Live Conflict Ukraine-Russia War

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,361
Reactions
22 12,853
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
The ship's ammunition was detonated accidentally, the crew was evacuated. Possibly means the ship is truly sinking or had already sunk.

The Neptune's must be flying low enough to struck the magazines buried deep inside the hull (blue). Most likely the S-300F magazine in the middle. Another possible option is that it struck the P-1000 Vulkan launcher in both port and starboard but that won't cause any water leak like the Russians reported

800px-Slava_cruiser_armament.svg.png


=======================================================================================================

on the other hand I must cancel or re-work my entire article on Ukraine war because I typed this LOLOLOLOL

Capture.PNG
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,508
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,925
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
The Neptune's must be flying low enough to struck the magazines buried deep inside the hull (blue). Most likely the S-300F magazine in the middle. Another possible option is that it struck the P-1000 Vulkan launcher in both port and starboard but that won't cause any water leak like the Russians reported

800px-Slava_cruiser_armament.svg.png


=======================================================================================================

on the other hand I must cancel or re-work my entire article on Ukraine war because I typed this LOLOLOLOL

View attachment 42508
I think they have had a decent intelligent report on capabilities of the ship beforehand (from US and NATO sources, note TR also keeps an eye on the Black Sea via SIGINT / ELINT instruments and MPAs to search for the mines recently).

2 TB2s in the air have acquired position of the vessel, tracked it, saw the pattern and heading.

Missiles are directed right on the sweet weak spots you have marked, the ship is huge had nothing but merely CIWS to respond. Likely she was cruising in slow speed or still at water. No maneuvarability since the engines were not ready to heat up and provide excess amount of power and the ship is literally huge to conduct such a maneuver.

What is more strange;
She was equipped with S300 missile systens and search radars, wasn't able to detect TB2s
Or, since she lacks an integrated instruments and CMS she couldn't multi-task on detecting & tracking and reacting to the missiles while holding a track on the TB2s and trying to jam or engage on them (which seems like they have failed to do)
But definitely her crew was lacking battle readiness, or readiness in overall.
Now they are trying to collect survivors with tugboats, again Russian Navy as its best.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,508
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,925
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I think they have had a decent intelligent report on capabilities of the ship beforehand (from US and NATO sources, note TR also keeps an eye on the Black Sea via SIGINT / ELINT instruments and MPAs to search for the mines recently).

2 TB2s in the air have acquired position of the vessel, tracked it, saw the pattern and heading.

Missiles are directed right on the sweet weak spots you have marked, the ship is huge had nothing but merely CIWS to respond. Likely she was cruising in slow speed or still at water. No maneuvarability since the engines were not ready to heat up and provide excess amount of power and the ship is literally huge to conduct such a maneuver.

What is more strange;
She was equipped with S300 missile systens and search radars, wasn't able to detect TB2s
Or, since she lacks an integrated instruments and CMS she couldn't multi-task on detecting & tracking and reacting to the missiles while holding a track on the TB2s and trying to jam or engage on them (which seems like they have failed to do)
But definitely her crew was lacking battle readiness, or readiness in overall.
Now they are trying to collect survivors with tugboats, again Russian Navy as its best.
+ Possibly the engagement took place during crew shift rotation. Assuming they should have held a redundant and risk-free rotation between the shifts but we are talking about Russians afterall.
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
541
Reactions
3 476
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
well, when you have 1000 kg warhead missile with only launcher tube protecting it, indonesian only says "lambaikan tangan" when AShM hit the ship.
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,508
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,925
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
1649911260555.png


Meanwhile, the incident took place in a weather making SAR nearly impossible.

Don't be fooled by WW3 wave model that gives small wave height close to the shores (which some sources share in social media), this model is incapable of modelling close to the shore areas, an example of difference between SWAN and WW3 wave models on Black Sea coast of Turkey:
1649911616694.png

1649911513322.png


So don't expect accurate readings from WW3 model for the spot between Romanian coast to Crimean peninsula, that area is possibly doomed.
Any location in northern Black Sea is stormy right now.
 
Last edited:

Ryder

Experienced member
Messages
10,858
Reactions
6 18,708
Nation of residence
Australia
Nation of origin
Turkey
Tb2 was used as a decoy while the neptune missiles striked.

Showing us once again how drones can be used as decoys.

Now a ship got distracted and then blown up by a missile.

Pretty scary how drones can be used this way.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,913
Reactions
4 10,053
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
They already lost a ship bearing the name of their Capital City Moskva, that's morale sinking moment is comparable to the demise of HMS Prince of Wales, Yamato or Bismarck moment.

That's kinda suck when thinking they are loosing this one against a country which had no single warships available and their only Frigate already being scuttled, talking about incompetent and Russian way to screwed up everything.

Then they are talking about to conventionally deter upper rank Naval countries like Japan 🤣🤣
 

Anmdt

Experienced member
Naval Specialist
Professional
Messages
5,508
Solutions
2
Reactions
118 24,925
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
That's kinda suck when thinking they are loosing this one against a country which had no single warships available and their only Frigate already being scuttled, talking about incompetent and Russian way to screwed up everything.
+ Loosing a ship equipped with 6 AK-630 CIWS
1649913027737.png

against;
To a missile quite similar to their own Kh-35 possibly in seeker as well,
To a missile that has not completed its development phase,
To a missile that hasn't been through a serial production phase,
To a missile that was possibly completed via hard efforts in bunkers and not in the factory's production line, after the broke out thus lacking the decent quality inspection.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,913
Reactions
4 10,053
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
+ Loosing a ship equipped with 6 AK-630 CIWS
View attachment 42517
against;
To a missile quite similar to their own Kh-35 possibly in seeker as well,
To a missile that has not completed its development phase,
To a missile that hasn't been through a serial production phase,
To a missile that was possibly completed via hard efforts in bunkers and not in the factory's production line, after the broke out thus lacking the decent quality inspection.

Hope Indonesia keep proceed to acquire Neptune after the war is over this sharing development burden all over again including possible share production as we know Ukraine Defense industry already being pounded to the zero, and Indonesia already in progress to build production line for local Made AShM
 

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Correspondent
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
5,025
Reactions
3 2,871
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
View attachment 42512

Meanwhile, the incident took place in a weather making SAR nearly impossible.

Don't be fooled by WW3 wave model that gives small wave height close to the shores (which some sources share in social media), this model is incapable of modelling close to the shore areas, an example of difference between SWAN and WW3 wave models on Black Sea coast of Turkey:
View attachment 42516
View attachment 42514

So don't expect accurate readings from WW3 model for the spot between Romanian coast to Crimean peninsula, that area is possibly doomed.
Any location in northern Black Sea is stormy right now.
54 from 500 rumored to be saved by the Turkish vessel
 
Last edited:

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,913
Reactions
4 10,053
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
But Comrades we can hit Istanbul now , we srtonk. Looking forward to eat some nice Black Sea fish .

Me remember after some aircraft crashes in Indonesian water, a woman found severed human finger on the fish she bought in the market near the cityport where the aircraft crashes
 

Dmitry

Committed member
Ukraine Correspondent
Messages
239
Reactions
4 841
Nation of residence
Ukraine
Nation of origin
Ukraine
I think they have had a decent intelligent report on capabilities of the ship beforehand (from US and NATO sources, note TR also keeps an eye on the Black Sea via SIGINT / ELINT instruments and MPAs to search for the mines recently).

2 TB2s in the air have acquired position of the vessel, tracked it, saw the pattern and heading.

Missiles are directed right on the sweet weak spots you have marked, the ship is huge had nothing but merely CIWS to respond. Likely she was cruising in slow speed or still at water. No maneuvarability since the engines were not ready to heat up and provide excess amount of power and the ship is literally huge to conduct such a maneuver.

What is more strange;
She was equipped with S300 missile systens and search radars, wasn't able to detect TB2s
Or, since she lacks an integrated instruments and CMS she couldn't multi-task on detecting & tracking and reacting to the missiles while holding a track on the TB2s and trying to jam or engage on them (which seems like they have failed to do)
But definitely her crew was lacking battle readiness, or readiness in overall.
Now they are trying to collect survivors with tugboats, again Russian Navy as its best.

The cruiser "Moskva" was built at a shipyard in the Ukrainian city of Nikolaev, during Soviet times

In Ukrainian literature, in the book "Taras Bulba" there is a famous phrase:
"I gave birth to you and I will kill you."
This was said by the father to the son who betrayed him
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom