Indonesia Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

Umigami

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
6,504
Reactions
7 5,308
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
mightywarr_20210925_080634_0.jpg

mightywarr_20210925_080634_1.jpg

mightywarr_20210925_080634_2.jpg

Can Batamec do this too with their tooling?
 

Chakrabirawa

New member
Messages
2
Reactions
9
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Nice to have 8 canisters SSM + SRSAM in 50 metres ship. Our KCR60 only has about 4 cans of SSM (and without any SAM), no?

View attachment 32024
Yes, dimension wise those boats are on the same class as our KCR 60s. But IMO, they have different functions. Considering Ukraine has smaller water teritory (the Black Sea only) than us, they seem going to utilize these boats as efficient platform to carry anti-ships and anti-air missiles (focusing on more space for CIC, weapon instalation, ammo storage)
From news I read sometimes ago, Ukraine Navy HQ in Crimea was captured by The Russian during the Crimea annexation, along with most of Ukraine Navy's major combatant ships. No idea though, have Ukraine frigates and corvettes returned by The Russian or not. This might lead Ukraine to replace those captured ships with temporary alternatives.
In our case, such tasks are carried by frigates so our KCRs main duty for now are doing patrols (focusing on more space for accomodations, fuels, water and food supplies), but they still retain some anti-ship capability (not sure for the radar and missile spec & readiness tho)
CMIIW
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,915
Reactions
4 10,056
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

They can actually, as they already in possession of some cutting tools (CNC Plasma) ,there is 1000 tonnes bending machine and so on. Their workshop quite spacious
1000-ton-bending-machine.jpg
images (57).jpeg
steel_fabrication.jpg
Main.jpg
cnc-plasma-cutting-machine.jpg


To note, they are in process to build 5500 tonnes Oiler ship for the Navy


First steel cutting in August 2020 and should be finished in 2022.
 

Barjo_2

Active member
Messages
82
Reactions
48
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
who will guarantee the gun on our back is point to the North not at ours to
This is why Indonesia is against AUKUS SSN project.

Facing the dragon at frontline already make cancer, giving Puppet country SSN and big toys only make Indonesia possition getting worst.

From AUKUS pact, we can see if Indonesia will be act as Buffer zone and place to commence the battle.
 

Aghost132483

Active member
Messages
120
Reactions
124
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
So other than PAL , Batamec also get some participation in Arrowhead 140 construction .

"Jakarta, September 23, 2021 --- The Indonesian Navy is strengthening the Main Weapon System Tool (Alutsista) by building a frigate type ship. PT. PAL Indonesia cooperates with Babcock England in the design of the Frigate Arrowhead 140, while for production activities it will cooperate with PT. Batamec. The construction of this frigate type ship was marked by the inauguration of the Project Officer and Commander of the Task Force (Dansatgas) for the construction of frigate ships by the Head of the Navy Procurement Service (Kadisadal) First Admiral of the TNI, Maman Rohman, ST, M.Han at Wisma Elang Laut, Menteng, Central Jakarta. . Thursday (23/09)."

This is the good news I want to hear a long time ago, I hope not only Batamec will have ability to construct the module, but other shipyard too, and one shipyard as place for integration module. I believe with this strategy we could speed up frigate or corvette construction.
 

Parry Brima

Contributor
Messages
982
Reactions
1 1,057
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Found an old Spiegel article about the German U216 offer to Australia. The price mentioned is $16 bil for 12 submarines. So about $1.33 bil per sub.

Not sure we can afford this.

The Germans probably offer us a brand new design that's not as big, nor as advanced as U216.

Heck, even the much shorter and lighter U218SG cost them $900 mil per sub.

========================

"Hamburg - Chancellor Angela Merkel is fighting for one of the most extensive arms export deals in German history. It involves the sale of up to twelve class 216 submarines to Australia . This is what SPIEGEL reports in its new issue .

The deal could bring the German industry an order value of 14 billion euros and is considered "outstanding" in government circles, as the submarine industry would benefit for decades."

 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,915
Reactions
4 10,056
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
So, current confirmed upcoming ship for TNI-AL currently include:

To be built & receive:
- 6x FREMM frigate
- 2x Maestrale frigate
- 2x Arrowhead 140 frigate

In construction:
- 2x KCR-60 FAC
- 2x PC-60m Patrol vessel
- 2x OPV-90m
- 2x 60m MCM vessel
- 1x 125m Replenishment oiler
- 1x 123m Hospital assistance ship

Finishing phase (fitting out equipment):
- 4x 117m LST
- 1x 60m trimaran FAC
- 1x 123m Hospital assistance ship
------------------------------------------------------------- +
Total: 26 ship to be launched, fitted, and crewed for the next 5-15 years.

Also,

Current contract with unclear status:
- 3x DSME Submarine deal
- 1x 95m Replenishment oiler

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's a lot of new crew that needed to man those vessel IMO.

Should Made comprehensive list of TNI AL project

in 2019 Steadfast Marine got contract for two 28 meter class patrol Boats


In 2019 PT Bandar Abadi got contract for two units LST



PC 60 by PT Caputra Mitra Sejati

 

kooppyyy

Active member
Messages
95
Reactions
118
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Found an old Spiegel article about the German U216 offer to Australia. The price mentioned is $16 bil for 12 submarines. So about $1.33 bil per sub.

Not sure we can afford this.

The Germans probably offer us a brand new design that's not as big, nor as advanced as U216.

Heck, even the much shorter and lighter U218SG cost them $900 mil per sub.

========================

"Hamburg - Chancellor Angela Merkel is fighting for one of the most extensive arms export deals in German history. It involves the sale of up to twelve class 216 submarines to Australia . This is what SPIEGEL reports in its new issue .

The deal could bring the German industry an order value of 14 billion euros and is considered "outstanding" in government circles, as the submarine industry would benefit for decades."

I won't use Australia as a comparison. Their acquisition price tends to be bloated due to customization and local production/supplier, just see their SPH acquisition program.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,915
Reactions
4 10,056
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
90 mil euros? that quite reasonable price tho for both MR and LR missiles

that's bullshit, even the MICA missiles for fighter aircraft would cost you around 2,7 million us dollar per round


then according to SIPRI arm trades Indonesia in 2017 bought around 40 MICA missile for Martadinata class (which some would be used as spare and spent for training)

SIPRI.jpg


now we are talking about MR missiles and Long Range Missiles which would cost you arm and legs and we are talking about a much larger VLS configuration compared to Martadinata class
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
657
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
that's bullshit, even the MICA missiles for fighter aircraft would cost you around 2,7 million us dollar per round


then according to SIPRI arm trades Indonesia in 2017 bought around 40 MICA missile for Martadinata class (which some would be used as spare and spent for training)

View attachment 32184

now we are talking about MR missiles and Long Range Missiles which would cost you arm and legs and we are talking about a much larger VLS configuration compared to Martadinata class
ah yes at first i thought it was "kemurahan harganya"
also, that price doesn't include with the vls systems right?
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom