Indonesia Indonesian Army,Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Darat (TNI-AD)

[chibiyabi]

If the same configuration that common in Russia, a disgrace and laughing stock. The publicity is bad recent time, known to turned its crews to accidental cosmonauts.

not just T72, even the mighty T90 all variants became jokes when facing modern ATGM

 

[chibiyabi]

Are we in a dire need of MBT? Are we facing a serious threats against MBT?

I think that any potential enemy armored vehicles mostly will be consisted of lighter armored one, and MBT will be in a small number.

as i said in another thread, MBT, medium Tank, IFV its all complementary. you should look at latest army Brigade Combat Team excercise in Baturaja

 

[Van Kravchenko]

K2

Hyundai Rotem :

 

[schuimpjes]

My favorite is that one video captured by Chinese tv station. 10/10 glorious.

Oh yes. Angry birds moment

 

[schuimpjes]

T90

They just changed the number

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Are we facing a serious threats against MBT?

we aren't in Kharkov or Gulf warfare anymore, and please forgot the tank to tank battle.

even recent conflict today tank to tank battle is little to none, the main function of MBT is to breakthrough enemy defense accompany by mobile infantry, again MOBILE INFANTRY. this stuff already here for ages, but no one bats an eye.

Tank-Infantry Teamwork: Combat Lessons, No. 9 (Lone Sentry)

why such Russia failed to gain big territory from Ukraine it just because they didn't learn from German what is Blizkrieg Is.

but, as you can see while ID Army train with Leopard they also Spam Infantry to protect tanks (I think its since Infantry are less expensive than the tank wkwk) while I personally love this, but the infantry still lacks of firepower such as Anti Tank weapon.

anyway, good luck with that T-72 and their line. even secon hand Dutch Leo2 didn't bats an eye of ID Army since they're in worst condition.

for me, its best to take more Leo2 or just all out to K2 or perhaps more religious K2 by Turk.

 

[Van Kravchenko]

not just T72, even the mighty T90 all variants became jokes when facing modern ATGM

If this tank existed, say good bye to all soviet armor.

yeah, a Brrrtt, but in land, and marching towards you

 

[Umigami]

more religious K2 by Turk

 

[Jagdflieger]

we aren't in Kharkov or Gulf warfare anymore, and please forgot the tank to tank battle.

even recent conflict today tank to tank battle is little to none, the main function of MBT is to breakthrough enemy defense accompany by mobile infantry, again MOBILE INFANTRY. this stuff already here for ages, but no one bats an eye.

Tank-Infantry Teamwork: Combat Lessons, No. 9 (Lone Sentry)

why such Russia failed to gain big territory from Ukraine it just because they didn't learn from German what is Blizkrieg Is.

but, as you can see while ID Army train with Leopard they also Spam Infantry to protect tanks (I think its since Infantry are less expensive than the tank wkwk) while I personally love this, but the infantry still lacks of firepower such as Anti Tank weapon.

anyway, good luck with that T-72 and their line. even secon hand Dutch Leo2 didn't bats an eye of ID Army since they're in worst condition.

for me, its best to take more Leo2 or just all out to K2 or perhaps more religious K2 by Turk.

You forgot about air support - no air support (respectively air-superiority) NO Blitzkrieg. This is actually Russia's present problem and has been since the 70's.

 

[Van Kravchenko]

You forgot about air support - no air support (respectively air-superiority) NO Blitzkrieg

ahh, I forgot this, that Stukas with their bombs and freckin 37mm cannon are scary hell to disable tanks and to keep adversaries duck down. today we can have it in air cavalry mode.

This is actually Russia's present problem and has been since the 70's.

I think they misplace the aircraft and missile intended to do wild weasel mission.

 

[NEKO]

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.​

Press Release, Paris, 14 June 2022: During Eurosatory exhibition in Paris, PT Pindad and Nexter agreed to cooperate for the supply of latest generation 120mm tank ammunition for the Indonesian Army. The agreement sealed between the two companies will permit to offer a complete range of 120mm tank ammunition, including SHARD APFSDS, High Explosive and training rounds. Nexter is a recognized as a leading company for the design and production of 120mm tank ammunition compatible with all Main Battle Tank equipped with NATO 120mm smooth bore guns. The agreement foresees also a strong local manufacturing, strengthening the Indonesian industry capabilities. The signature was witnessed by the Indonesian Ministry of Defence and French DGA.

“PT Pindad, an Indonesian national defence industry, is working on completing portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunition, not only the small calibre ammunition that already existing since 1980s. PT Pindad is willing to have a strategic partnership with Nexter as a global known company with high quality products and that has a complete portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunitions that meet with the needs of the Indonesian Armed Forces”, said Abraham Mose, CEO of PT Pindad.

Following the signature of this Letter of Intent, the Executive Vice President Weapon and Ammunition Dominique Guillet declared: “As a European leader in medium and large ammunition, Nexter is committed to establish long-term partnerships with the Indonesian industry to enhance Indonesia’s local high-tech industrial content. Our cooperation with Indonesia’s largest land defence systems company PT PINDAD for the complete range of 120mm ammunition is a perfect illustration of this ambition and we proud of this new success.”

This new step is following the signature of a memorandum of understanding in Indonesia in last February in presence of French and Indonesian Ministries of Defence pertaining to their cooperation on various types of medium and large calibre ammunitions.

PT Pindad and Nexter Ammunition Cooperation | Joint Forces News

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.

www.joint-forces.com

 

[Umigami]

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.​

Press Release, Paris, 14 June 2022: During Eurosatory exhibition in Paris, PT Pindad and Nexter agreed to cooperate for the supply of latest generation 120mm tank ammunition for the Indonesian Army. The agreement sealed between the two companies will permit to offer a complete range of 120mm tank ammunition, including SHARD APFSDS, High Explosive and training rounds. Nexter is a recognized as a leading company for the design and production of 120mm tank ammunition compatible with all Main Battle Tank equipped with NATO 120mm smooth bore guns. The agreement foresees also a strong local manufacturing, strengthening the Indonesian industry capabilities. The signature was witnessed by the Indonesian Ministry of Defence and French DGA.

“PT Pindad, an Indonesian national defence industry, is working on completing portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunition, not only the small calibre ammunition that already existing since 1980s. PT Pindad is willing to have a strategic partnership with Nexter as a global known company with high quality products and that has a complete portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunitions that meet with the needs of the Indonesian Armed Forces”, said Abraham Mose, CEO of PT Pindad.

Following the signature of this Letter of Intent, the Executive Vice President Weapon and Ammunition Dominique Guillet declared: “As a European leader in medium and large ammunition, Nexter is committed to establish long-term partnerships with the Indonesian industry to enhance Indonesia’s local high-tech industrial content. Our cooperation with Indonesia’s largest land defence systems company PT PINDAD for the complete range of 120mm ammunition is a perfect illustration of this ambition and we proud of this new success.”

This new step is following the signature of a memorandum of understanding in Indonesia in last February in presence of French and Indonesian Ministries of Defence pertaining to their cooperation on various types of medium and large calibre ammunitions.

PT Pindad and Nexter Ammunition Cooperation | Joint Forces News

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.

www.joint-forces.com

For now let's forget about acquiring Panther.

 

[Umigami]

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.​

Press Release, Paris, 14 June 2022: During Eurosatory exhibition in Paris, PT Pindad and Nexter agreed to cooperate for the supply of latest generation 120mm tank ammunition for the Indonesian Army. The agreement sealed between the two companies will permit to offer a complete range of 120mm tank ammunition, including SHARD APFSDS, High Explosive and training rounds. Nexter is a recognized as a leading company for the design and production of 120mm tank ammunition compatible with all Main Battle Tank equipped with NATO 120mm smooth bore guns. The agreement foresees also a strong local manufacturing, strengthening the Indonesian industry capabilities. The signature was witnessed by the Indonesian Ministry of Defence and French DGA.

“PT Pindad, an Indonesian national defence industry, is working on completing portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunition, not only the small calibre ammunition that already existing since 1980s. PT Pindad is willing to have a strategic partnership with Nexter as a global known company with high quality products and that has a complete portfolio of medium to large calibre ammunitions that meet with the needs of the Indonesian Armed Forces”, said Abraham Mose, CEO of PT Pindad.

Following the signature of this Letter of Intent, the Executive Vice President Weapon and Ammunition Dominique Guillet declared: “As a European leader in medium and large ammunition, Nexter is committed to establish long-term partnerships with the Indonesian industry to enhance Indonesia’s local high-tech industrial content. Our cooperation with Indonesia’s largest land defence systems company PT PINDAD for the complete range of 120mm ammunition is a perfect illustration of this ambition and we proud of this new success.”

This new step is following the signature of a memorandum of understanding in Indonesia in last February in presence of French and Indonesian Ministries of Defence pertaining to their cooperation on various types of medium and large calibre ammunitions.

PT Pindad and Nexter Ammunition Cooperation | Joint Forces News

PT Pindad and Nexter are to cooperate for the supply of the latest generation 120mm tank ammunition to the Indonesian Army.

www.joint-forces.com

I just realized, why not 105 mm HP too?
Maybe because Harimau population isn't that many yet.

 

[Umigami]

Nexter SHARD round

Nexter 120 mm SHARD: towards tailored APFSDS solutions - EDR Magazine

By Paolo Valpolini When main battle tanks (MBTs) armour was made of rolled homogeneous armour (RHA) comparing armour piercing (AP)

www.edrmagazine.eu

 

[FPXAllen]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1537067067362316288

Without knowing the full extent of that 'leak', while I do see the the purpose of having at least one MBT division in each Indonesian major islands, it's hard to really understand why we should acquire MBTs from another country.

Chance for another rounds of 'shopping', perhaps? /s

While we're at it, how about prioritizing to expand Pindad's production facility and finalize a contract to acquire a large number of Harimau so they can make more of it in the shortest amount of time instead? I think a 4:1 ratio of modern medium tank to MBT will be ideal for us.

 

[FPXAllen]

If this tank existed, say good bye to all soviet armor.

View attachment 44948

yeah, a Brrrtt, but in land, and marching towards you

Umm, an AP round from that gun may be able to penetrate the top part of most of today's MBTs if it fired from the air but it won't achieve the same success from the ground level. Of course it still can cause considerable damage, but if it's truly that effective when mounted on a tank chassis, it will already been mass-produced.

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Umm, an AP round from that gun may be able to penetrate the top part of most of today's MBTs if it fired from the air but it won't achieve the same success from the ground level. Of course it still can cause considerable damage, but if it's truly that effective when mounted on a tank chassis, it will already been mass-produced.

well, its once started as a Air Defence, but rendered obsolete by the massive development by Ground to Air Missile.

if you put an AP into that stuff, even the T90 will suffer enough damage to make it unable to move.

 

[NEKO]

Without knowing the full extent of that 'leak', while I do see the the purpose of having at least one MBT division in each Indonesian major islands, it's hard to really understand why we should acquire MBTs from another country.

Chance for another rounds of 'shopping', perhaps? /s

While we're at it, how about prioritizing to expand Pindad's production facility and finalize a contract to acquire a large number of Harimau so they can make more of it in the shortest amount of time instead? I think a 4:1 ratio of modern medium tank to MBT will be ideal for us.

I also think that MT should become priority, unless there is some cuci gudang for seken MBT, cheap but still good.

If there is some unused budget we can use it to get SPH, MLRS, attack helicopter.

 

[FPXAllen]

cuci gudang for seken MBT

Depends on what MBTs that are being 'cuci gudang-ed' of course.

For example, in case the Russian offered us some of their T-90s, even without the ongoing Russo-Ukraine conflict I still don't think that it will be a good choice.

However, given the current situation in the West, and that Western European countries are starting to ramp up their militaries, there won't be much chance for another Leo 2 garage sale if ever.

 

[Lordimperator]

I just realized, why not 105 mm HP too?
Maybe because Harimau population isn't that many yet.

Nah, from Pindad news

PT. Pindad (Persero) - Pindad Tandatangani MoU Terkait Munisi Dengan Nexter Group

pindad.com