Live Conflict Pakistan-India Tensions

TheInsider

Experienced member
Professional
Messages
4,280
Solutions
1
Reactions
41 15,287
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I think it is logical to de-escalate the situation. It is crystal clear that Pakistan is well prepared for this. IMHO, India tried to get the upper hand before Pakistan receives J-35s in 2026, hoping RAFALEs and SU-30MKIs will have the upper hand and force Pakistan into some kind of a deal. This is not the case, and I think this might turn into a situation where you bet more money to win back the money you lose and lose even more. If things get out of hand, without air superiority, drones will reign supreme, and Pakistan might launch military ops inside Indian controlled Kashmir with the help of its combat drone fleet.
 

RMZN

Committed member
Messages
183
Reactions
5 419
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Because clearly in current conflict India is the loser, Do you guys think to save face India will escalate this even further by launching another attack or will they deescalate the situation and take the BIG FAT L this time by doing nothing ?
Depends on if Pakistan is willing to let direct strikes into Pakistani territory be answered with these aircraft shootdowns or if they launch counterstrikes into Indian territory, to which India would need to respond in kind.
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,867
Reactions
99 9,379
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
I think it is logical to de-escalate the situation. It is crystal clear that Pakistan is well prepared for this. IMHO, India tried to get the upper hand before Pakistan receives J-35s in 2026, hoping RAFALEs and SU-30MKIs will have the upper hand and force Pakistan into some kind of a deal. This is not the case, and I think this might turn into a situation where you bet more money to win back the money you lose and lose even more. If things get out of hand, without air superiority, drones will reign supreme, and Pakistan might launch military ops inside Indian controlled Kashmir with the help of its combat drone fleet.

On the contrary. If it escalate it will likely be bad for Pakistan. Let me explain it in some details later.
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
10,161
Reactions
126 20,626
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
Heck, ill just post my take I gave (in a DM) here openly:

They didnt enter. They just did some stand-off lobbing with no proper SEAD/DEAD beforehand is my guess. So the HQ-9 probably shot down stuff as IAD was lit up to receive them....along with whichever CAP with the new PL-15.

The timing was way too early. A month should have been given at least (along with feints/tricks to desensitize Pakistan response pattern) to get pakistan to expend economically/psychologically first a lot more....and then SEAD/DEAD has to be done the proper way on SAMs at the very least.

The AWACS (as to properly controlling strike vectors to respond/optimize to whichever CAP snapshot in the air) also was terrible as there was some decision to hit these targets no matter what etc (rather than keep that somewhat more fluid).

IAF is just garbage at this conflict tier....too much hubris and blockheadedness w.r.t what they have.

It is fundamentally "at best" designed for an all out war to support major land thrusts and taking/inflicting the real attrition past the apex one-off stuff its being forced to do in this window of time.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
2,940
Reactions
99 13,643
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
A lesson is in order on what "flag flying in the wind direction" means.

1746631038507.png

@Sanchez as well, good job. Balanced objective analysis. Thank you. It is lacking in so many other "fora".
Just trying to employ some common sense. If everyone did that, we'd be golden. Can't have nice shit though.

The timing was way too early. A month should have been given at least (along with feints/tricks to desensitize Pakistan response pattern) to get pakistan to expend economically/psychologically first a lot more....and then SEAD/DEAD has to be done the proper way on SAMs at the very least.
Similar populations, they had to give a response soon. If Pakistanis don't retaliate, they'll bury the losses under fakenews and be done with it. Ground strikes were mostly successful after all.

On the right image is RAFALE written too. I don't understand what that tweet tries to tell us.

Grasping at straws to come out on top of internet arguments.

Meanwhile, in the real world

As all the wrecks we've been talking about are already found in the Indian side of the border, his initial point is moot.

technically drones are also aircraft and we shot those down
Drones don't have M88 engines or ejection seats.
 

Strong AI

Contributor
Messages
1,392
Reactions
45 5,352
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
A lesson is in order on what "flag flying in the wind direction" means.

View attachment 74966

Just trying to employ some common sense. If everyone did that, we'd be golden. Can't have nice shit though.


Similar populations, they had to give a response soon. If Pakistanis don't retaliate, they'll bury the losses under fakenews and be done with it. Ground strikes were mostly successful after all.



Grasping at straws to come out on top of internet arguments.
On the right image is RAFALE written too. I don't understand what that tweet tries to tell us.
I think that tweet talks only about the RAFALE text, it is highlighted in yellow.
But on that image claimed to be false is literally written RAFALE too. No?
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Moderator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
10,161
Reactions
126 20,626
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
A lesson is in order on what "flag flying in the wind direction" means.

View attachment 74966

Just trying to employ some common sense. If everyone did that, we'd be golden. Can't have nice shit though.


Similar populations, they had to give a response soon. If Pakistanis don't retaliate, they'll bury the losses under fakenews and be done with it. Ground strikes were mostly successful after all.



Grasping at straws to come out on top of internet arguments.

I'll give my thoughts (deeper ones as to Indian decision making and its severe problems) later on after dust settles more and things are calmer.

As there could be Pakistan retaliations and then any other escalation ladders that has to be waited out first anyway.

Plus Indian ecosystem (political, media etc) gives me a migraine much like Pakistani one gives (fair minded) Pakistanis a migraine on their end too.
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,867
Reactions
99 9,379
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
Heck, ill just post my take I gave (in a DM) here openly:

Along with this, let me add something that a distinguished Pakistani gentlemen (Oscar) posted in other forum to get a fairly sensible Pak perspective. (Who knows more then any other Pak folks IMO)

"Because right when they hit it they handed over dossiers claiming all these locations were terrorist hideouts - linking to internationally declared terrorist orgs - and in it claimed they did their best by using small munitions to avoid civilian causalities.

They had additional targets - and as they tried to force in have been brought down in the process. Then they pivoted to thinking of activating cold start but without the ability to push PAF out are nervous about launching their strike corps on just SAM cover.

If you hit them - they will disregard caution and this goes well beyond this and their numbers ensure that they will prevail in places while you hold them in others.
Both sides bleed but they have a lot more sustaining resources than you.


So either you will cave then, or launch nukes - either way the calculus is bad but there is a mix of hawkish egos on both sides along with wanting a face saving withdrawal which everyone including all your allies are pushing."



To simply put, Indian armed forces usually start (I am generalizing) looking a bit disorganized in early responses and initiatives in short lived tactical events. (Like this or the one in 2019) However, in the logn shot as time passes and they get their act together, they utilize their number and resource advantage. @Sanchez @TheInsider



PS: Right now this is looking ominous because Pak seems to be preparing to hit back (hard?)
 

steppeWolf

Active member
Messages
72
Reactions
2 69
Nation of residence
Pakistan
Nation of origin
Pakistan
I think it is logical to de-escalate the situation. It is crystal clear that Pakistan is well prepared for this. IMHO, India tried to get the upper hand before Pakistan receives J-35s in 2026, hoping RAFALEs and SU-30MKIs will have the upper hand and force Pakistan into some kind of a deal. This is not the case, and I think this might turn into a situation where you bet more money to win back the money you lose and lose even more. If things get out of hand, without air superiority, drones will reign supreme, and Pakistan might launch military ops inside Indian controlled Kashmir with the help of its combat drone fleet.
It won't de-escalate. Shooting down of IAF planes last night was a defensive measure. It wasn't the retaliation. The retaliation is YET to come.
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
4,867
Reactions
99 9,379
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh

French official says Pakistan downed Rafale jet as officials examine possible further losses​

From CNN’s Saskya Vandoorne in Paris

A high-ranking French intelligence official told CNN today that one Rafale fighter jet operated by the Indian Air Force was downed by Pakistan, in what would mark the first time that one of the sophisticated French-made warplanes has been lost in combat.

Pakistan claimed earlier today to have shot down five Indian Air Force jets in retaliation for Indian strikes, including three Rafales. Indian officials are yet to respond to the claim.

The French official told CNN that French authorities were looking into whether more than one Rafale jets were shot down by Pakistan overnight.
Pictures taken of parts of an aircraft that crashed in Indian-administered Kashmir show the label of a French manufacturer, but experts said it was not possible to say whether the part came from a Rafale aircraft.

Dassault Aviation, the French manufacturer of the jet, has not responded to CNN’s requests for comment.


 

mTT

Committed member
Messages
299
Reactions
6 753
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom