India AMCA Program

[Spitfire9]

A second source said that EOI states that all key managerial positions including but not limited to CEO, CFO, COO and the entire Board of Directors shall be held by individuals who are resident Indian citizens. This means, the source added, that no private company can actually hire a foreign talent at the top to spearhead the venture.

The sources also pointed out that annual turn-over of the single/lead company shall have minimum Rs 2,000 crore in the last three financial years (FYs). Also, the non-lead partner should have a minimum annual turnover of Rs 200 crore for the last three FYs.

The only company which fits this criteria is HAL, they said.

Ahead of crucial AMCA meet, private companies flag heavy tilt in HAL’s favour

EOI was marked a historic shift in defence procurement & industrial participation policy since this meant that HAL will have to bid along with private firms to bag the contract.

theprint.in

I would say that the current Tejas programmes are in the state they are in partly because of less than dynamic leadership from the government down. Excluding talent is not a good idea. Carrying on with the same company that performed so badly with Tejas is not a good idea. The brief seems to be written to ensure that the people institutionalised to accept failure with no sanction will be the people who will be running the show.

 

[Nilgiri]

Hmm but would that not be unfair to all the private giants that worked on this project?
After all they could use this as marketing to manufacture stuff for other large defence industries as well.

Common worldwide.

I mean no matter what Boeing, Northrop, Raytheon, L3, Pratt etc provide to F-35........ its still the LM F-35 as LM is the final assembler, past the design and development they did.

 

[sup_lol]

Common worldwide.

I mean no matter what Boeing, Northrop, Raytheon, L3, Pratt etc provide to F-35........ its still the LM F-35 as LM is the final assembler, past the design and development they did.

well the issue is that, India is trying to bring up its private defence industry while boeing, Northop, Raytheon etc are well established giants.

Eh idk tbh, we'll see.

 

[sup_lol]

Ahead of crucial AMCA meet, private companies flag heavy tilt in HAL’s favour

EOI was marked a historic shift in defence procurement & industrial participation policy since this meant that HAL will have to bid along with private firms to bag the contract.

theprint.in

I would say that the current Tejas programmes are in the state they are in partly because of less than dynamic leadership from the government down. Excluding talent is not a good idea. Carrying on with the same company that performed so badly with Tejas is not a good idea. The brief seems to be written to ensure that the people institutionalised to accept failure with no sanction will be the people who will be running the show.

If the whole thing is yet again given to HAL i would give up and the thing is only gonna come out by 2040 at the earliest by which time the whole damn world would have moved on the 6th Gen. The only saving grace is that its gonna be designed to be close to 6th gen with MUMT and a lot of other stuff but DEWs or anything of that sort is out of the question because its a medium weight fighter with not even close to enough power.