• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

TR Casual Discussion Çay Bahçesi

Ripley

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
1,428
Reactions
51 4,568
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Turkey
OK, while we’re discussing the order of March of Turkish Navy and its command structure, I will ask for your help guys. Does Turkish Navy hold a rank of Commodore?
I mean, there are North and South marine zone commands and combat fleet commands commanded by various ranks of admirals. But I can’t confirm that we have a rank (*title) as commodore. Is there maybe a title corresponding to it?
@Yasar_TR abi? @Anmdt ?
 

TR_123456

Active member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
27
Reactions
114
Nation of residence
Nethelands
Nation of origin
Turkey
OK, while we’re discussing the order of March of Turkish Navy and its command structure, I will ask for your help guys. Does Turkish Navy hold a rank of Commodore?
I mean, there are North and South marine zone commands and combat fleet commands commanded by various ranks of admirals. But I can’t confirm that we have a rank (*title) as commodore. Is there maybe a title corresponding to it?
@Yasar_TR abi? @Anmdt ?
It should be Tugamiral.
 

TheInsider

Experienced member
Professional
Messages
4,890
Solutions
1
Reactions
51 17,023
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Commodore is not a hierarchical rank in the Turkish Navy, but rather an operational title given to senior colonels who command a flotilla-level naval unit. They are granted the power of an admiral and use the flag and insignia of an admiral even though they are colonels.
 

Ripley

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
1,428
Reactions
51 4,568
Nation of residence
United States of America
Nation of origin
Turkey
Commodore is not a hierarchical rank in the Turkish Navy, but rather an operational title given to senior colonels who command a flotilla-level naval unit. They are granted the power of an admiral and use the flag and insignia of an admiral even though they are colonels.
So the rank that carries the title is colonels, prefarebly a senior one, right? But do we call them commodore while they carry the task, command the filotilla or just call them as their ranks ie, colonel?
 

Nilgiri

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Aviation Specialist
Messages
11,013
Reactions
153 22,476
Nation of residence
Canada
Nation of origin
India
So the rank that carries the title is colonels, prefarebly a senior one, right? But do we call them commodore while they carry the task, command the filotilla or just call them as their ranks ie, colonel?

If it is anything like US system (that started this messy slop of rear admiral lower instead of cleaner commodore in mid 1980s....and then commodore becomes this special captain "+" rank)...

....the crew might often refer to this kind of captain as "Commodore" but in official communications it would always be Captain (or Colonel if you keep same as land forces name - Albay in Turkish I think).

That is the NATO OF-5 standard...and its important since it prevents any clash with other NATO navies that still retain the Commodore rank in OF-6 like say in UK and Canada (as it should be IMO, much cleaner than having two rear admiral types for 1 star and 2 star).
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,762
Solutions
2
Reactions
145 26,692
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
So the rank that carries the title is colonels, prefarebly a senior one, right? But do we call them commodore while they carry the task, command the filotilla or just call them as their ranks ie, colonel?
TL : DR
It is an official position, but not a title. Officially addressed by his own title and they used to (or have to) hold the 'kurmay' title.

Leaving the fancy descriptions aside, specifically when most of people don't even know what an admiral does, or when they are appointed as an admiral; a commodore is commander of a flotilla. Often they are also assigned to the lead ship of the flotilla (on the side of the ship's own commander), they are commander of the flotilla, not the ship but hierarchically still above the captain of the ship.

Commodore is also an official position, which is addressed by 'Komodorluk'.

North and South Zone Commands may not have a commodore, it is typically the Combat Flotilla Command, with an exception of submarine flotilla, having distinct flotilla commands which is consisting of commodore flotillas.

They are officially addressed by ' Staff Colonel Commodore' in direct translation of 'Kurmay Albay Komodor '. And he is also addressed as captain / commander of the ship. It is not a must-have-to condition.

I am not sure how the captain/commander of the ship addresses the commodore (if he is present on the ship) but likely it could be 'commodore' - or my doubt here also extends to rest of the crew / staff.

Combatant flotilla;
FACs,
Frigates,
Corvettes,
Submarines.

North/South;
Landing ships,
Bases,
Patrol boats,
OPVs,
Used to hold an authority over the coast guard - doubting if so nowadays.
 

Okan

Active member
Messages
70
Reactions
2 220
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Ne kadar da tanıdık geliyor.

 
Top Bottom