Montreux and Ataturk declaration from 103 retired Turkish admirals

Skyfall

Committed member
Messages
221
Reactions
3 913
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
Why are former military personnel collectively involving themselves in politics? Some members make comparisons between Turkey and Western "Ideals" but give us an example in the West where this has happened. This also reminds me of the University professors that wrote a letter against operations in Syria. Why don't they leave there state paid salaries in protest and form a political party together?
 
T

Turko

Guest
Why are former military personnel collectively involving themselves in politics? Some members make comparisons between Turkey and Western "Ideals" but give us an example in the West where this has happened. This also reminds me of the University professors that wrote a letter against operations in Syria. Why don't they leave there state paid salaries in protest and form a political party together?
First the subject is Montreux and fundamentalism in TN.
Second they weren't not ordinary officers, they were navy admirals who used to conduct doctrines of Turkish government over disputed water.
Who should have made commitment about Montreux , the Ayasofya İmamı ?


İ can't understand what exactly disturbed you, retired admirals complaining about illegal organizations in Turkish Navy.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
4,523
Reactions
6 7,175
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Don't be so brave with these statements so you not to be deceived. Our memory is long.
Why don't you remind people what sects are about instead of talking about memory.
 
S

Sinan

Guest
Why are former military personnel collectively involving themselves in politics? Some members make comparisons between Turkey and Western "Ideals" but give us an example in the West where this has happened. This also reminds me of the University professors that wrote a letter against operations in Syria. Why don't they leave there state paid salaries in protest and form a political party together?
You need to look before.

In a TV program, head of the Turkish parliament said that "Erdogan can null the Montreux agreement with a single signature".
That opened the pandoras box.
 

Skyfall

Committed member
Messages
221
Reactions
3 913
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
First the subject is Montreux and fundamentalism in TN.
Second they are not ordinary officers, they are navy admirals who use to conduct doctrines of Turkish government over disputed water.
Who should have made commitment about Montreux , the Ayasofya İmamı ?


İ can't understand what exactly disturbed you, retired admirals complaining about illegal organizations in Turkish Navy.
What disturbed me is that what's to say these people are not influenced (or lobbied) from people abroad, especially enemies of the State or State enemies.
 

Skyfall

Committed member
Messages
221
Reactions
3 913
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
You need to look before.

In a TV program, head of the Turkish parliament said that "Erdogan can null the Montreux agreement with a single signature".
That opened the pandoras box.
He's an idiot for doing that but most likely AKP testing the water to gauge public opinion.
 

Skyfall

Committed member
Messages
221
Reactions
3 913
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
United Kingdom
What Turkey needs is a decent opposition party to voice public concerns or opinions instead of constant declarations and protests that are always politically motivated.
 
T

Turko

Guest
What disturbed me is that what's to say these people are not influenced (or lobbied) from people abroad, especially enemies of the State or State enemies.
1617617122158.png

Yeah this admiral is not from US Navy!
He serves in Turkish Navy.


Enemy states what exactly did , they after world war one made you signed Sevres Treaty. Thanks to Montreux we barely ebolished it.

We won't allow you removing Atatürk from Turkish Army.
 

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
10,458
Reactions
5 18,063
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Regardless of what side you guys on.

Can we all agree that the straits need to have a transit fee.

All that money need to be made is burning me.
 
S

Sinan

Guest
What Turkey needs is a decent opposition party to voice public concerns or opinions instead of constant declarations and protests that are always politically motivated.
In a democratic country everyone or every group can voice their concerns. You can't criminalize anyone for talking.
 

mulj

Experienced member
Messages
1,989
Reactions
3,243
Nation of residence
Bosnia & Herzegovina
Nation of origin
Bosnia & Herzegovina
Regardless of what side you guys on.

Can we all agree that the straits need to have a transit fee.

All that money need to be made is burning me.
it wont happen, tranches are to deep.
 

Combat-Master

Baklava Consumer
Moderator
Messages
3,667
Reactions
15 25,473
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Montreux Treaty should be abolished, our waters our sovereign right to govern the straits as we please - not others.
 

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
10,458
Reactions
5 18,063
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
View attachment 17591
Yeah this admiral is not from US Navy!
He serves in Turkish Navy.


Enemy states what exactly did , they after world war one made you signed Sevres Treaty. Thanks to Montreux we barely ebolished it.

We won't allow you removing Atatürk from Turkish Army.

What link does sevres and montetruex have???

You do realise it was in Ataturks plan to take over the straits completely during the independance war and in the 1930s.

The allies played dirty with us by denying a military takeover. Same story with Mosul.

Then again im not angry at anybody as our capabilities were limited.
 
T

Turko

Guest
In a democratic country everyone or every group can voice their concerns. You can't criminalize anyone for talking.
He appears to be blind to declarations of the Hagia Sophia Imam while civil servants remain silent during their duties.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
4,523
Reactions
6 7,175
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
View attachment 17591
Yeah this admiral is not from US Navy!
He serves in Turkish Navy.


Enemy states what exactly did , they after world war one made you signed Sevres Treaty. Thanks to Montreux we barely ebolished it.

We won't allow you removing Atatürk from Turkish Army.
What is wrong with this?
Montreux Treaty should be abolished, our waters our sovereign right to govern the straits as we please - not others.
Unlike the olden times power projection to the Black Sea does not rely on navy alone. Cargo planes can carry pretty much anything to anywhere.
 

Combat-Master

Baklava Consumer
Moderator
Messages
3,667
Reactions
15 25,473
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Unlike the olden times power projection to the Black Sea does not rely on navy alone. Cargo planes can carry pretty much anything to anywhere.

You know that's not sustainable, why even suggest such a thing? :)

Black Sea Countries gonna be at mercy of Turkey :) it'll be a hoot !
 
Top Bottom