Joining QUAD, change it to PENTAInstant way, asked US and Japan for us to get their defense umbrella.
Latest Thread
Joining QUAD, change it to PENTAInstant way, asked US and Japan for us to get their defense umbrella.
I see that too far really wkwk. You know how US Forces can struck target in Pakistan that based on Title 10 they are only legal to doing military operation in wartime, that you must know Pakistan is not the place that de jure US was at war? The solution was their hunter killer drones and personnels were BKOed to CIA with its freer Title 50 that can doing operation anywhere anytime except inside US territory.Joining QUAD, change it to PENTA
Well, yes he is too scatterbrained for anything, attempted to study everything but missed more than half the points. Yeah, he's not good at focusing on one thing and drawing a conclusion.That loud Komodo wkwk…. No. He still too afraid to take conclusion why our ancestors from molecular biology and Adam and Eve stories are different, or he is too conservative to me.
Hadits that human was so high before and getting shorter gradually also not fit with science at all wkwk. He must think about that also, so he can be more freely to speak his view and not snared by his belief
I think with this case, we know what China is thinking right now: island chains strategy is fragile, these "allied" countries can't always be politically influenced to stay in the US camp and their alignment can sway either way at any moment. So China will push more attempt at ruining the island chain strategy politically, and I suppose will take form through economic influence. Americans are gigit jari right now, frustrated with China's investment strategy which they cannot hope to copy.Joining QUAD, change it to PENTA
Yup, faith is subjective, but this stuff can also affecting the trajectory where certain country going into, so the destruction can be collective to the whole country, and i think it’s not worth it at all to die for certain people belief or religion that as you said, subjective. It is normal for other people to not believe the same so called ‘reality’ as what you believe, even secular religion is more real than belief of certain cult teaching for me.people generally cannot differentiate between faith (subjective reality) and objective reality.
Ya, people can make it fit, even Animism or Hindu that older than Abrahamic religions are still can be made fit. I don’t know, but i think younger generation especially that are relatively more exposed to more views than its older generations are find more defects in ‘it’, that might be Hiloni–like generation are the next thing happen here.Even in the modern world, faith and religion, I think, are perfectly compatible.
We need dedicated anti tank battalions reallyAndhika Perkasa
Get those CG !
Andhika Perkasa
Get those CG !
Ada opini lain soal T-90 yang disinyalir berhasil dijebol dengan Carl Gustav.But here we are, even tankies admitted that Carl Gustav destroyed a "T90"
It’s so inflexible to destroy tanks the commander have to move battalion wkwk or maybe the personnels are shared to the squad or ODA?We need dedicated anti tank battalions really
A battalion is not that big in terms of relative size, just a few hundred men. I don't think assigning a specific task to a battalion makes them inflexible, quite the contrary IMO.It’s so inflexible to destroy tanks the commander have to move battalion wkwk or maybe the personnels are shared to the squad or ODA?
Better give AT recoilless rifle to each platoon, expensive platoon that people can be proud of, and the morale getting higher because they have more firepower. It just empty words wkwk many personnels are can’t even aim through the iron sight (forget optical sight) at the condition of peteng dedet (gelap gulita).
sekarang ini konsep dedicated battalion makin di tinggalkan, karena bakal memperpanjang rantai komando, TNI AD sudah mulai merubah doktrin pertempurannya dengan bikin yon komposit, sudah ada yon cakra. dalam pergelarannya yon komposit ini digabung menjadi setingkat brigade tim pertempuran. penyempurnaan dari doktrin yg dimiliki oleh marinir. jadi dengan yon komposit sebenarnya sudah punya kemampuan AT, yg belum itu ya perkuatan unit infanteri, belum punya fire power yg memadai, makanya RPG terus CG banyak diinginkan diakuisisi AD. Sejak dahulu infanteri marinir udah punya kekeuatan daya tembak yg lebih dengan RPGnya, dan jelas keliatan waktu operasi di Aceh dulu, gerak marinir lebih cair karena ga perlu nunggu tembakan bantuan.A battalion is not that big in terms of relative size, just a few hundred men. I don't think assigning a specific task to a battalion makes them inflexible, quite the contrary IMO.
Of course, we can try giving all rifle units in the Army some form of AT weapon or have a dedicated AT platoon in every battalion. But can we tho? That will be an enormous requirement of AT equipment vs actual procurement capability. Added on top of that is the balance between having the right amount of firepower when we need it vs what units will get them.
A Platoon is way too small, just some dozens of men, and not all of them will be given AT nor are supposed to operate AT weapons. A platoon is also generally cannot sustain itself, a battalion can, and having a battalion perform this task is important due to the complexity of AT weapons and AT task itself and the AT firepower required at a time to effectively defeat an armored column (which will also operate at battalion level).
Concentrated firepower > Dispersed firepower. Why did the Germans make Tank Divisions? concentrating their tanks instead of dispersing them the way the French did? Because it is simply better to concentrate than to disperse your forces when waging (and winning) a battle.
Hell no wkwk it's like moving the whole Indobatt in Naqoura (UNIFIL) wkwk imagine thatA battalion is not that big in terms of relative size, just a few hundred men.
I know how a few hundred men look like, combined with all their equipment and vehicles, that's just one small stadium in size or so, I've seen a queue bigger than that. Honestly, a battalion is big? Name me a major military operation conducted with less than a battalion in size. Even a brigade is considered the lowest level of unit capable of independent command. Compared to the scale of war for most of history, a battalion is almost nothing, and that even includes medieval warfare.Hell no wkwk it's like moving the whole Indobatt in Naqoura (UNIFIL) wkwk imagine that
Benar, tapi konteksnya disini adalah skenario vs armored column melawan peer enemy, bukan melawan insurgent level threat. Jadi keperluan untuk firepower sudah sangat berbeda lagi, apalagi jika AT yang dimaksud adalah yang tipe berat, tidak bisa digunakan perorangan tapi penting jika lawannya adalah unit kavaleri berat.sekarang ini konsep dedicated battalion makin di tinggalkan, karena bakal memperpanjang rantai komando, TNI AD sudah mulai merubah doktrin pertempurannya dengan bikin yon komposit, sudah ada yon cakra. dalam pergelarannya yon komposit ini digabung menjadi setingkat brigade tim pertempuran. penyempurnaan dari doktrin yg dimiliki oleh marinir. jadi dengan yon komposit sebenarnya sudah punya kemampuan AT, yg belum itu ya perkuatan unit infanteri, belum punya fire power yg memadai, makanya RPG terus CG banyak diinginkan diakuisisi AD. Sejak dahulu infanteri marinir udah punya kekeuatan daya tembak yg lebih dengan RPGnya, dan jelas keliatan waktu operasi di Aceh dulu, gerak marinir lebih cair karena ga perlu nunggu tembakan bantuan.
But imagine that whole battalion is a dedicated AT battalion. Good to @chibiyabi he said right now the Army just started composite battalion and cakra battalion. I still can take if the AT battalion put their platoon to other battalion, but isn't that just make the coordination more complicated rather than just one battalion commander has lot of capabilities.I know how a few hundred men look like, combined with all their equipment and vehicles, that's just one small stadium in size or so, I've seen a queue bigger than that. Honestly, a battalion is big? Name me a major military operation conducted with less than a battalion in size. Even a brigade is considered the lowest level of unit capable of independent command. Compared to the scale of war for most of history, a battalion is almost nothing, and that even includes medieval warfare.
The military is not about parades, hanging out at koramil, handling traffic, or committing token security force (the art of just showing up), which may only demand less than 100 guys or so, but no, this is considering a real combat situation. Even then, the AT battalion idea is generous (and cheap) enough, not even talking about regiment or even division level capability.
We have hundreds of thousands of soldiers, and in wartime will require more, but moving like 600 guys to perform one tactical task is heavy?
Firepower is the issue. I mean the idea of a composite force originated during the time of Napoleon when the Corps acted as a mini-army with so-called composite capability/ combined arms. The point is that each Corps unit can be flexible and able to act independently, hence increasing maneuverability. But this is a Corps unit, which is like 20.000 men strong and was considered "small army" in the 1800s. But 100 men unit doing independent tactical engagement? how much firepower does it carry tbh?But imagine that whole battalion is a dedicated AT battalion. Good to @chibiyabi he said right now the Army just started composite battalion and cakra battalion. I still can take if the AT battalion put their platoon to other battalion, but isn't that just make the coordination more complicated rather than just one battalion commander has lot of capabilities.
Salah satu rumor :belum tentu T-90nya hancur karena gak terlihat adanya ledakan amunisi melainkan "cuma" sekedar ledakan tanki bahan bakar.
Battalion specialized to fire CG, Ironman battalion. Why not just bigger gun sekalian 105mm to replace your CG anti tank battalion?Well, I simply proposed some battalion capable of having high AT firepower, in the context of combating something similar to what Russia is doing with their armored column (certainly not against GAM).
CMIIW, dari contoh Yon Mandala Yudha sama Gardapati, buat AD yang terhitung 'Komposit' itu kalau ada lebih dari satu kecabangan di Yon yg samasekarang ini konsep dedicated battalion makin di tinggalkan, karena bakal memperpanjang rantai komando, TNI AD sudah mulai merubah doktrin pertempurannya dengan bikin yon komposit, sudah ada yon cakra. dalam pergelarannya yon komposit ini digabung menjadi setingkat brigade tim pertempuran. penyempurnaan dari doktrin yg dimiliki oleh marinir. jadi dengan yon komposit sebenarnya sudah punya kemampuan AT, yg belum itu ya perkuatan unit infanteri, belum punya fire power yg memadai, makanya RPG terus CG banyak diinginkan diakuisisi AD. Sejak dahulu infanteri marinir udah punya kekeuatan daya tembak yg lebih dengan RPGnya, dan jelas keliatan waktu operasi di Aceh dulu, gerak marinir lebih cair karena ga perlu nunggu tembakan bantuan.