Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

RadenSudirman

Well-known member
Messages
341
Reactions
288
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Selama TNI doktrinnya masih merebut wilayah yang dikuasai musuh ya sulit punya doktrin pre emptive strike kaya israel atau singapore, mindset dan strategi TNI yg sepertinya harus di ubah
Kapan Singapore pernah membuktikan "doktrin" mereka? Tidak pernah, maka itu cuma omong kosong, teori tanpa praktek, omdo

Realita di Indonesia itu begini: Rakyatnya saja gak mau ada "preemptive strike".

"Huhu aku gak mau Indonesia "imperialis"
"Aku gak mau "multipolar", maunya unipolar di bawah AS agar negara-negara lain gak kompetisi"
"Kita itu gak perlu kuat, yang penting rakyatnya sejahtera"
"Indonesia aneksasi Timor Timur 100% salah"
"Kita harus kasih Papua hak untuk referendum"
"Anggaran pertahanan dan militer itu tidak berguna, uangnya buat pembangunan saja"

Kalau rakyatnya saja begitu, apa ekspektasimu sama pemerintah eksekutif? Apakah rakyat mau kita ada "preemptive strike"? Kalau kamu tanya saya, maka opini saya sekalian saja gambar strategi untuk skenario intervensi ke seluruh Asia Tenggara, dan bangun kekuatan militer sebesar mungkin. Tapi toh rakyatmu sendiri banyak yang menentang gagasan semacam itu, mau gimana hayo.

Lagipula "preemptive strike" itu perlu musuh yang jelas. Israel musuhnya jelas negara-negara Arab muslim, Singapura potensi musuhnya adalah KITA

Sedangkan bagaimana orang Indonesia melihat dunia luar?

Kalau bilang musuh Indonesia itu Barat, dibilang antek Rusia dan China/ Tankie

Kalau bilang musuh kita China, dibilang PLA itu jauh jauh lebih kuat dari TNI, jadi kita gak akan menang

Jadinya maunya orang Indonesia itu apa?
kamu pikirkan itu dulu sebelum mengagumi sesuatu tanpa memahami konteksnya
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
7,529
Reactions
21 12,098
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
It's kinda alarming the progress the Australia with Aukus lately, first with nuclear submarine and now with tomahawk, we'll be crush in the middle if both parties (China vs Aukus) fight, i guess we should step up our game plan also, is there any plan to own and develop our own long range cruise missile, having missile like khan help but the range was to short,
Do not follow the likes of Iran or NorKo, relying too much on missiles. Like it or not traditional airpower that counts. We're talking about long range strike fighters, VLO jets, AWACS, tankers...
kinzhal will be nice or Kalibr will be better, i am pointing out russian weapons because there's no way we could have tomahawk from the US

I was called 2nd Connie back then when I float the idea that we should start lobbying for J-35 sale. Like it or not, the U.S will never sell us their top of the line weaponry, and certainly not F-35s in the face of Oz and SG objection. So we should find 5th gen jet out there whatever the cost because stealth aircraft is a basic necessity in modern war.

Hell I don't think the U.S would sell us D3 AMRAAM's.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,902
Reactions
4 10,019
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
335931136_692911589296371_2291132157836890417_n.jpg
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,902
Reactions
4 10,019
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Majapahit punya 5 Armada, dan menurutku itu postur yang ideal. 3 Armada: Barat, Tengah, Timur, 1 Armada RI, 1 Armada cadangan (reserve fleet)
Tiga armada aja cukup apalagi kalau isinya sekelas armada ke enam atau ketujuh
 

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Is it realistic though, why is it towed lmao. I just realized that the ammo is in different chasis than the turret
Swedish already made it with UDES XX-20.

No production so far, beside why risking put eggs in one basket? Once it disabled the loss can cost a huge toll.
 

RadenSudirman

Well-known member
Messages
341
Reactions
288
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Tiga armada aja cukup apalagi kalau isinya sekelas armada ke enam atau ketujuh
I think we should have what the Japanese had during WW2, Kido Butai AKA Elite Carrier Strike Group. They had 4 Carriers, and in the Battle of Midway, went up against 3 American carriers (which is also under one command).

Koarmada RI AKA the "Kostrad of TNI AL", shall be designed in that manner, with 2 Carriers, KRI Majapahit and KRI Sriwijaya. Other regular 3 Fleets hold certain territory, but Armada RI can be committed at will and has the most firepower.
 

Madokafc

Experienced member
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
5,902
Reactions
4 10,019
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
I think we should have what the Japanese had during WW2, Kido Butai AKA Elite Carrier Strike Group. They had 4 Carriers, and in the Battle of Midway, went up against 3 American carriers (which is also under one command).

Koarmada RI AKA the "Kostrad of TNI AL", shall be designed in that manner, with 2 Carriers, KRI Majapahit and KRI Sriwijaya. Other regular 3 Fleets hold certain territory, but Armada RI can be committed at will and has the most firepower.

This is where Aircraft carrier is the utmost important element ever
Sekelas Marina Militare cukuplah

Ya kurang lah, Indonesia negara kepulauan terbesar di dunia, tetangganya di laut gahar gahar, Italia negara di tengah Mediterania ....
 

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,506
Reactions
1 2,452
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Ya kurang lah, Indonesia negara kepulauan terbesar di dunia, tetangganya di laut gahar gahar, Italia negara di tengah Mediterania ....
gimana kalau sekelas JMSDF, 1/2 aja dulu kali ya buat 10 tahun kedepan.

BTW kalau FREMM jadi 6 biji + 2 Maestrale, kelas Ahmad Yani masih bakalan dipensiunkan kah?
 
Last edited:

Van Kravchenko

Contributor
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
1,285
Reactions
2 872
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
reminds me more of a churchill with flamethrower trailer hehe

ww2-britain-churchill-crocodile-tank-scaled-2048x1052.jpg
It works, but deemed impractical.
Tanks has gone many history of design from turetless to multi turreted tank. today MBTs were the peak of it's development
 

NEKO

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
2,839
Reactions
3 2,375
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
It works, but deemed impractical.
Tanks has gone many history of design from turetless to multi turreted tank. today MBTs were the peak of it's development
Current MBT still can be improved further by improving its SUK.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom