Indonesia Casual Discussion Warkop Indonesia

norman88

Committed member
Messages
178
Reactions
133
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Gimana kalau pesawat 5th gen disuplai data pesawat lain lewat data link?
Itu akan mematikan sekali situational awareness dapat tapi dianjuga tidak mengorbankan stealthnya.
yap kalau mengandalkan link 16 atau didampingi awacs memang sangat mematikan, tapi itu juga tergantung misi dan lokasi, kalau lokasinya di zona sendiri atau paling tidak di zona netral maka akan efektif tapi kalau lokasinya di zona lawan maka kurang efektif karena awacs sebagai mata tambahan pespur siluman akan mudah dideteksi long range air surveillance radar lawan. Sebenarnya di zona netral pun pespur non siluman masih ada kesempatan menang, tinggal kuat-kuatan datalink.
 
Last edited:

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,761
Reactions
1 2,645
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Gimana kalau pesawat 5th gen disuplai data pesawat lain lewat data link?
Itu akan mematikan sekali situational awareness dapat tapi dianjuga tidak mengorbankan stealthnya.
betul, jaringan berbagai informasi lewat saluran secured dengan perangkat sensor lainnya

Pada saat pesawat siluman menggunakan radar keberadaannya terekspos RWR lawan kan, disitu pesawat non siluman bisa counter balik.
dikira film top gun kah wkwk,
pesawat 5th gen pas beroperasi juga koordinasi dengan sensor lainnya, tentunya dibackup AWACS KJ series
 

norman88

Committed member
Messages
178
Reactions
133
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
conventional radar ? probably ... but one of the hype people going regarding sophisticated AESA radar is exactly this reason, they are harder to recognized by RWR, even PESA is already quite a hassle for RWR.
How about modern EW like spectra or epawss? Is it good enough to detect AESA radar? In military exercises such as a red flags almost every F-35 action in BVR mode use a datalink not radar. Does this indicate the AESA radar is also vulnerable?
 

norman88

Committed member
Messages
178
Reactions
133
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
dikira film top gun kah wkwk,
pesawat 5th gen pas beroperasi juga koordinasi dengan sensor lainnya, tentunya dibackup AWACS KJ series
Artinya pespur siluman gak efektif bekerja sendirian, didampingi AWACS pun kalau di zona lawan kurang efektif.
 

Lordimperator

Experienced member
Indonesia Correspondent
Messages
4,761
Reactions
1 2,645
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Artinya pespur siluman gak efektif bekerja sendirian, didampingi AWACS pun kalau di zona lawan kurang efektif.
F35I SEAD wink wink

ada buku menarik mengulas pesawat gen 5
David Baker (2021); FIFTH GENERATION FIGHTERS
the physics of IRST limit their effect range, their operational effectiveness and the field of view in the presence of suboptimal environmental conditions.

As an example, the Typhoon’s PIRATE system uses long-wave IR to increase acquisition range and attempts to compensate for environmental conditions and mid-wave IR to provide sufficient resolution for detecting and engaging a hostile. But even with this admittedly sophisticated and valuable system, the rear-aspect PIRATE range is around 50 miles (80km) while front aspect range is no better than 30 miles (48km)
keterbatasan jarak deteksi IRST
 
Last edited:

Umigami

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
6,103
Reactions
5 4,938
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
21:22 Sepertinya yg paling efektif ya pespur 4.5 dan 5 ditandem dengan data link yang baik
 

norman88

Committed member
Messages
178
Reactions
133
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
F35I SEAD wink wink

ada buku menarik mengulas pesawat gen 5
David Baker (2021); FIFTH GENERATION FIGHTERS
Misi SEAD gak pake AWACS karena diharuskan presisi dan cepat. Dan ini kan lagi bahas battle air to air pespur bukan misi air to ground kayak SEAD, itupun kalau F-35 berhasil melakukan misi SEAD sudah pasti mengekspos keberadaannya dan lewat datalink bisa dengan mudah pespur non siluman dengan atribut air superiority mengintersep.
 

norman88

Committed member
Messages
178
Reactions
133
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

Soman45

Well-known member
Messages
333
Reactions
641
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia

1693469053821.png

1693469100197.png

1693469152491.png

Kalo diliat MM40 block 2 dan bentuk kapalnya diluncurin dari Bung Tomo class kalo nggak salah beberapa tahun lalu Exocet pernah gagal kan? nah mungkin ini videonya
 

chibiyabi

Contributor
Messages
516
Reactions
3 438
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Togo
Misi SEAD gak pake AWACS karena diharuskan presisi dan cepat. Dan ini kan lagi bahas battle air to air pespur bukan misi air to ground kayak SEAD, itupun kalau F-35 berhasil melakukan misi SEAD sudah pasti mengekspos keberadaannya dan lewat datalink bisa dengan mudah pespur non siluman dengan atribut air superiority mengintersep.
misi tempur pesawat stealth ya ga bisa dilepaskan dari penggunaan AWACS secara efektif, yg mutlak dari pesawat gen 5 ya element of surprisenya itu, dan inget lo ya.. pespur gen 5 juga punya IRST
 

Gary

Experienced member
Messages
8,264
Reactions
22 12,779
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Mengenai pespur gen 4 melawan gen 5 sih ga perlu banyak teori, udah sering dicoba hasil nya tetap sama.

Mau mendekat buat WVR ?

AU Jerman contohnya mengirim EF2000 latma dgn USAF (2012)

Two other German officers, Col. Andreas Pfeiffer and Maj. Marco Gumbrecht, noted in the same report that the F-22’s capabilities are “overwhelming” when it comes to modern, long-range combat as the stealth fighter is designed to engage multiple enemies well-beyond the pilot’s natural field of vision – mostly while the F-22 is still out of the other plane’s range.
Grumbrecht said that even if his planes did everything right, they weren’t able to get within 20 miles of the next-generation jets before being targeted.


Jadi jangan berharap banyak sih ,mengenai F-15EX head to head dengan pesawat VLO sekelas J-20/J-35, bukan kelasnya lagi. Lagipula kalaupun F-15EX "beruntung" bisa sampai merge, J-20 itu TWR nya lebih baik daripada F-15EX dengan mesin WS-15 (160kN+) dan dengan canard, low speed handling nya mungkin jauh lebih baik.
 

this is crunch

Contributor
Messages
657
Reactions
4 633
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Never have i seen this method of shiplaunching from height this high, i wonder when it's impacted to the water will degrade the components and structural strength.
 

Umigami

Experienced member
Moderator
Indonesia Moderator
Messages
6,103
Reactions
5 4,938
Nation of residence
Indonesia
Nation of origin
Indonesia
Mengenai pespur gen 4 melawan gen 5 sih ga perlu banyak teori, udah sering dicoba hasil nya tetap sama.

Mau mendekat buat WVR ?

AU Jerman contohnya mengirim EF2000 latma dgn USAF (2012)

Two other German officers, Col. Andreas Pfeiffer and Maj. Marco Gumbrecht, noted in the same report that the F-22’s capabilities are “overwhelming” when it comes to modern, long-range combat as the stealth fighter is designed to engage multiple enemies well-beyond the pilot’s natural field of vision – mostly while the F-22 is still out of the other plane’s range.
Grumbrecht said that even if his planes did everything right, they weren’t able to get within 20 miles of the next-generation jets before being targeted.


Jadi jangan berharap banyak sih ,mengenai F-15EX head to head dengan pesawat VLO sekelas J-20/J-35, bukan kelasnya lagi. Lagipula kalaupun F-15EX "beruntung" bisa sampai merge, J-20 itu TWR nya lebih baik daripada F-15EX dengan mesin WS-15 (160kN+) dan dengan canard, low speed handling nya mungkin jauh lebih baik.
J20 banyak orang bilang lebih slugish dibidang WVR, sayapnya itu kelihatan kecil kalau dibandingin badannya.

China sama sekali gak mengharap J20 buat dogfight, Gun aja gak punya.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom