt F100 PW-229 EEP : 8000 hours
  2. Lyulka Al-31F : 900-1500 hours
  3. RD-33 : 700 hours

That means the F-16s will spend most of their active service flying instead of doing repairs and overhauls.

Indonesian air force both operate the F-16 A/B and C/D all of which uses the older Prat F-100-PW-220E and the SU-27/30 with Lyulka Al-31F. Overall our air force prefer the F-16 and the F-16s remains Indonesian air force backbone. The Sukhois are known hangar que**.

Note: there are some difference on the engine life hours, but overall Russian engines are more prone to overhauls. As note the AL-31F could be overhauled twice and then it must be dumped.


#ARMAMENTS

A2A

This is where the F-16 particularly shines, starting from the AAM. The F-16 has a lavish choice firing multiple NATO standard air to air munitions, but to keep it real we’re talking the two standard Fox 2 and Fox 3 missile in Moroccan inventory the AIM-9 and AIM-120

The latest iteration for the Sidewinders is the dash 9X blk II, which offers significant improvement in target discrimination than the dash 9X block I and improved off boresight capability. The Algerian principal short range AAM is the R-73 which also offers the same off boresight capability , but its questionable if its match or exceed the 9X, because unlike the Archer, the Sidewinder has incremental improvement program from time to time.

The same could be said with the Fox 3s, the principal long range AAM of the Moroccans is the AMRAAM while the Algerians, the Adder AA-12. While both are classified as medium to long range missile, just like the AIM-9X, the AIM-120D benefitted from Pentagon incremental upgrade of the missile, there has been 4 block iteration of the AIM-120 since its introduction in the 90s , while the AA-12 has only one.

The AIM-120D are reportedly able to achieve the longest air to air kills ever recorded on an air breathing target last year.

Other than that, Moroccan F1s also employed the MICA which is a very agile air to air missile

A2G

The war in Ukraine shows us that Russian air force platforms has not invested significantly on targeting pods to employ laser guided smart bombs and continue to rely on old iron bombs and missiles (which are very expensive).

The F-16s (especially that employed by Morocco) are able to lob precision bombs usually in the forms of either the GPS/INS guided JDAM, laser guided Paveways or the GPS+Laser LJDAM/ French AASM all of which are deployed on the Moroccan F-16s and Mirage F1s.

All those smart bombs could hit their target precisely because the Royal Marocco Air Force (RMAF) had invested significantly in the use of targeting pods.

Some of the advanced pods employed by RMAF :

  • Goodrich DB-110
  • Litening
  • Damocles
  • Sniper
Algerian air force do have their own smart bombs, but most of it are heavy and big, KAB-1500L for example, and because Russian smart bomb kits aren’t produced nearly as much as their US counterparts, its must be very expensive due to lack of economy of scale, hence bought in limited number. Also being Russian platform, it doesn’t really have anything close to the targeting pods deployed by Western jets. I am aware of the T220/E targeting pod , but its performance questionable, and if I’m not mistaken Russian air force themselves had not used any of those.

Both RMAF and AAF deployed anti radiation missile (AGM-88b and KH-31PD)

Both RMAF and AAF deployed shor range A2G missile (AGM-65 and Kh-29), but the AGM-65 is a lot smaller in size for the same role and performance. More missile could be carried.

AAF Su and MiG’s are equipped with the KH-59MK ALCM, while the RMAF will soon uses the Delilah, both are combat proven in both Syria (IAF) and Ukraine (used by RuAF). But AAF leads this time.

RMAF F-16 will soon be equipped with the RGM-84L Block II Harpoon AShM, replacing or augmenting existing AM-39 launched from the Mirage F1s.

#Avionics.

Let me explain, the mechanically scanned and electronically scanned radar has nothing to do with efficiency. Its more to do wth radar beam steering.

A mechanically scanned radar could be superior than a PESA radar if the software and T/R module is better. Being mechanical has nothing to do with target discrimination, an electronically scanned radar steers the radar beam electronically to all side while mechanical steered ones used (as the name suggest) mechanical arms to swing the plate around. But yes, PESA could scan the skies faster than mechanically scanned ones.

AESA radar can achieve better signal to noise ratio compared to PESA (better signal to noise ratio will improve radar detection range). AESA design is approximately 2.79 dB better than PESA design in that aspect ( or about 47% better )

lna-and-noise1.png


Furthermore , since individuals T/R modules on AESA do not rely on a single high power amplifier, they can transmit signal at different frequencies at the same time. As a result, an AESA can form several independent beams at different frequencies simultaneously by dividing the array into a few smaller sub-array, that improves its multitasking capabilities.


AESA is also very resilient to jam and could actually used in jamming role as demonstrated by the APG-83 on the Lightning.

Russia does not produce AESA (safe for maybe the Su-57s) and its performance is questionable.

The SABR APG-83 installed on the Vipers are 3rd gen AESA radars, not all AESA are equal, and because this is US made, its more mature. It is reportedly developed with lessons from the APG-81 Radar (the most advanced radar on any flying jets)

The F-16s are equipped with the LINK 16 data links, I don’t have to explain why data links are important and overall Moroccan orders for its electronics package are more extensive as you can read in this link below


The biggest L for the RMAF is their F-16s are not supported by the necessary air refueling tanker to do air to air refueling. (and so do us, Indonesians lololol), but good for them , RMAF had those CFT as standard and a more fuel efficient F100 PW-229 engine


#Pilot kit.

Moroccan Pilot are equipped with the latest JHMCS II helmet mounted cueing system which not only looks better, it is a step ahead than the Sura HMCS used by Su and MiG pilots

#crew

At best this is questionable, but RMAF pilots do train with the best (USAF). Air forces train with their weapons supplier and the Russian air force performance are laid bare for everyone to see. But until an actual Morocco v Algeria war happens this is at best guessing.


Next : NAVY

Navies firepower in WW1 and WW2 are measured in their throw weight, while modern navy firepower are measured by the battle force missile (BFM).

BFMs are missiles that “contribute to battle force missions such as area and local air defense, anti-surface warfare, and anti-submarine warfare. Terminal defense SAMs, which protect only the host ship, are not considered a battle force missile.” Thus, weapons like RAM, ESSM, SA-N-9, Mistral, and HHQ-10 point defense SAMs would not count toward the tally of BFM. (source)



Looking at the BFM , Algeria won in every measures.

  • 2x Meko A200 = 32x RBS-15MK3
  • 3x Adhafer =24x C-802
  • 1x Kalaat Bani Abbes = 8 Aster 30 Area defense missile
  • 4 x Kilo 636 = 16 Kalibr SLCM

Total BFM = 80

Morroccan Navy :

  • 2x Floreal FFL = 4 Exocet MM.38
  • 1x FREMM = 8 Exocet MM40
  • 1x Sigma 10513 = 8 Exocet MM40
  • 2x Sigma 9813 = 8 Exocet MM40

Total BFM =28
 
Last edited:

Sami1234

Committed member
Messages
257
Reactions
293
Nation of residence
Algeria
Nation of origin
Algeria
Algeria will easily squad W this, even the Americans know it, the last maneuvers they placed the Moroccan forces back in the Atlas Mountains
FVtyQrCXsAEKeWg.jpeg.jpg

All this keep in mind that 80% of the Moroccan army is not even inside Morocco they are in the sand well in Western Sahara that's a Big L for them, i said it before, if Morocco picked a fight with Algeria that would be the dumbest idea in their whole history. they'd better stay at the lvl of the Sahrawi Army 🇪🇭💪.
 
Last edited:

TR_123456

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
5,076
Reactions
12,632
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
I still do not see any superiority of the Moroccan Air Force over Algeria Especially since Algeria will operate after the year of 2025 the modernized Su-30 + Su-57E + Su-34 and MiG-29M2 fighters with large number of locally made chinese drone Protected by our air defense forces, which are the first without a doubt in Africa..Personally, I see that the air superiority is in the favor of Algeria, and what we really lack is the AWACS planes
Lets talk allies,who are your allies?
 

Knowledgeseeker

Experienced member
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Morocco Moderator
Messages
1,815
Reactions
20 4,631
Nation of residence
Norway
Nation of origin
Moroco
Hm......
There are many factors to be considered tbh
Since Morrocco and Algeria have shared land borders, I dont think the navy will be the decisive factor in a possible confrontation; especially when such nations are buying weapons from abroad and not producing them domestically

Now, for land forces I think Algeria has the edge considering their massive numbers while Morroco may have a better airforce or lets say "more effective and effecient" airforce by using better drones and planes

Many members are already talking about the technical factors of the armies in such a scenario and thus I wanna share a new point of view

However, IMO, the true factor in this war will be MONEY!
A war between Algeria and Morocco wont only be bloody but way too long as well and war cost money; from maintaining troops to stockpiling ammunitions. Thus, the country with the most stable source of income will have the edge in such war of attrition. Typically, such sources of income are either Food or Gas! (yes production isnt that amazing during wartime!) And since Algeria has gas and a greater land area; hey do have an edge in a possible warfare scenario. Therefore, if Morroco wanna win it needs to be quick and decisive which is quite difficult since Algeria is just way too big for it to be conquered quickly
When you say massive numbers are you refering to quantity in land vehicles? Morocco is one of the food self producing countries in the world. Algerian economy is relying on export of gas, and if morocco cut of this supplies then it would be a huge problem for Algeria.
 

Knowledgeseeker

Experienced member
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Morocco Moderator
Messages
1,815
Reactions
20 4,631
Nation of residence
Norway
Nation of origin
Moroco
NATO standard is a way to rate the forces compared to NATO forces,except the new members from the old soviet states.

If you look at the official numbers,Algeria beats Morocco in every scenario but Russia should have beaten Ukraine in two weeks which as you know didnt happen.
Thats we need more info.

@500 can you make comparison between the Armed Forces of Algeria and Morocco?
What do you mean by official numbers? I will post tommorow a post about the experience, and training of morocco.
 

Knowledgeseeker

Experienced member
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Morocco Moderator
Messages
1,815
Reactions
20 4,631
Nation of residence
Norway
Nation of origin
Moroco
Air force : While Moroccan air force is relatively smaller, but the F-16s Morocco has just blows the competition, it has a better engine (F100-PW-229) , better avionics (AN/APG-68v(9) + APG-83 AESA radar) and a more advanced and diverse armament.

#ENGINE

The engine on the Moroccan Vipers is the powerful and tested Pratt F100-PW-229 with 130kN thrust and most importanly a far longer mean time between overhaul (MTBO) than the Su and MiG Lyulka AL-31 and Klimov RD-33 series.

Engine life comparison

  1. Pratt F100 PW-229 EEP : 8000 hours
  2. Lyulka Al-31F : 900-1500 hours
  3. RD-33 : 700 hours

That means the F-16s will spend most of their active service flying instead of doing repairs and overhauls.

Indonesian air force both operate the F-16 A/B and C/D all of which uses the older Prat F-100-PW-220E and the SU-27/30 with Lyulka Al-31F. Overall our air force prefer the F-16 and the F-16s remains Indonesian air force backbone. The Sukhois are known hangar que**.

Note: there are some difference on the engine life hours, but overall Russian engines are more prone to overhauls. As note the AL-31F could be overhauled twice and then it must be dumped.


#ARMAMENTS

A2A

This is where the F-16 particularly shines, starting from the AAM. The F-16 has a lavish choice firing multiple NATO standard air to air munitions, but to keep it real we’re talking the two standard Fox 2 and Fox 3 missile in Moroccan inventory the AIM-9 and AIM-120

The latest iteration for the Sidewinders is the dash 9X blk II, which offers significant improvement in target discrimination than the dash 9X block I and improved off boresight capability. The Algerian principal short range AAM is the R-73 which also offers the same off boresight capability , but its questionable if its match or exceed the 9X, because unlike the Archer, the Sidewinder has incremental improvement program from time to time.

The same could be said with the Fox 3s, the principal long range AAM of the Moroccans is the AMRAAM while the Algerians, the Adder AA-12. While both are classified as medium to long range missile, just like the AIM-9X, the AIM-120D benefitted from Pentagon incremental upgrade of the missile, there has been 4 block iteration of the AIM-120 since its introduction in the 90s , while the AA-12 has only one.

The AIM-120D are reportedly able to achieve the longest air to air kills ever recorded on an air breathing target last year.

Other than that, Moroccan F1s also employed the MICA which is a very agile air to air missile

A2G

The war in Ukraine shows us that Russian air force platforms has not invested significantly on targeting pods to employ laser guided smart bombs and continue to rely on old iron bombs and missiles (which are very expensive).

The F-16s (especially that employed by Morocco) are able to lob precision bombs usually in the forms of either the GPS/INS guided JDAM, laser guided Paveways or the GPS+Laser LJDAM/ French AASM all of which are deployed on the Moroccan F-16s and Mirage F1s.

All those smart bombs could hit their target precisely because the Royal Marocco Air Force (RMAF) had invested significantly in the use of targeting pods.

Some of the advanced pods employed by RMAF :

  • Goodrich DB-110
  • Litening
  • Damocles
  • Sniper
Algerian air force do have their own smart bombs, but most of it are heavy and big, KAB-1500L for example, and because Russian smart bomb kits aren’t produced nearly as much as their US counterparts, its must be very expensive due to lack of economy of scale, hence bought in limited number. Also being Russian platform, it doesn’t really have anything close to the targeting pods deployed by Western jets. I am aware of the T220/E targeting pod , but its performance questionable, and if I’m not mistaken Russian air force themselves had not used any of those.

Both RMAF and AAF deployed anti radiation missile (AGM-88b and KH-31PD)

Both RMAF and AAF deployed shor range A2G missile (AGM-65 and Kh-29), but the AGM-65 is a lot smaller in size for the same role and performance. More missile could be carried.

AAF Su and MiG’s are equipped with the KH-59MK ALCM, while the RMAF will soon uses the Delilah, both are combat proven in both Syria (IAF) and Ukraine (used by RuAF). But AAF leads this time.

RMAF F-16 will soon be equipped with the RGM-84L Block II Harpoon AShM, replacing or augmenting existing AM-39 launched from the Mirage F1s.

#Avionics.

Let me explain, the mechanically scanned and electronically scanned radar has nothing to do with efficiency. Its more to do wth radar beam steering.

A mechanically scanned radar could be superior than a PESA radar if the software and T/R module is better. Being mechanical has nothing to do with target discrimination, an electronically scanned radar steers the radar beam electronically to all side while mechanical steered ones used (as the name suggest) mechanical arms to swing the plate around. But yes, PESA could scan the skies faster than mechanically scanned ones.

AESA radar can achieve better signal to noise ratio compared to PESA (better signal to noise ratio will improve radar detection range). AESA design is approximately 2.79 dB better than PESA design in that aspect ( or about 47% better )

lna-and-noise1.png


Furthermore , since individuals T/R modules on AESA do not rely on a single high power amplifier, they can transmit signal at different frequencies at the same time. As a result, an AESA can form several independent beams at different frequencies simultaneously by dividing the array into a few smaller sub-array, that improves its multitasking capabilities.


AESA is also very resilient to jam and could actually used in jamming role as demonstrated by the APG-83 on the Lightning.

Russia does not produce AESA (safe for maybe the Su-57s) and its performance is questionable.

The SABR APG-83 installed on the Vipers are 3rd gen AESA radars, not all AESA are equal, and because this is US made, its more mature. It is reportedly developed with lessons from the APG-81 Radar (the most advanced radar on any flying jets)

The F-16s are equipped with the LINK 16 data links, I don’t have to explain why data links are important and overall Moroccan orders for its electronics package are more extensive as you can read in this link below


The biggest L for the RMAF is their F-16s are not supported by the necessary air refueling tanker to do air to air refueling. (and so do us, Indonesians lololol), but good for them , RMAF had those CFT as standard and a more fuel efficient F100 PW-229 engine


#Pilot kit.

Moroccan Pilot are equipped with the latest JHMCS II helmet mounted cueing system which not only looks better, it is a step ahead than the Sura HMCS used by Su and MiG pilots

#crew

At best this is questionable, but RMAF pilots do train with the best (USAF). Air forces train with their weapons supplier and the Russian air force performance are laid bare for everyone to see. But until an actual Morocco v Algeria war happens this is at best guessing.


Next : NAVY

Navies firepower in WW1 and WW2 are measured in their throw weight, while modern navy firepower are measured by the battle force missile (BFM).

BFMs are missiles that “contribute to battle force missions such as area and local air defense, anti-surface warfare, and anti-submarine warfare. Terminal defense SAMs, which protect only the host ship, are not considered a battle force missile.” Thus, weapons like RAM, ESSM, SA-N-9, Mistral, and HHQ-10 point defense SAMs would not count toward the tally of BFM. (source)



Looking at the BFM , Algeria won in every measures.

  • 2x Meko A200 = 32x RBS-15MK3
  • 3x Adhafer =24x C-802
  • 1x Kalaat Bani Abbes = 8 Aster 30 Area defense missile
  • 4 x Kilo 636 = 16 Kalibr SLCM

Total BFM = 80

Morroccan Navy :

  • 2x Floreal FFL = 4 Exocet MM.38
  • 1x FREMM = 8 Exocet MM40
  • 1x Sigma 10513 = 8 Exocet MM40
  • 2x Sigma 9813 = 8 Exocet MM40

Total BFM =28
Nice to see more detailed explanation around the systems, and missiles the airforces are using! Thank you for providing value bro!
 

Knowledgeseeker

Experienced member
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Morocco Moderator
Messages
1,815
Reactions
20 4,631
Nation of residence
Norway
Nation of origin
Moroco
That changes alot,doesnt it?
I believe it does. Algeria is getting more and more isolated politcally speaking as western world starting to acknowledge the effort of morocco in sahara inclduding the hole arab world. Algeria had great support from Egypt earlier, and egypt where also involved in the sand war between morocco and algeria. I have to mention that the arab world would always try to mediate betweeen the 2 states, but morocco definitly has a edge there.
 

Sami1234

Committed member
Messages
257
Reactions
293
Nation of residence
Algeria
Nation of origin
Algeria
I believe it does. Algeria is getting more and more isolated politcally speaking as western world starting to acknowledge the effort of morocco in sahara inclduding the hole arab world. Algeria had great support from Egypt earlier, and egypt where also involved in the sand war between morocco and algeria. I have to mention that the arab world would always try to mediate betweeen the 2 states, but morocco definitly has a edge there.
Do you know that all the companies investing in Algerian oil and gas are Americans and Europeans? calling Algeria an isolated country in the middle of a gas crisis in Europe
 

Knowledgeseeker

Experienced member
Moderator
Arab Moderator
Morocco Moderator
Messages
1,815
Reactions
20 4,631
Nation of residence
Norway
Nation of origin
Moroco
Guys please stay on topic, everything else will be deleted.
 

Sami1234

Committed member
Messages
257
Reactions
293
Nation of residence
Algeria
Nation of origin
Algeria
That will help alot.
Officially Algeria ranks above Morocco in numbers.
Don't listen to him he is not telling the truth, most of his army is in Western Sahara not even in Morocco keep that in mind or do a quick research about the sand wall.
 
Last edited:

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
10,839
Reactions
6 18,674
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
How many wars did the Algerians and Moroccans have?

It seems to be historical I know the Western Sahara plays a role but Ottoman Algeria and Morocco seem to have had their own fair share clashes for centuries.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom