TR Air Defence Programs

King_West

Active member
Messages
98
Reactions
2 399
Nation of residence
Belgium
T
I think they need it for themselves,many Ukranian attacks coming in the future.
They indeed needed for themselves to protect from increasing Ukrainian raids. If Russia offers a good price it will be a win-win. Erdogan can claim a good deal, and appease trump.
 

Merzifonlu

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
769
Reactions
27 2,318
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey
I think they need it for themselves,many Ukranian attacks coming in the future.
I doubt they'll want it for themselves. They'll need to convert the export version to its original state. On the other hand, they have a commitment to India, and since they'll be exporting it anyway, they won't need to make any significant changes to the system. If they retrieve the S-400 systems from Türkiye, I think they'll perform a minor overhaul and then sell them to India.
 

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
3,696
Reactions
209 18,877
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
That is a Ukranian defence news site making these allegations. It doesn’t give any indication of the “source” of such news.

Including a similar Turkish site, there are a number of other foreign sites that make the same news too. But none of them give the source of the news.
It looks like someone made the news piece, and everyone followed suit.

Reminds me of “Nasrettin Hoja” the Medieval Ottoman Comedian; who utters a lie at the beginning of the street we was walking on and believes the same lie when he reaches the end of the street and hears it; as it has travelled faster than him.

Can anyone give a credible source that corroborates this news?
 
Last edited:

Iskander

Contributor
Think Tank Analyst
Messages
792
Reactions
15 2,081
Nation of residence
Azerbaijan
Nation of origin
Azerbaijan
That is a Ukranian defence news site making these allegations. It doesn’t give any indication of the “source” of such news.

Including a similar Turkish site, there are a number of other foreign sites that make the same news too. But none of them give the source of the news.
It looks like someone made the news piece, and everyone followed suit.

Reminds me of “Nasrettin Hoja” the Medieval Ottoman Comedian; who utters a lie at the beginning of the street we was walking on and believes the same lie when he reaches the end of the street and hears it; as it has travelled faster than him.

Can anyone give a credible source that corroborates this news?
All Russian websites publishing this information cite the Turkish newspaper Nefes as their source. Nefes cites an unspecified source. This story may be false. But it is interesting. Russia does have serious problems with air defense. The problem is that it has thousands of military installations in its vast territory that need protection from long-range Ukrainian drones. In Crimea, almost all of its air defense systems, including the S-400 and even the “legendary” S-500, seem to be out of action. (All Russian weapons, from Kalashnikovs to T-72s, are legendary :) ) Even with their vast front line, they have a serious shortage, not to mention the thousands of installations, including strategic ones, that need air defense in the rear. The claim that they want to buy S-400s from Turkey and sell them to India is a myth for the truly naive.
 

Radko

Experienced member
Messages
1,510
Reactions
14 2,857
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Bosnia & Herzegovina
All Russian websites publishing this information cite the Turkish newspaper Nefes as their source. Nefes cites an unspecified source. This story may be false. But it is interesting. Russia does have serious problems with air defense. The problem is that it has thousands of military installations in its vast territory that need protection from long-range Ukrainian drones. In Crimea, almost all of its air defense systems, including the S-400 and even the “legendary” S-500, seem to be out of action. (All Russian weapons, from Kalashnikovs to T-72s, are legendary :) ) Even with their vast front line, they have a serious shortage, not to mention the thousands of installations, including strategic ones, that need air defense in the rear. The claim that they want to buy S-400s from Turkey and sell them to India is a myth for the truly naive.
They all got the source as militaryni
 

Saithan

Experienced member
Denmark Correspondent
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
9,414
Reactions
50 21,201
Nation of residence
Denmark
Nation of origin
Turkey
I am not sure Russians will want the S-400 back. I mean that would mean it's capable and can do the job. :)

In other words what we got may be a really crappy thing :) and the reason for not wanting it back is because it's crap.

Joking to a side, looking at Denmark we can see how drones are being used to disrupt infrastructures and such. I have mure trust in TSK capabilities, but is our Law enforcement just as well equipped to track and trace drone operators and such ?

With the rappid growth of AI, I think it becomes important to have semi-autonomous systems developed to handle drone threats. Especially because using drones as fire and forget is getting increasingly easier as the days pass by.

Mini mobile Vans with drone warfare systems with a trailer that has 25mm-35mm hardkill option, or potentially a 40mm with shorter range for same effect.

Or develop a Drone hunter platform that can be deployed rapidly in 1-5 minutes.
 

Strong AI

Experienced member
Messages
2,333
Reactions
53 7,620
Nation of residence
Germany
Nation of origin
Turkey
Last edited:

Sanchez

Experienced member
Moderator
Think Tank Analyst
DefenceHub Diplomat
Messages
3,403
Reactions
104 15,407
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey

boredaf

Experienced member
Messages
1,816
Solutions
1
Reactions
28 5,156
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Not necessarily a good thing, wish we had an idea on range.
I'd say it is, if your target is a low flying anti-ship missile coming at your ship, which seems to be the aim of this test.

Edit: Let's not forget, while they are testing the missile from the VLS system in this video, it is also going to be used in this configuration as point defence as well, with a range of 15 km.


goksur_web_haber_112024.jpg
 
Last edited:

Samba

Committed member
Messages
177
Reactions
2 267
Nation of residence
Turkey
Nation of origin
Turkey

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
3,696
Reactions
209 18,877
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
I'd say it is, if your target is a low flying anti-ship missile coming at your ship, which seems to be the aim of this test.

Edit: Let's not forget, while they are testing the missile from the VLS system in this video, it is also going to be used in this configuration as point defence as well, with a range of 15 km.


goksur_web_haber_112024.jpg
This is great news for our sea platforms.
As you rightfully point out it will also be used as a PDMS with 20 missiles and with an effective range of 15km to replace the RAM missile systems US were so reluctant to supply to us.
Since it is using a missile derived from Bozdogan WVR a2a missile, it is very accurate and should really be effective against supersonic cruise missiles too. If so, tough news to swallow for the across the water neighbours that were contemplating in investing in Indian Brahmos AShMs.

Aselsan has also stated that the missile system can accommodate the longer range Gokdogan BVR a2a missile, making it a longer range and higher altitude PDSM system similar to ESSM of US. I guess the fire control radar will have to be configured to cover the extended range of the Gokdogan.

As it will be using Bozdogan missiles the Goksur fully loaded with 20 missiles will have munitions worth around 8-10 million dollars. So it is not a cheap system.
Should the canisters be filled with Gokdogan the system cost will be in excess of 20 million dollars. Costly! But it will be ours to use and sell as we please.

 

boredaf

Experienced member
Messages
1,816
Solutions
1
Reactions
28 5,156
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
This is great news for our sea platforms.
As you rightfully point out it will also be used as a PDMS with 20 missiles and with an effective range of 15km to replace the RAM missile systems US were so reluctant to supply to us.
Since it is using a missile derived from Bozdogan WVR a2a missile, it is very accurate and should really be effective against supersonic cruise missiles too. If so, tough news to swallow for the across the water neighbours that were contemplating in investing in Indian Brahmos AShMs.

Aselsan has also stated that the missile system can accommodate the longer range Gokdogan BVR a2a missile, making it a longer range and higher altitude PDSM system similar to ESSM of US. I guess the fire control radar will have to be configured to cover the extended range of the Gokdogan.

As it will be using Bozdogan missiles the Goksur fully loaded with 20 missiles will have munitions worth around 8-10 million dollars. So it is not a cheap system.
Should the canisters be filled with Gokdogan the system cost will be in excess of 20 million dollars. Costly! But it will be ours to use and sell as we please.

Well, for cost effectiveness we could try using Roketsan's new Eren loitering munition from ships, if it proves to be precise enough. It should only cost a fraction of either missiles, with enough range and could also loitering for 15 minutes or something. And, we could use them against surface threats as well.
 

Yasar_TR

Experienced member
Staff member
Administrator
Messages
3,696
Reactions
209 18,877
Nation of residence
United Kingdom
Nation of origin
Turkey
Well, for cost effectiveness we could try using Roketsan's new Eren loitering munition from ships, if it proves to be precise enough. It should only cost a fraction of either missiles, with enough range and could also loitering for 15 minutes or something. And, we could use them against surface threats as well.
Eren, as far as I know, is propelled by a jet engine and has a speed of around 550-650km/hour. It could definitely be used against relatively slower cruise missiles and some air platforms like helicopters and UAVs, if as you say, is precise enough. Logically Turbo Jet engine propulsion should be more expensive than solid fuelled rocket propulsion. What makes Bozdogan so expensive is its high quality guidance and seeker system that would enable it to hit very fast and agile targets.
It may be wrong to expect Eren to possess such sensitive seeker head and guidance system as it would be slower. Thus it may well be a cheaper alternative to use against specific price sensitive targets.
 

Follow us on social media

Top Bottom