• Forum restore complete (see latest announcement thread)

TR Air-Force TF-X KAAN Fighter Jet

boredaf

Experienced member
Messages
2,271
Solutions
1
Reactions
42 6,661
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Our aviation industry has been quick in making many of the products they have made. In the best case scenario P1 can join the Airforce after a few months of bootcamp, I am dreaming.

Imagine P1 P2 and P3 join the force mid 2027, only takes some daredevil topgun pilots to take up the challenge.

If they can get the hardware right from the start they can upgrade while the planes fly in service.
It must be the oxygen deprivation, come back down to earth. Those planes will be making test flight for years to come. Are you seriously incapable of having a single grounded opinion? Why is it always over the top, unrealistic stuff with you?
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,054
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Only the engine is American
Not at all. KF-21 have tens of subsystems sourced from US and other countries. A Turkish user got triggered and made a massive list last year on twitter. I'm sure many of this will be nationalized in time, but many others simply won't be as that requires gutting the aircraft and making a new one. Now, he was few up with some Korean trolls and got triggered badly we should add, but some of the items were a surprise to me as well. It's not just the engine, KF-21 is not being sold to anyone without American approval in either Block 1, 2 or 3. It's like an East Asian Gripen. Kaan's work ahead is much harder, not just because it's supposed to be a larger, more "assertive" fighter but also because honestly aside from the engine and the seat, number of ITAR components in it are very far in between. They are trying to make almost everything in house. Ball is still out which program will be more successful; I'm sure Turkey would also love to not having to make everything in house which increases costs and risks, but it is what it is. KF-21 will never be as "Korean" as Kaan is "Turkish". Again, not a jab, just how things are standing.

 

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
4,280
Reactions
263 22,349
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
If a plane is designed and manufactured by a country, then that country has the right to claim ownership.

Gripen is Swedish.
KF21 is S Korean

They both have many foreign parts used in their construction. But that does not detract from the fact that both are products of the relative countries.

It is not good economics to produce a part yourself when it is easily available to purchase. It takes time and money to indigenise every part.

We have no other choice but indigenise, because the parts we want are not freely sold to us.

But then there are downsides to the Swedish and S Korean route. Engines are US built, ejection seats are UK built. US and UK can block sales of planes to countries they deem not friendly. That is a sale issue. Not an issue of the planes’ ownership.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,654
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
The total number of Kaan prototypes planned keep varying over time. Now it looks like 4-6 excluding the P0 I guess. They tend to finish the job with a smaller number of prototypes as the number was more like 8 before. On the other hand this number may be with the F110 engine alone and the TF35k will need additional prototypes and possibly more than a couple I guess.
 
Last edited:

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,054
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
A plane is a sum of its parts. And a plane has many parts. And many owners (ip).
This have layers. Re US; buying an aircraft from US needs congressional approval; so acceptance of the near entirety of American political system. An aircraft with ITAR components, so an aircraft that's under American export restrictions require US State Dept approval, so an acceptance of the government of the time.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,654
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
This have layers. Re US; buying an aircraft from US needs congressional approval; so acceptance of the near entirety of American political system. An aircraft with ITAR components, so an aircraft that's under American export restrictions require US State Dept approval, so an acceptance of the government of the time.
Things will get a lot more complicated going forward as there is a bill to increase the level of integration between the US and Israel military joint development. Possibly the US will use more and more of Israel made components in the future which will need approval of Israel. This can surely limit the clientele of American made war machines.
 

urban mine

Contributor
Messages
825
Reactions
62 1,745
Nation of residence
South Korea
Nation of origin
South Korea
Isn't this just a rehash of what we talked about last time?

Most of the items listed in that article are already in the process of being localized, so why are we even debating whether they’re “Korean” or “Turkish”? It was actually kind of funny that the list even included details of technologies purchased and support received during development. Do they think Allah or the Hindu gods just directly imparted knowledge into the engineers’ heads in Turkey or India?

Is this a problem for exports? Well, if there were diplomatic issues with Korea, that might be the case, but we’ve never sold to any country where sales are prohibited in the U.S. Even in the case of the widely sold FA-50, there are many instances where foreign components included in the aircraft for overseas sales were replaced with domestically produced ones.

Some people may feel uncomfortable with phrases like “U.S. approval,” but keep in mind that Turkey is, after all, the country with the second-largest fleet of F-16s, right after the United States.

Not at all. KF-21 have tens of subsystems sourced from US and other countries. A Turkish user got triggered and made a massive list last year on twitter. I'm sure many of this will be nationalized in time, but many others simply won't be as that requires gutting the aircraft and making a new one.
But I don't understand what that means. Does that mean there are parts that are completely irreplaceable? Well, when you localize a product, some redesign is naturally involved, but it goes without saying that you design it to meet those specifications to ensure compatibility....
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,054
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey

US to move forward with Turkey jet engine sales ahead of NATO summit, sources say​


"The engines, produced by General Electric, will power ⁠Turkey's first indigenous combat jet Kaan, a major project launched in 2016 as part of NATO member Ankara's efforts to be more self-sufficient in its defense. One of the sources said the package will be worth more than $700 million."

 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,054
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
So, how many engines does this sum of money buy, is it like $7mn each.
More like 15-17 each, especially if it will be a single country order and not a bulk purchase by DoD to GE. Expect 40 engines plus 2-3 spares for the 20 B10 jets.
 

Zafer

Experienced member
Messages
5,654
Reactions
15 8,712
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
More like 15-17 each, especially if it will be a single country order and not a bulk purchase by DoD to GE. Expect 40 engines plus 2-3 spares for the 20 B10 jets.
This would be an opportunistic pricing but we don't need that many anyway. On th flip side the new Kaan engine will fetch quite a bit of money when it is made.
 
Last edited:

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
4,280
Reactions
263 22,349
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
More like 15-17 each, especially if it will be a single country order and not a bulk purchase by DoD to GE. Expect 40 engines plus 2-3 spares for the 20 B10 jets.
For a bulk order of 329 engines for 136 f15EX for the US , GE was given a contract of 1.58billion dollars in 2021. That puts each engine at just under 5 million dollars.


700million dollar contract, at a price of 7 million a piece, should cover 100 engines for 40 jets. Otherwise 14 million dollars a piece for 50 engines to cover 20 jets is like “daylight robbery”. Normal price for these engines is between 6 to 8 million dollars for small runs
 

Afif

Experienced member
Moderator
Bangladesh Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Bangladesh Moderator
Messages
5,139
Reactions
104 10,047
Nation of residence
Bangladesh
Nation of origin
Bangladesh
For a bulk order of 329 engines for 136 f15EX for the US , GE was given a contract of 1.58billion dollars in 2021. That puts each engine at just under 5 million dollars.


700million dollar contract, at a price of 7 million a piece, should cover 100 engines for 40 jets. Otherwise 14 million dollars a piece for 50 engines to cover 20 jets is like “daylight robbery”. Normal price for these engines is between 6 to 8 million dollars for small runs

I mean, Türkiye is paying little over $500 millions per Eurofighter (total package). Comparatively this isn't that big considering it would bring an squadron of homegrown 5th gen fighter into service on time and introduce most significant capability upgrade in TurAF's history.
 

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
4,193
Reactions
127 19,054
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
Reporter: Türkiye wants the F-110 jet engines, and they want their F-35 fighter jets. Are you going to Türkiye with a big gift bag?

Trump: I think so. He's a member of NATO. Some people don't consider himself, but he really is.

He is a strong member of NATO. Yeah, I'm going to probably do something that's going to make him very happy.

And Vance here clarifies the requirements again.
"Pete and the entire team are reviewing this right now, because there are certain things that we have to certify have happened — that have happened in order to comply with American law. The president has asked us to do that.

We're running the traps and confirming that's happened.

This is really a congressional thing, and ensuring that Türkiye has complied with American law so they can get the F-35s. We will announce that when we have-"

He's referring to the NDAA with S400 ownership. If it's going to be finally resolved, it'll probably be resolved this summer.

 
Top Bottom