I will explore this subject on a thread in Pak section. You see as a secularist I have always tried to figure out why the fcuk are so many Paks crazed with religion? Why do they start and fart religion? It fcukin pores out like a fountain. But it's all feigned as most are as irreligious in substance as any other, if not more than others.
My conclusion was it all began from 1947. The migrants from India moved to Pakistan not because of ethnic, cultural, lingustic etc reasons but because of religion. That 5% of Pak demography mostly centred today in Karachi had a identity crisis. Shorn or sans religion [Muslim] they were just Indians, be they Biharis, Utter Pradeshis or Bengalis. Whereas rest of us majority [95%] Pakistani's were Pakhtuns, Punjabis, Sindhis, Balochis, Kashmiris and thus had a identity asides Islam. But these migrants if they drop 'Muslim' tag what are you left with. Just Indian. Thus they stress 'Muslim' to differantiate themselves from India by stressing the later as "Hindu".
In a sense a secular migrant 'Muhajir' is a contradiction because he/she negates their reason for being in Pakistan or Pakistani. It is this identity crisis that has been infected onto rest of the majority and where taking pride in your province/ethnic group is seen as a sin. Fact is legally Pakistan is a FEDERATION of five major ethnic/provinces and the name Pakistan reflects that as a acroynm.
P 4 Punjab
A 4 Afghania [NWFP] today Khyber Pakhtun
K 4 Kashmir
S 4 Sind
T -
A -
N - as suffix from Balochis-TAN
View attachment 1290