Indonesia Indonesian Air Force, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Udara (TNI-AU)

Aghost132483

Active member
Messages
120
Reactions
124
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
The more make sense feedback is from Andi Widjayanto as below video


It can give explanation that reaction of CRB is like "emak-emak ngamuk" because she wasn't involved but curious enough to get clarity and finally only to find she's been accused of lying. That's why she brought the issue to public and roasted it. Thus, to calm down this emak emak ngamuk is to invite her to the talks of internal Mindef discussion.
Agree with you, Andi W explanation is more make sense compared to CRB, and CRB kinda looks like artist for reality show with a lot of gimmick, that's why media like to invite her
 
Last edited:

JATOSINT 

Experienced member
Professional
Messages
2,254
Reactions
4 3,224
Website
twitter.com
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
that's our common question....Mr. MoD suppose to involved Mrs. CRB in the process, thus she wont be such noisy like this, watch following video for the chronology of events in details from Mrs. CRB point of view

I'm not sure about the '$124 B harus habis di 2024' thing
 

Mandala

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
874
Reactions
1 1,747
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
According to this article here are some of the items Prabowo plan to buy for each force:

Air Force:
• 36 Rafale
• 36 F-15EX

Army:
• More Leopard 2 MBTs
• 1,200 Carl Gustav anti-tank rifles

Navy:
• 4 Scorpene Submarines
• 2 Gowind Corvettes

 

Parry Brima

Contributor
Messages
982
Reactions
1 1,057
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
I'm not sure about the '$124 B harus habis di 2024' thing

From those $124 bil, only $79 bil that's allocated for procurement. The other $32 bil for maintenance and contingency, and another $13 bil for interest.

We can easily sign many contracts worth total of $79 bil until 2024.

 

Zuko

Active member
Messages
41
Reactions
49
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
According to this article here are some of the items Prabowo plan to buy for each force:

Air Force:
• 36 Rafale
• 36 F-15EX

Army:
• More Leopard 2 MBTs
• 1,200 Carl Gustav anti-tank rifles

Navy:
• 4 Scorpene Submarines
• 2 Gowind Corvettes


Curious how Mindef and all Matra TNI plan to professionally manned the "new equipments"...?

The below last year article mentioned that MoD plans to train 300 combat pilot and 100 hercules pilot over the next 2 years. I am not sure whether this target is even achievable or more of a wishful thinking.

https://www.liputan6.com/bisnis/read/4430355/misi-prabowo-beli-100-jet-tempur-canggih

I am happy that MoD seems focus to rectify previous mistake and putting proper budget/investment toward building capable armed forces....yet I wish its more of a logical and professional plan as opposed to "what it seems" as ego-driven plan. Hopefully I am wrong...... :(
 

Captain Wales

Committed member
Messages
227
Reactions
188
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Curious how Mindef and all Matra TNI plan to professionally manned the "new equipments"...?

The below last year article mentioned that MoD plans to train 300 combat pilot and 100 hercules pilot over the next 2 years. I am not sure whether this target is even achievable or more of a wishful thinking.

https://www.liputan6.com/bisnis/read/4430355/misi-prabowo-beli-100-jet-tempur-canggih

I am happy that MoD seems focus to rectify previous mistake and putting proper budget/investment toward building capable armed forces....yet I wish its more of a logical and professional plan as opposed to "what it seems" as ego-driven plan. Hopefully I am wrong...... :(
one of the fastest way to "train" new pilot is recruiting from already qualified civilian pilot, there's a lot of them are out of job because of pandemic.

while it still take time to re-train/re-qualify them from civilian pilot into fast jet pilot (or transport pilot) but because they already had some experience in flying it still easier to re-train them to be AF pilot then to train new pilot from scratch.

it been done in country like US.
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
According to this article here are some of the items Prabowo plan to buy for each force:

Air Force:
• 36 Rafale
• 36 F-15EX

Army:
• More Leopard 2 MBTs
• 1,200 Carl Gustav anti-tank rifles

Navy:
• 4 Scorpene Submarines
• 2 Gowind Corvettes

why in bloody indonesian earh land, there's no body give a bloody concern about end user oppinion and what they actually want.

Instead all politican and man in power only think about
"Hey, this guy give me more money. Lets buy their stuff" or "This one looks good, i want some" spamming with multiple stuff from foreign vendors.

Wich, in case cause catastropic problem because hard effort to maintenance.

I wonder wether the MOD has already talk the airforce need of plane or Navy need of boats .


If above shopping list is true, i give a go for The army (who will reject Swedish and German supremacy tho), F 15x seems oke, and NOPE for the navy.

But well, , ,
Nothing is change as long as the stuff dint come.
 

R4duga

Experienced member
Messages
1,670
Reactions
2 2,367
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
According to this article here are some of the items Prabowo plan to buy for each force:

Air Force:
• 36 Rafale
• 36 F-15EX

Army:
• More Leopard 2 MBTs
• 1,200 Carl Gustav anti-tank rifles

Navy:
• 4 Scorpene Submarines
• 2 Gowind Corvettes

i only see the gowind one is the strange thing here .
 

Zuko

Active member
Messages
41
Reactions
49
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
one of the fastest way to "train" new pilot is recruiting from already qualified civilian pilot, there's a lot of them are out of job because of pandemic.

while it still take time to re-train/re-qualify them from civilian pilot into fast jet pilot (or transport pilot) but because they already had some experience in flying it still easier to re-train them to be AF pilot then to train new pilot from scratch.

it been done in country like US.

What I can gathered, even in US this is still largely an idea/concept, i.e. recruiting commercial pilots to become combat pilots. Fighter jets especially which I guess would require different physical and mental ability requirements. Imagine fighter jets pilot need to be able to do high G maneuvers whilst civilian/commercial pilots may not need ability to do this.


Again, whilst its good MoD is planning to invest/budget more, I reaaalllly do hope they do proper planning.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,913
Reactions
4 10,053
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
why in bloody indonesian earh land, there's no body give a bloody concern about end user oppinion and what they actually want.

Instead all politican and man in power only think about
"Hey, this guy give me more money. Lets buy their stuff" or "This one looks good, i want some" spamming with multiple stuff from foreign vendors.

Wich, in case cause catastropic problem because hard effort to maintenance.

I wonder wether the MOD has already talk the airforce need of plane or Navy need of boats .


If above shopping list is true, i give a go for The army (who will reject Swedish and German supremacy tho), F 15x seems oke, and NOPE for the navy.

But well, , ,
Nothing is change as long as the stuff dint come.

I am always believe when i see it with myself, leak are more inline with hoaxes, when the said article got contract i still retain my doubt, until the first keel laying being done, till the aircraft got flight tested, or when the vehicles got roll on the roads then i would believe it. That's what is all about Indonesia defense procurement
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
I am always believe when i see it with myself, leak are more inline with hoaxes, when the said article got contract i still retain my doubt, until the first keel laying being done, till the aircraft got flight tested, or when the vehicles got roll on the roads then i would believe it. That's what is all about Indonesia defense procurement
You share my oppinion also, but this time already 3 years back to last election none of the stuff had come 😌


But well "Asal Bapak Senang" motto, still fly around today
 

BBOn

Committed member
Messages
173
Reactions
87
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Agree with you, Andi W explanation is more make sense compared to CRB, and CRB kinda looks like artist for reality show with a lot of gimmick, that's why media like to invite her
Without her "gimmick" this hundred billion dollar will be pass under radar and no one will be curious about what exactly the Mod going to do with your money,my money and everyone money.
Think by your self, how could you put 30 billion dollars for maintenance thing without even tell our representatives what is exactly you are going to buy.
Is that not weird to you? Put aside about how connie talk like an artist, is that really matter compare to her contribution to make things become clear?
I am not her buzzer. But, I really understand what is she try to say. Start to give the KPK acces. Simple. do not hide with rahasia negara again. We talk about procurement. How can we believe the foreign procurement not leaked by outsiders while SIPRI can easily access what we buy and know the exact quantity. We believe foreigners and refuse to believe our own people. Is that make any sense. We dont have strategic weapon like ballistic missile, we dont have bombers or aircraft carrier and our MOD is not funding anything that need lot of money for we can interpret as super secret weapon that need lot of secrecy to keep them safe. Still, we act like we do really have super secret weapon that can make our military supremacy will be endangered if " we tell the monetary inspector agecy ". what a joke.
 
Last edited:

JATOSINT 

Experienced member
Professional
Messages
2,254
Reactions
4 3,224
Website
twitter.com
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
According to this article here are some of the items Prabowo plan to buy for each force:

Air Force:
• 36 Rafale
• 36 F-15EX

Army:
• More Leopard 2 MBTs
• 1,200 Carl Gustav anti-tank rifles

Navy:
• 4 Scorpene Submarines
• 2 Gowind Corvettes

Carl Gustav AT Riffles???

I am always believe when i see it with myself, leak are more inline with hoaxes, when the said article got contract i still retain my doubt, until the first keel laying being done, till the aircraft got flight tested, or when the vehicles got roll on the roads then i would believe it. That's what is all about Indonesia defense procurement
Or until the weapon appeared on our Parade :D
 

joedhie2k

Committed member
Messages
151
Reactions
196
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
aannd whatever quadrilion blah blah blah monies still not mentioning IFX...
rafale is an ugly aircraft anyway.. all that curves but cannot think big hiding the refueling probe
 

Umigami

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
6,450
Reactions
5 5,264
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
aannd whatever quadrilion blah blah blah monies still not mentioning IFX...
rafale is an ugly aircraft anyway.. all that curves but cannot think big hiding the refueling probe
After few flight hour you just gonna forget It's there, so why bother?
 
Top Bottom