Indonesia Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,535
Solutions
2
Reactions
119 25,122
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Good bisa buat backup.

Yes, if the boat already located then send DSRV but if we are still in the searching phase then better to use side-scan sonar. Side-scan sonar is looks like a torpedo and towed by the host ship, so the operating depth can be adjusted.

That's how ocean infinity able to found Argentine sunken sub (depth : about 800 m), even the ship can map southern indian ocean in the seach of MH370 (depth: few km).

Effective range? Ulur kabelnya biar bisa lebih dalem.
Another submarine hasn't been sent there for nothing (i presume it is on the way), it is one of the best way to localize the submarine using passive receivers. If crew is alive they will be tapping to the hull, it is better if other surface vessels are silent so that another submarine can hear them.
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
3,191
Reactions
4 2,819
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
FYI for all
It seems some Indon medias blatantly copy paste what we discuss here without giving the slightest credit to whoever the author here. They merely translating it using machine translation.

To the journalist in question : mas, saya paham Anda kerja dikejar target artikel harian. Tapi kalau Anda main copas mentah2x apa yang kami diskusikan minimal kasih acknowledgment credit buat para forumer disini khususnya si penuliasnya. Jangan cuma jadi silent reader disini trus kau copas mentah2x. Brengsek kau kalau mainmu gitu❗
Salty.
Can you give source? Mungkin bisa dibagi sini saucenya.
 

FPXAllen

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,126
Reactions
4 1,702
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
FYI for all
It seems some Indon medias blatantly copy paste what we discuss here without giving the slightest credit to whoever the author here. They merely translating it using machine translation.

To the journalist in question : mas, saya paham Anda kerja dikejar target artikel harian. Tapi kalau Anda main copas mentah2x apa yang kami diskusikan minimal kasih acknowledgment credit buat para forumer disini khususnya si penuliasnya. Jangan cuma jadi silent reader disini trus kau copas mentah2x. Brengsek kau kalau mainmu gitu❗
Uh, I was confused because at first I thought this was directed at me. But then after reading it again, I understand that's not the case.

Now I'm curious, which local medias?
 

joedhie2k

Committed member
Messages
151
Reactions
196
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
nobody in local media has slightest technical or operational knowledge of a submarine.. if you want, you can get interviewed
 

Captain Wales

Committed member
Messages
227
Reactions
188
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
oh and while we are on the topic of submarine rescue, personally, I would prefer us to do RnD on DSRV rather than midget subs. At least the role and benefit are much clearer
yes just like @NEKO said above, it would be expensive to do RnD on DSRV alone.
better buy the system from company like james fisher and sons and got TOT from them, they already specialized on deep sea operation and their system already proven and operated by much of the world navy.

even all of the sub rescue system that coming to help indonesia were made from them
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,535
Solutions
2
Reactions
119 25,122
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
That is bad. I don't think they brought enough candles to produce oxygen
I am sure they can ration it and squeeze the endurance as long as possible. The matter is finding sub as soon as possible and getting in contact with the crew.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,535
Solutions
2
Reactions
119 25,122
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Technically risky and $ risky.
Suddenly developing DSRV for very deep operation and after spending lots of money probably would only purchase 1 or 2, and I dont think it will success on international market.
JFD has aided some countries to build their own DSRV, it is rather they design it and the customer country modifies some parts like secure hatches etc. It is not that expensive too, one DSRV is sufficient.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,535
Solutions
2
Reactions
119 25,122
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
yes just like @NEKO said above, it would be expensive to do RnD on DSRV alone.
better buy the system from company like james fisher and sons and got TOT from them, they already specialized on deep sea operation and their system already proven and operated by much of the world navy.

even all of the sub rescue system that coming to help indonesia were made from them
Nobody makes DSRV from scratch there are a few builders experienced on that. The rest is product of these countries made locally or slightly modified. Not a big cost at all granting what it provides.

Crew + crew under training + experts costs at least a billion $. Not yet accounting for human life and prestige.
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
657
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
And how can one stating that the location has not been found yet at the same time able to determine the depth❓
it was from different sources,
1 states that the sub has not yet to be found,
the other sources states that
if the sub exceeds more than 500 meters, the hull will no longer able to resist the depth preassure
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
3,191
Reactions
4 2,819
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Even without TOT is fine.

I am sure they can ration it and squeeze the endurance as long as possible. The matter is finding sub as soon as possible and getting in contact with the crew.
They can use scrubber to remove Co2 probably there is several canister of it onboard, but during kursk accident there is a possibility that the surviving crews got killed because of fire created by the scrubber, its getting mixed with salt water or something and during priz accident the crews survived because of the scrubber, it make them survive long enough until getting rescued.
 

Indos

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
1,219
Reactions
1,537
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Another submarine hasn't been sent there for nothing (i presume it is on the way), it is one of the best way to localize the submarine using passive receivers. If crew is alive they will be tapping to the hull, it is better if other surface vessels are silent so that another submarine can hear them.

If the submarine is not in deep water, I think technically we can use our other submarine to rescue those sailors right ??
 

FPXAllen

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,126
Reactions
4 1,702
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
If the submarine is not in deep water, I think technically we can use our other submarine to rescue those sailors right ??

how could a submarine rescue each other
It can. If said submarine is carrying deep sea rescue vessel, like this:

1514910622216.jpg


Unfortunately, as far as my knowledge goes, we don't have such rescue vessel.
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
657
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
still, the best way to rescue the sailor aboard the sub is using dsrv, either it deployed from the surface ship, or a submarine one as a mother ship
images (4).jpeg
images (10).jpeg

+i dont own the pict
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
3,191
Reactions
4 2,819
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Uh, I was confused because at first I thought this was directed at me. But then after reading it again, I understand that's not the case.

Now I'm curious, which local medias?
So you also write article about this?

It can. If said submarine is carrying deep sea rescue vessel, like this:

1514910622216.jpg



Unfortunately, as far as my knowledge goes, we don't have such rescue vessel.

If its shallow and don't need DSRV then why don't the crew just immediately reach the surface? Its not like other sub have decompression chamber and complex and complete health facility.

Sorry i mixed it with post from other member.
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
657
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
FYI for all
It seems some Indon medias blatantly copy paste what we discuss here without giving the slightest credit to whoever the author here. They merely translating it using machine translation.

To the journalist in question : mas, saya paham Anda kerja dikejar target artikel harian. Tapi kalau Anda main copas mentah2x apa yang kami diskusikan minimal kasih acknowledgment credit buat para forumer disini khususnya si penuliasnya. Jangan cuma jadi silent reader disini trus kau copas mentah2x. Brengsek kau kalau mainmu gitu❗
aaaah this one kah

 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
3,191
Reactions
4 2,819
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
section 3, page 18:

3.10. ABILITY OF THE DISSUB TO SIGNAL HER POSITION
a. The crew of a DISSUB may be able to indicate her position by one or more of the following methods:
1. Releasing one or two indicator buoys.
2. Firing Submarine Launched One Way Transmission (SLOT) buoys which transmit on VHF JEZEBEL Channels 25, 27, 29 or 31.
3. Firing an expendable communications buoy (ECB) or SEPIRB, which will transmit a SARBE DF beacon.
4. Firing yellow or white smoke candles or red or green grenades. The smoke candles may have fluorescent dye containers attached, which produce patches of green dye in the water, and may also carry a message
5. Transmitting her name in voice plain language and/or in SST mode on the UWT.
6. Transmitting on sonar, echo sounder, or by using emergency location beacons.
7. Hull tapping.
8. Releasing fuel or lubricating oil.
9. Switching on navigation or other underwater lights


They shouldn't have mentioned about the oil spill there are at least 10 other reasons i can list right now for the cause of oil spill.
Since they haven't reported and acoustical anomaly, indicating an explosion or implosion -bubble rise, it means the chances are still high for them to be safe.
aaaah this one kah
aaaah this one kah

 

FPXAllen

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,126
Reactions
4 1,702
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
So you also write article about this?

I did. My apologies, I'm not trying to self promote myself or anything. But here's what I wrote:

https://gbp.com.sg/regional_stories/kapal-selam-tni-al-kri-nanggala-hilang-kontak-di-laut-bali/

Or in English:


I've only written what's confirmed at the time of writing and no, I didn't just 'google translate' anyone posts from here.


If its shallow and don't need DSRV then why don't the crew just immediately reach the surface? Its not like other sub have decompression chamber and complex and complete health facility.

Sorry i mixed it with post from other member.

The current world record for free diving is 214 meters and it can only be achieved through rigorous training which is not everyone's forte. From that depth, one must pause several times during surfacing to allow the nitrogen build-up inside blood vessels to dissipate first before continue. If the diver surfaced too fast, he / she risks decompression sickness which can be fatal.

I have talked with TNI-AL divers on several ocassions. If memory serves me right, they told me that it's not a simple task to surface from 'just' 50 meter depth even with diving equipments.

Edit: here's the link about free diving and decompression risks for anyone interested:

 
Last edited:

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom