So you are against Ataturk's path? You realise that secularism simply means a removal of religion from state. This has proven to be a good thing globally. Secular nations are far more successful than their religious counterparts. Governments that rule with religion are generally more corrupt. The west's decline into liberalism is a result of multiple factors, secularism isn't the primary cause. For example, China is staunchly atheist, yet isn't going down that path.
Now that we got that out of the way, notice how I said secular NATIONALISM. AKA not tying Islam to nationalism. Being nationalistic regardless of faith. Much better than forcing ummah nonsense down everyone's throat. We are seeing right now what Islamism does to a country.
If you go back to the first few decades of the establishment of the Republic, you will see how Turkic mythology and Turkic identity was taught to children. Then came political Islam...
That was Ataturks time im calling todays one.
In the past you had lots of pan Islamists in the Ottoman Empire who epoused Turkish nationalism while today most are anti nationalist.
Times have changed. Even Ataturk despite not believing religion still saw it as part of society.
Now today most secular nationalists have turned into progressives.
Not to say religion supports nationalism because it depends really. You will have people who believe religion and nationalism go together while others separate it.
It depends really. I still believe, believing in something is the way to go.
I know science and technology is said to render religion as obsolete. But you gotta believe in something even if it does not make sense.
Religion still played a role in the Turkish independance war.
Thats why the Ottoman sultan and Ataturk used religious symbols to try and woo people into their cause.
I find the whole concept of people rejecting nations and their identity as ridiculous.
Because this bs of we are 1 race or there is 1 ummah is really utopian to its core. Humans by nature are tribal. Concept of a community has existed for centuries.
Another reason why this concept of Ummah has failed well it works as spiritual but politically no and will never.
Same story why communism has failed. Any kind of utopia bs always ends in failure.