India Jet Engines and Gas Turbines

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
9,827
Reactions
120 19,949
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India

hugh

Committed member
Messages
223
Reactions
3 623
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Is it reasonable to expect the engines first flight(other than the Russian testbed) within a year?
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
9,827
Reactions
120 19,949
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Is it reasonable to expect the engines first flight(other than the Russian testbed) within a year?

Doubtful, this program has been given very low priority for so many years now and its suffered....as seen by this long space of time between the first flying test bed tests with Russians earlier being ~ 10 years etc.

With catch up need (of larger jet engine propulsion ecosystem) and also trying to deploy it (dry version) on the Stealth UAV platform (which will also take some years to complete), it will probably proceed at its leisurely place, dependent on where things stand now with the FTB results whatever those are and the later feedback loop created from afterburner version.

India is unfortunately very red-tape bureaucrat heavy on a number of things and it costs India a lot. There was simply lot more intra-service consensus and impetus w.r.t: space, missiles, radars etc (where production was actually done to learn, iterate and take forward with concrete design freezes where needed) compared to jet propulsion and it shows.
 

hugh

Committed member
Messages
223
Reactions
3 623
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
India is unfortunately very red-tape bureaucrat heavy on a number of things and it costs India a lot. There was simply lot more intra-service consensus and impetus w.r.t: space, missiles, radars etc (where production was actually done to learn, iterate and take forward with concrete design freezes where needed) compared to jet propulsion and it shows.
I remember, reading online, Indians boasting Modi for his approach towards the country's "neglected" defence industry. I thought he brought some urgency to the indigenous defence programs?

I'm not a fan of Erdogan but he takes this business very seriously. It's either you deliver(and deliver on time) or get sacked. I wouldn't want to venture out of my depth regarding Indian politics or bureaucracy but political will and good execution are vital for any major defence projects, imho.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
9,827
Reactions
120 19,949
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
I remember, reading online, Indians boasting Modi for his approach towards the country's "neglected" defence industry. I thought he brought some urgency to the indigenous defence programs?

I'm not a fan of Erdogan but he takes this business very seriously. It's either you deliver(and deliver on time) or get sacked. I wouldn't want to venture out of my depth regarding Indian politics or bureaucracy but political will and good execution are vital for any major defence projects, imho.

Well Kaveri was already separated from its major end-use (Tejas) in 2008 or so as it missed some crucial parameters. This preceded Modi coming to power, there was some impetus from one defence minister he had (w.r.t Tejas, but again Kaveri was already disjointed from it)....but the larger issue is Indian govt fiscal resource strain and way it handles this with bureaucrats it has (who is delegated with prioritisation where).

Once you unlock deterrence levels with nukes + missiles and have the 80s-90s situation where India was facing massive fiscal pressure at low GDP per capita along with internal, regional and international security pressure that needed opex (further constraining what you have for capex especially from statist tax+ public debt+spend which has its own pressure from rest of larger govt)....this just baked in lot of things to begin with at to decision tree forks in the road. Things like jet engines need large amounts of commited capex in the end.

It affects means to an end (objectives wise) approach in various branches of govt and especially defence bureaucracy....when you can do means for sake of means somewhat inductively....the GDP per capita is still very low so there is large fiscal pressure overhang always if you look at Indian govt budget and reluctance for deep reform there (that needs to really come first for that attitude to expand to where statism is much more entrenched w.r.t defence autarky) etc.
 

dronie

Active member
Messages
48
Reactions
1 53
Nation of residence
India
Nation of origin
India
I remember, reading online, Indians boasting Modi for his approach towards the country's "neglected" defence industry. I thought he brought some urgency to the indigenous defence programs?

I'm not a fan of Erdogan but he takes this business very seriously. It's either you deliver(and deliver on time) or get sacked. I wouldn't want to venture out of my depth regarding Indian politics or bureaucracy but political will and good execution are vital for any major defence projects, imho.
Well simply ask if they will get more votes and political support on building a jet engine or a massive high speed rail network ? His supporters and detractors both like to paint him as some strong man /dictator when all every indian PM has been is part of the buerocracy and having nukes makes you more "secure" in the mind.
 

kakaliam2

Member
Messages
8
Reactions
2 12
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
India
I remember, reading online, Indians boasting Modi for his approach towards the country's "neglected" defence industry. I thought he brought some urgency to the indigenous defence programs?

I'm not a fan of Erdogan but he takes this business very seriously. It's either you deliver(and deliver on time) or get sacked. I wouldn't want to venture out of my depth regarding Indian politics or bureaucracy but political will and good execution are vital for any major defence projects, imho.
It's a problem of larger system. You can't simply fire a Government Employee. The Indian Judiciary which often lives in Ivory Towers sides with David even if he is wrong.

Cut the bureaucracy and for the poor level of Manufacturing and lack of ancillary ecosystem we have now 4 SSBNs and the next 13,000-Ton one already in Construction. That is what happened since that program is directly under PMO.

As far as Jet Engine is concerned there are improvements. The New Engine that is now called K9* will be mated with a New Afterburner with weight of only some 110Kg heavier. They didn't sit idle. Weight was brought down from 1500 Kg to some ~1140 Kg for same performance as F404. The next plan for them is to do the same thing GE did- Upgun to F414 class.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom