Indonesia Navy Indonesian Navy, Tentara Nasional Indonesia-Angkatan Laut (TNI-AL)

[Agent_G]

Maintenance routine of Indonesia Navy Submarine at PT PAL facilities, picture taken at 30 November 2020 credit to lembaga keris

View attachment 7633 View attachment 7634 View attachment 7635

maybe the submarine wants to be installed Torpedo Decoy

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Why our sub so frequently get on the dock? And get dirty so easily?

I dont know what exactly happened, but its seem to be trying as long as possible underwater.

Look at its rust, its almost cover up entire hull.


Hopefully, im glad to see our top brass realize as soon as possible to make Natuna island a fortification.
Yet, its only naval, air, and land based base that capable to lauch preemptive strike in case of total war. But again ist still need tons of "gorengan" to be strong enough.


Anyway, still no clue what AH said at his tweet.
Surely its not a subs, we still have active contract with korean.
Or even Fighter, thats will need tons of lobby.
Or even surface combatant, i didnt notice that france put hard effot to push it onto us recently.


Or AH just loafing about small yet tactical alutsista one.

 

[trishna_amrta]

What does he mean by bakamla only?
Navy?

Meaning when it's come to law enforcement on the high sea it's within BAKAMLA turf. With TNI-AL focusing more on high intensity conflict. But that doesn't mean BAKAMLA can't ask TNI-AL unit for assistance either when the situation become more intense and beyond the capability of BAKAMLA unit.

View attachment 7625
Pengennya ada kepastian soal ini

"Kepastian" is an abstract concept. Even after "janur kuning melengkung" there isn't any kepastian. Only after the graveyard stone (batu nisan) has been cast there is a kepastian.

Anyway so far there is only Naval Group coming to MoD right? There isn't any from either ThyssenKrupp or SAAB

Why our sub so frequently get on the dock? And get dirty so easily?

That is good. Meaning the sub had spent more time underwater (which is good for crew training). Also keep in mind the nature of tropical water is different from that of temperate water (generally, less salinity with far more diverse microorganism)

 

[Gundala]

Why our sub so frequently get on the dock? And get dirty so easily

The right question is which one of our registered Submarine doing that maintenance? I wish I could see the numbers hehehe

Anyway so far there is only Naval Group coming to MoD right? There isn't any from either ThyssenKrupp or SAAB

Thyssen will come with Turkey I think. Sad to see SAAB didnt make the cut, I like their submarine

 

[R4duga]

The right question is which one of our registered Submarine doing that maintenance? I wish I could see the numbers hehehe


Thyssen will come with Turkey I think. Sad to see SAAB didnt make the cut, I like their submarine

thyssen consultant already come here aren't they ? if i remember they are the one who pointed out one of the flaw in jangbogo, and directly send letter of consult to mr.president itself .

https://fnn.co.id/2020/02/04/kapal-selam-korsel-1-surat-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi/

Kapal Selam Korsel (2): Franklin Paham Kemampuan Galangan Kapal Daewoo

Oleh Mochamad Toha Jakarta, FNN - Setelah penandatangan kontrak untuk kapal selam lagi, permasalahan pun muncul. Apakah pengadaan, pembelian, dan

fnn.co.id

pic source : https://www.pepnews.com/politik/p-f...t-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi

the 214 use PEM Fuel Cell for the AIP module , which have almost non existent moving parts other than small pumps , which contribute to "quietness" of the submarine , and they operates at 80 degree celcius which can contribute to reducing heat signature from submarine .

on the other hand , the french AIP use MESMA , which having a considerable amount of moving parts , may contribute to radiate detectable noise from submarine , and they operated at 700 degree celcius temperature (due to ethanol based fuel) .

beside above , PEM fuel cell have higher efficiency compared to French mesma 50-70% vs 30% , but french mesma had higher power output ...... , quite though choice for our MoD indeed

 

[Umigami]

thyssen consultant already come here aren't they ? if i remember they are the one who pointed out one of the flaw in jangbogo, and directly send letter of consult to mr.president itself .

https://fnn.co.id/2020/02/04/kapal-selam-korsel-1-surat-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi/

Kapal Selam Korsel (2): Franklin Paham Kemampuan Galangan Kapal Daewoo

Oleh Mochamad Toha Jakarta, FNN - Setelah penandatangan kontrak untuk kapal selam lagi, permasalahan pun muncul. Apakah pengadaan, pembelian, dan

fnn.co.id

View attachment 7647
pic source : https://www.pepnews.com/politik/p-f...t-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi

the 214 use PEM Fuel Cell for the AIP module , which have almost non existent moving parts other than small pumps , which contribute to "quietness" of the submarine , and they operates at 80 degree celcius which can contribute to reducing heat signature from submarine .

on the other hand , the french AIP use MESMA , which having a considerable amount of moving parts , may contribute to radiate detectable noise from submarine , and they operated at 700 degree celcius temperature (due to ethanol based fuel) .

beside above , PEM fuel cell have higher efficiency compared to French mesma 50-70% vs 30% , but french mesma had higher power output ...... , quite though choice for our MoD indeed

View attachment 7648

I don't think it has that much moving part.
In a warm water like Indonesia and South China Sea, is heat signature gonna be that "mencolok" ?

TKMS-Golcuk offer would be much more interesting if there was some Pencil on it.

 

[Anmdt]

thyssen consultant already come here aren't they ? if i remember they are the one who pointed out one of the flaw in jangbogo, and directly send letter of consult to mr.president itself .

https://fnn.co.id/2020/02/04/kapal-selam-korsel-1-surat-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi/

Kapal Selam Korsel (2): Franklin Paham Kemampuan Galangan Kapal Daewoo

Oleh Mochamad Toha Jakarta, FNN - Setelah penandatangan kontrak untuk kapal selam lagi, permasalahan pun muncul. Apakah pengadaan, pembelian, dan

fnn.co.id

View attachment 7647
pic source : https://www.pepnews.com/politik/p-f...t-konsultan-kapal-selam-untuk-presiden-jokowi

the 214 use PEM Fuel Cell for the AIP module , which have almost non existent moving parts other than small pumps , which contribute to "quietness" of the submarine , and they operates at 80 degree celcius which can contribute to reducing heat signature from submarine .

on the other hand , the french AIP use MESMA , which having a considerable amount of moving parts , may contribute to radiate detectable noise from submarine , and they operated at 700 degree celcius temperature (due to ethanol based fuel) .

beside above , PEM fuel cell have higher efficiency compared to French mesma 50-70% vs 30% , but french mesma had higher power output ...... , quite though choice for our MoD indeed

View attachment 7648

Should it be an AIP?
Japanese latest Soryu with new batteries offers as good as submerged range and endurance as the AIP. Easier to maintain and replace at any dock, while with AIP there will be a huge dependency on the supplier in maintenance and spare parts, also where it would be overhauled.
Besides capability and how good it sounds, operation-ability and maintenance should be considered here. You wouldn't be pleased when the submarine is bound to return to all the way back to surabaya once it is time for an AIP overhaul, assuming MRO abilitiy is gained recently one can not also assume capable facilities to be established soon in remote areas/bases yet alone the AIP maintenance capability.

I am aware Soryu class is a lot bigger, yet it is not obstacle what i refer to here is the tech,not submarine itself alone.

 

[Anmdt]

I don't think it has that much moving part.
In a warm water like Indonesia and South China Sea, is heat signature gonna be that "mencolok" ?

TKMS-Golcuk offer would be much more interesting if there was some Pencil on it.

I think Turkey has made the offer already (with TN version), and your officials wasn't much interested.

 

[Umigami]

Should it be an AIP?
Japanese latest Soryu with new batteries offers as good as submerged range and endurance as the AIP. Easier to maintain and replace at any dock, while with AIP there will be a huge dependency on the supplier in maintenance and spare parts, also where it would be overhauled.
Besides capability and how good it sounds, operation-ability and maintenance should be considered here. You wouldn't be pleased when the submarine is bound to return to all the way back to surabaya once it is time for an AIP overhaul, assuming MRO abilitiy is gained recently one can not also assume capable facilities to be established soon in remote areas/bases yet alone the AIP maintenance capability.

For me, the biggest Cons of Soryu are it's pretty huge, I don't think it'll suitable for our shallow sea. Second, It need a lot of sailor to man it (compared to 214 and Scorpene)
Can we request smaller soryu with better automation to japan?

 

[Anmdt]

For me, the biggest Cons of Soryu are it's pretty huge, I don't think it'll suitable for our shallow sea. Second, It need a lot of sailor to man it (compared to 214 and Scorpene)
Can we request smaller soryu with better automation to japan?

It is not about automation, it carries more fuel, more range-snorkelled or submerged, more torpedos in storage. Number of submarines can be reduced and missions which will be tasked for AIP submarines can be given to soryu.
Type 214 is 6 meters, Soryu is 8 meters in depth, none of them are good for "shallow waters" they can not approach bottom that much.

 

[trishna_amrta]

I don't think it has that much moving part.
In a warm water like Indonesia and South China Sea, is heat signature gonna be that "mencolok" ?

TKMS-Golcuk offer would be much more interesting if there was some Pencil on it.

Thermal signature only became issue when the sub at PD and the observer is flying overhead., but then again in that situation a simple Mk.1 Eyeball is enough to detect the sub. Keep in mind submarine operate underwater (in seawater) not on some open air surface, so thermal signature is generally non issue.

 

[R4duga]

Thermal signature only became issue when the sub at PD and the observer is flying overhead., but then again in that situation a simple Mk.1 Eyeball is enough to detect the sub. Keep in mind submarine operate underwater (in seawater) not on some open air surface, so thermal signature is generally non issue.

then it comes to the 2nd parameter , acoustic issue .

 

[Madokafc]

For me, the biggest Cons of Soryu are it's pretty huge, I don't think it'll suitable for our shallow sea. Second, It need a lot of sailor to man it (compared to 214 and Scorpene)
Can we request smaller soryu with better automation to japan?

Those who say Indonesian water is shallow quite uninformed, the average depth of Java sea the most shallow ones in Indonesia is around 46 meter deep, Natuna sea is more than that, Arafura is in thousand, so with Palu and Celebes sea, Malacca strait is in twenty meter deep.

 

[trishna_amrta]

Those who say Indonesian water is shallow quite uninformed, the average depth of Java sea the most shallow ones in Indonesia is around 46 meter deep, Natuna sea is more than that, Arafura is in thousand, so with Palu and Celebes sea, Malacca strait is in twenty meter deep.

Java Sea average depth is merely 150' Natuna Sea merely slightly deeper but only at certain spots, even that not by any significant margin. Also, everything from the western side of Malacca Strait to the eastern end of Java Sea, northward to the entire South China Sea are newly made seas. What today's are seas in the region was a lush tropical jungle not so long ago (in geological timeframe). Not to mention warm enough to the point I felt cooler on the boat than underwater even in place with deep trench such as Lombok Strait I never have any thermometer when going under, but I do have my skin telling me the difference of temperature

 

[Umigami]

Java Sea average depth is merely 150' Natuna Sea merely slightly deeper but only at certain spots, even that not by any significant margin. Also, everything from the western side of Malacca Strait to the eastern end of Java Sea, northward to the entire South China Sea are newly made seas. What today's are seas in the region was a lush tropical jungle not so long ago (in geological timeframe). Not to mention warm enough to the point I felt cooler on the boat than underwater even in place with deep trench such as Lombok Strait I never have any thermometer when going under, but I do have my skin telling me the difference of temperature

So our 209 and dsme 1400 are good enough?

 

[trishna_amrta]

So our 209 and dsme 1400 are good enough?

"Good enough" mostly depend on combat system weapon system, crew training & proficiency, and most importantly, logistic & maintenance support.

 

[Umigami]

Tenggelam Tak Ada Kabar, Kapal Selam Buatan RI Gagal Dikirim?

Jelang tutup tahun, kabar kapal selam Alugoro yang diproduksi di PT PAL Indonesia, Surabaya, belum juga ada kabar perkembangannya.

www.cnbcindonesia.com

 

[Djketoprak]

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1334108447084748800

Does Anyone know what happen with our new submarine?? Decoy installment or our sub get "kebakaran"??

Sorry for my english

 

[Ravager]

I don't know about you guys but

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1334108447084748800

Does Anyone know what happen with our new submarine?? Decoy installment or our sub get "kebakaran"??

Sorry for my english

This is the very question that if you ever slightly make a misshap in answering would invite a plenty of new tukang gorengan , tahu bulat , bakso and Ojol " camped " around your neighbourhood ..

So , sorry bruh ... I think i will pass this one .

 

[Van Kravchenko]

Does Anyone know what happen with our new submarine?? Decoy installment or our sub get "kebakaran"??

Two subs are in queue, the 405 seems got some problemo.
Cant guarantee if its a fire or not.

Judging from its condition, the 405 are undergoing recoating process, and the fire are caught up at 2 point.
Anyway, from 5 subs, only 1 that still meronda.

Yes we have issue with budget cut from the latest submarine contact.
Even "karya anak bangsa" still didnt pass series of test.

Imho, the original 209 still better than 209 KW2.

Better the MOD get us some serious stuff.